Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Dyed Maple Bowl

Posts

Dyed Maple Bowl

#1

Dyed Maple Bowl

Thom in Kent,WA

>This is a 4 inch tall by 7 inch diameter bowl made from Silver Leaf Maple. I used alcohol based dye of the color dark mission brown. I used my pyrography burner to embellish the top rim and the base. I also used the woodburner to sign the name. Finish is several coats of Deft lacquer with sanding of 1500 between coats. Critiques welcome of the bowl and then composite photo.


img

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

#2

3 things I like, 3 things I don't

T Daniel

>Boy, does this piece bring back memories!

Things I like; nice color, nice finish, nice rim treatment

Things I don't like:

1) shape...you are meking yourself work too hard. The straight sides make the transition from side to bottom too difficult.

2) you are making the piece fit your chuck instead of making the chuck fit the piece. On a piece of this diameter use a tenon instead of a dovetail pocket or buy a smaller set of jaws so you can reduce the size of the base. You are letting limited equipment dictate your shapes.

3) The straight sides make it difficult to cut across the bottom so that makes leaving a dip in the center of the bottom almost unavoidable. Try leaving the center of the bottom proud about the diameter of a dime and then reomove that with sanding.

All in all it is a very nice bowl and shows you have come a good distance already.

TD

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

#3

Re: 3 things I like, 3 things I don't

Thom in Kent,WA

>Thanks for the comments. The comment about the chuck hit the mark for me. I have other jaws and I do like to use a tenon rather than a pocket. I never thought that the jaws were dictating the bowl, but they do and were. I'll try the dime thing on the inside of the bowl bottom. Getting comments like this are just what I need to get me to thinking about doing things in a new way. Thanks T Daniel.

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

#4

Re: 3 things I like, 3 things I don't

Glenn Hodges

>Thom, I also like what Terry liked. The way the inside goes straight down makes it difficult to sand.

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: 3 things I like, 3 things I don't

Brad Vietje

>I also like the treatment of the recess to disguise it somewhat -- Terry was probably including that under edge treatment. If you develop the habit of reversing bowls between centers as a final turning step, you can get any size/shape foot you want, regardless of the size of the jaws. I often make a small foot that extends down into the tenon, or even turn it all away to leave no foot at all.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

#6

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

Barry Turner

>I think it is a very nice bowl. I love the color. I also agree with the other comments. Generally speaking, straight-sided bowls are just never quite as nice as they should be, considering all of the work they require.

Granted, straight-sided bowls are more difficult to turn and sand, but that's not the most important thing. I was taught that bowls should be one continuous sweeping curve from the rim to the bottom, inside and out. Not only are bowls like this easier to hollow and sand, they are much more pleasing to the eye.

I also agree with the comment about the base. Not so much the chuck driving the bowl's design, just that I think the base is a bit too large for the bowl. I probably would have forgone the base all together and just made a small concave area for the bowl to rest on.

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

#7

Richard Allen

Re: Dyed Maple Bowl

Richard Allen

>Overall I like the bowl. I like the way that you decorated the rim to resolve the "disappearing rim" issue. I like the waste in the vertical side of the bowl. The slight flare on the inside is nice. The frame of burning marks on the underside is a terrific way to show off something on the bottom. That is something I will "steal" from you in the future.

I generally avoid dye. In the long run the dye looks muddy and unnatural. If I want a particular color I would much rather work with a wood that is that color or will become that color in a natural way.

On a bowl with vertical sides like yours, which I have no problem with, is a terrific place to decorate. The decoration can be figure in the wood or something you add in one of the many available ways (burning, coloring, carving, texturing...)

I prefer the rim to slope either in or out. With this bowl shape I would tend toward the sloping out rim. Your rim looks to be flat. When you fill the bowl, a flat rim will leave nothing of the bowl to see ("disappearing rim"). You have made a terrific solution to this issue. You decorated the rim which will maintain a presence of the bowl even when it's filled.

A squat bowl like you have made works well with a large foot. Maybe even a larger foot would work. That leaves a wide open space on the bottom. Framing that space, the way you did with the burring, emphasizes that wide open space. That wide open space should contain something worth looking at. This is terrific for figured woods or some design or artistic work you might add there. Instead you have your signature, and such, smack dab in the middle. You might want to put your signature to the side of this framed "canvas".