Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

Posts

Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#1

Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

Allen Neighbors

>I guess I'm just old enough with thick enough skin, to wonder why anyone would want to ask for critiques, and then get bent out of shape when they get one.

When I put a pic on and ask for critiques, that's what I really want. I don't care how "brutal" you get with me about one of my turnings, but I don't only want to know what's wrong, I want to know what I might do to correct the errors. That's the way I learn. And if I take a hit, maybe it will help someone else that's just a beginner, too. I don't mind.

I am a novice woodturner. I don't want to stay a novice. I am not financially able to travel much, and even then distance is still a factor, so I have never attended a class. The nearest club that I can find is over 100 miles away, and I can't get in touch with anyone at that one to even know if it's still active.

I've learned an awesome amount from reading posts on this forum, and I appreciate you folks so much. I am thrilled that you would take the time to help out newby turners like myself. Each of you have my respect and admiration. I look at your work with admiration and awe... when I grow up, I want to be like you. :o)

Anyway. Thanks a lot for your time and your instructions of the past couple of months. You all are A-one in my mind.

Thanks for listening.

AL

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Al, posts like yours makes all the time spent on this site worthwhile.

You seem to be a secure individual....not all people are. It's easy to get so emotionally attached to our work that it can become difficult to seperate a critique from a personal attack. The critique,in many cases, is viewed as a criticism of the person who turned the piece....as well as the piece itself.

Many turners spend years turning bad forms because they are unwilling to listen to the opinion of respected turners, or even attempt to change their work habits. With an open mind, you will progress rapidly.

There are many here who impress me also..too many to name!

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#3

Thanks Al....

T Daniel

>We didn't plan on doing critiques on entire pieces but things evolve :). We had planned to just show specific details of designs; rim treatments, shadow lines, beads, grooves and such. It is not our aim to hurt anyone's feelings and as long as no one feels unjustly criticized we don't mind doing these critiques. Be aware though that we are also turners who are learning just like yourself. Also, be aware that some things are regional. Things that I do here in Georgia might not be acceptable in New York or Chicago. Likewise things done in New York might not do well here. Personally, my opinions come from what sells here. I see things in the AAW mag that I know would not sell here but apparently they sell in other parts of the country. Use the suggestions that you receive and make up your own mind after trying them. If we help you we help ourselves because elevating this art form to a higher level will help all of us. Of course the flea markets won't have as much merchandise........

TD

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#4

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

David Propst

>Hey Al,

I totally agree with you about critiques, it is one of the best tools we have to make ourselves better turners. There are two problems I have seen with critiques in an open forum like this. The first is that some folks post their turnings and really do not want anything but a complement which is fine, but unfortunate. The second is I have seen posts where someone politely critiques a piece and other posters jump in critizing the person who offered a critique.

I think if someone posts a pic and mentions that "critiques welcome" then they are asking for input and we should all feel free to offer our opinion. I was saddened to see Wally and Russ post that they did not feel comfortable offering critiques here. I am in awe of many of the turners here. There is such a huge wealth of knowledge in this community. It is in all of our best interest to glean as much as we can from each other.

In October I took a weekend class with David Ellsworth at Arrowmont. On Sunday, we spent well over two hours with David critiquing and discussing the work the fourteen of us had brought. This was the most valuable part of the weekend. As a result I have become much more critical of my work and my turning has improved noticably (so my wife says).

Though David gave overall favorable critiques of two of my three pieces, I would no longer have even taken two of them. Throughout that weekend and especially during the critique session concepts that I first learned about in Richard Raffin's "Turned Bowl Design" book kept being referred to. Every new new turner should read it and keep it close by from then on.

Now, if my back will cooperate. I'll be back in the shop in the morning.

Best Regards,

David

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

Keith Tompkins

>Hi David, an important function of the critique is to point out how even subtle changes can dramatically affect the appearance of a turning. As you learned from David's critique, the principles of design are essential to us as wood turners, and by applying them, we can improve the quality of our work without years of trial and error.

I personally don't have a problem doing a critique, but some here do. Perhaps they could critique a piece of thier own work, showing how a piece could be improved. Maybe comparing an old piece to a newer one.That way, no hard feelings.

Even the newest newbie will benefit from the critique and good design ideas.

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#6

Nice to see this type of thread

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>I can remember when folks were rather nervous about whether we should do critiques at all here.I can also remember being one of the folks being confronted after giving a critique.Glad to see that seems to be behind us.

An honest critique by a person who knows how it should be done is a powerful tool for growth.Raffan`s book,Turned Bowl Design is also a great place to start investigating form and design.Still can`t understand why it`s no longer in print.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#7

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

RussFairfield

>I am only speaking for myself here. I will not use an open forum to offer a critique or comments for improvement about the work of someone I don't know and can't see.

The critique we are talking should be an educational event, as opposed to the "Show Critique" at an event like the AAW Symposium. One is for learning something, the other is for recognition.

Personally, I don't see that throwing something out for a "potluck" critique serves any useful educational purpose. There are too often conflicting comments from different people, and that serves to confuse rather than educate. The person who asks for the critique should know and respect the qualifications of whomever they are asking, they should expect to learn something from it, and they should expect that all conversation between them should be confidential. The key word here is "conversation". There is only so much anyone can see from a photograph, and if this critique is to be educational, there has to be a conversation.

If you want my opinion you will have to send me an e-mail or meet me for a private conversation in the Chat Room. Don't expect that to happen on this forum.

I did make comments about some of the work in the Chat Room on Wednesday night, and will probably do it again. That was only because we were in a group that never exceeded 28 people, and the owner of the piece in question was there to answer questions or be a part of the discussion. I am only sorry that there was too much to look at in too little time, and we didn't have the time for a thorough discussion of anything. I always left each piece with the feeling that there was much unsaid, and that makes me wonder if the person was well served by what little we had time to say.

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#8

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I agree that there was far too many pieces in the chat. Hopefully in the future that will change. Quality is better than quanity!

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#9

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

Jim Swank

>I have to disagree with one of your comments, at least in part.

(excerpted) "The person who asks for the critique should know and respect the qualifications of whomever they are asking"

When I get comments or critiques, I examine the piece in light of those comments and see if I can learn something from them. Obviously, comments by someone like David Ellsworth, Wally, TD, yourself, or several others I could name carry more weight than from a total stranger. For me, that simply means I would look closer, a second, third, or even fourth time if I did not immediately see and agree with the comments, where I might dismiss the same comment from an unknown person after a more cursory review.

I expect others who put their work up for critique to see things in a similar light.

Re: Info for Wally, Russ, Other Critique-ers

#10

Design features

T Daniel

>Russ, I think if we limit our discussion to design features we will be ok. Also, we will be much more organized next time and hopefully we will have the full time of the chat to do it and won't have to rush. If we get too many entries I'll ask Ron to weed out some. Last week our comments were basically on general form, design details such as foot size and height, and appropriate finish. I thought all the comments made were sincere and there was no bashing. We'll try this until we get it right!

TD