Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

Posts

The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#1

The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

RussFairfield

>The Rule os 1/3 was used several times in last nights discussion, and there have been several people have asked about it here this morning.

You need go no farther than right here at Wood Central. Follow the link to a discussion of this and other rules.


Some Rules For Good Design

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#2

The Role of the Rule

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>I can understand the pricipal of the "Rule of the 1/3." However, it seems to me (an untrained newbie) that if this is followed exclusively, all pieces would start looking alike, as far as shape and dimensions are concerned, once the diameter size is decided.

There was a previous post w/pic showing a vase, and one of the comments was that it looked "pear shaped." It obviously did not conform to the rule. But I thought it was a well thought out design and was appealing to the eye.

I understand the use of formulas in design, but I think there should be plenty of room for "free-form" design.

Maybe I am missing a point. I am struggling with trying to make pieces that are not only pleasing to me, but can pass muster when I put up a post.

Comments more than welcome!!

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#3

Re: The Role of the Rule

Raymond Overman in SC

>I'm not a design expert by any means and have my own design demons to contend with but you'll find the rule of 1/3 does apply in a sense when looking at a pleasing pear shape. The top portion of the pear's curve is going to be ~1/3 the length of the bulged bottom. It will also be ~1/3 the diameter of the bulged bottom.

Thus, the squatty and knotty pears that came off of my Nana's old pear tree weren't pretty in a bowl even though they were great when cooked with a little sugar. The golden mean, golden rectangle, fibonacci sequence, and other such design fundamentals are often found in nature.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#4

Re:George- you aren't allowed...

JamieDonaldson

>... to break the Laws of Art/Design until you have mastered them, and after that you may break them as you please! That's why they invented Grad. School- you learn THE RULES as an Undergrad, and how to justify breaking THEM in an MFA program!

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#5

Re:George- you aren't allowed...

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>Jamie:

Very good point. I did not mean to imply that the rule (and others like it) was not valid. Of course, when one is learning, the fundamentals come first. I can't believe how much sawdust I've made tryig to get consistent curves and shapes, and getting bowls to look like bowls.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#6

Re:George- you aren't allowed...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Yes, rules are made to be broken. A form that I use a lot in hollow vessels, can be the same width and be 4 inches tall, 6 inches tall, 8 inches tall and still be the same good form. The key is proportions and balance. The form can have all kinds of adornments and still be the same basic form

I think that until the turner really understands form and design the two most important "rules" to NOT be broken are that the foot should be 1/3 the diameter of the vessel, and that curves should flow uninterupted, without flat spots.

Wally


img

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#7

I agree totally

TDaniel

>

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#8

Re:George- you aren't allowed...

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>Wally:

This discussion is giving me better insight into what others are thinking. That's kinda why I asked the questions in the first place. You are absolutely correct about the importance of getting flowing curves without flat spots. A lot harder to do than say! As someone previously said, once I get down the basics, then I can start fooling around with more advanced designs.....

Thanks to all for the input.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#9

Re: The Role of the Rule

John Lucas

>You can use the rule of thirds in a lot of different ways, not just height vs width etc. For example Mass and volume. The pear is a good example the bottom looks 2/3's heavier than the top even the the shapes might not be exactly the golden mean or the 1/3 rule. Color also affects mass. I forgot who's piece is was that I saw the other day but it had a very light color on the top and darker on the bottom. This strongly affects the feeling of weight and balance and believe Wally said something about balance also being important. What I'm trying to say is there are a lot of factors other than just the rule of thirds.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#10

Re: The Rule of the 1/3

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>So, if I have some 10" x 10" 12/4 stock, I cannot make one bowl without violating the "Rule of Three" and it will never look good? Should I just glue up two blanks to have a 6 inch piece so it will look good? Am I doomed?

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#11

Re: The Rule of the 1/3

John Lucas

>Just call it a platter then the rules don't apply anymore :):)

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#12

Re: The Rule of the 1/3

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Rules are made to be broken. You can turn a lovely bowl 10 x 4 inches. Just turn a short foot with a nice sweeping curve to the rim. It'll look great. There's another way to use the 3 in. depth. Just use a contrasting wood segmented around the rim to add depth. Makes a handsome piece. I'll repeat a pic that I posted a few days ago to illustrate.

Wally


img

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#13

Re: The Rule of the 1/3

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Correction: I should have said 10 x 3 inches.

Wally

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re:George- you aren't allowed...

Keith Tompkins

>George, if you study the pieces you aren't happy with, you will most likely discover that they violate the 1/3 rule. If you start applying the rule to your work, you should notice an improvement. TNEN, when you can create good forms on a consistant basis, you can bend, twist, cut and fold the rules with a good understanding of what's really happening when you do.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#15

Re: The Rule of the 1/3

Carole Valentine

>Well, Doug, if that's true then I am in trouble with one of my exchange pieces! It was made from a 10"x10"x2" (and it ain't a platter!) LOL Too bad though...it's already shipped.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Rule of the 1/3

Keith Tompkins

>Wally, there are other factors besides things such as rectangles, ratios, etc. this piece displays another, completely different approach.

What you are creating in your forms, and in this bowl is a catenary.Imagine holding a length of fine chain by each end...No matter how far you hold your hands apart, the resulting curve of the hanging chain is as smooth and flowing as can be. Gravity pulls evenly on the whole affair. Basing your work on this effect allows you to seemingly violate all sorts of rules, yet produce stunning pieces.

I bet if you held such a chain over the bowl pictured in this post, it would touch from the rim to the center without any air gaps.. I posted a thread a while back titled the "Tompkins Triangle" method of bowl design. That's exactly what my triangle method mimics...a catenary effect.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#17

Russ, The 10" bowl can also be 3 1/3" high

Guy in Cuba

>Many of the art and photography sites also discuss the rule of three, and although Russ indicates that a 10" diameter bowl should be about 6 2/3" high (2/3 of 10"), the rule could also be used to indicate that the height of the bowl could be 1/3 of 10" or about 3 1/3" high.

Re: The Rule of the 1/3 *LINK*

#18

Height can be fudged on

TDaniel

>IMHO a 10" block could be turned into a plate or a bowl. Up to 1.5" I would make it into a plate, above that I would make it into a shallow bowl (or collection plate). Up to 6" tall will work. Then comes the awkard area: at 6" your eye cannot determine if the piece is a bowl or a vase. Then at about 10" high your eye sees a vase. Anything taller is a vase. This area between 6" high and 10" high is the height I would try to avoid generally, though you can violate this rule with certain pieces of wood and get away with it. I generally think of the thirds rule as applying to diameter ratio of the rim (or max diameter of the body) to the base. Many of Wally's pieces violate the height rule with no adverse problems.

TD