Re: diagonal/cross section views of platters
RussFairfield
>I think that everyone is trying to make this too difficult.
The only thing that is important about the plate or platter is the wood grain, or any decoration that you put on it. Everything is visible, and there is no better way to show off a piece of wood.
After that there are only 3 choices - basic shape, rim and foot. The basic shape can be flat or dished like a shallow bowl. It can have a foot or no foot, a small foot like a bowl, or a wide foot like a dinner plate. It can have a rim or no rim, a narrow rim, or a wide rim. I have never seen any combination of these features that didn't look good on a plate or platter.
There is one other choice that has nothing to do with shape, and that is "thickness". I see there being only 2 choices, one that is obviously "art", and the other that is obviously "useable". One is paper thin to prove you can do it and impress anyone who picks it up, woodturner or not. The reaction you are after is, "WOW, this can't be wood!" That reaction sells plates and platters as "art". The other choice is thick because that means heavy, stable, and "useable"; and there a lot of people who prefer that.