Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

Posts

Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#1

Roger Dunn

Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

Roger Dunn

>I stumbled into a "Lumbermen's Home Center" in Fife looking for denatured alcohol expecting to pay between $11 and $14 per gallon. They didn't have DNA but the salesman showed me a good alternative. It is a product labelled "Shellac Thinner Solvent Alcohol" - 'use in place of denatured alcohol' and 'water miscible'. The label indicates it contains Methanol. It is manufactured by Recochem from Canada and the price was only $7.99 per gallon. It may be the product that Canadian turners have commented on as what they use north of the border. I'm going to try mixing it with DNA for drying bowls and thanks again Dave Smith.

Roger Dunn

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#2

It is methanol, that is why it is cheaper.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Roger,

I have been meaning to ask your permission to post the pictures and comments you sent me over a year ago. I am pretty sure you said I could post them but want to make sure.

About the alcohol. I don't like the potential health hazards of using methanol. While it is not as dangerous as cyanide it can have serious acute and accumulative effects. I have always wondered how it can readily be use as a shellac solvent. People are aware of the non toxic qualities of shellac after it is cured so they think applying it is also safe. Applying it without gloves. Breathing the vapors as it dries. All the time thinking they are using a safe finish. Do you get my drift or should I snow harder?

A few months ago someone posted the fact that a leading brand of denatured alcohol(DNA) was mostly methanol. I thought he was wrong so I rechecked the MSDS and found that the information on the can and in the MSDS were misleading. Half of the product is ethanol denatured with 5% methanol and the other half is methanol. In simple terms the product is 55% methanol. I read the first part thinking it referred to the entire mixture but on closer review realized the clever way it was worded. Remember that if the percentage of ingredients is not listed they are supposed to be listed starting with largest. The label states it contains ethanol denatured with methanol. However the ingredient list starts with methanol followed by ethanol. Mea culpa.

Since than I have been trying to research the different formulas of brands available on the consumer market. I want to make a list of brand names with their actual composition to make it easier for a person to figure out what they are using. So far I have found 3 products that are about 90% ethanol; True Value , Sunnyside and Parks. If anyone knows of more products please email me their names so I can add them to the list which I will post on line.

Methanol will work just find for the alcohol drying process. However, if you do use it be sure to protect your self when handling it and while the pieces are drying.

Now that a lot of people think I am an alarmist I'll go back to my computer problem.

Dave Smith

The more I know the safer I can be in Longview, WA.

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#3

Thanks

Tony Shaftel

>I recall posting about the stuff I got at the Borg being mostly methanol. I was disappointed, yet somehow unsurprised, that a product so easy to provide in a safer form (denatured ethanol) has been replaced in much of the retail market by a relatively unsafe product (55% methanol). Very sad.

Thanks very much for identifying safer brands.

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#4

Another Question Dave

Raymond Overman in SC

>This may have been covered but I can't find a combination of search terms that gives me the answer. How do you dispose of your used DNA?

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#5

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

RussFairfield

>Now you know why I go down to the State Store and buy Everclear for mixing shellac. Certified as being 95% pure grain alcohol by the US Government, and that other 5% is water. My shellac is 100% safe for drinking.

Now you know the meaning of "getting shellaced".

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#6

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

Raymond Overman in SC

>I guess that solves the disposal problem too.

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#7

But

Bill Howatt

>it creates the "I have no alcohol for my shellac" problem.

Bill

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#8

Re: It is methanol, that is why it is cheaper.

Vicmarc.fan

>Dave,

If you have time I have a question. You say in the article in More Woodturning that you have a lathe that limits you to 12". On December 12,2005 I cored out four pieces of green Sycamore. I cut about 3" away to get rid of the pith down the center first. I left 1" on the largest blank which was about 18" and 3/4" on each of the smaller ones. I put all the blanks in a large plastic bag overnight with 5 gal. alcohol. All the blanks were fine except the ones over about 16". All of them had cracks. My question is, have you had any feedback on pieces cracking that are over the 12" dia.? Seems funny each one cracked on me.

Ron

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#9

I hear there's a lot of crystal meth up there!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#10

I think he "flushes" it...;)

DWR

>

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#11

Re: Don't Add Barr's S-L-X

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>to your list of "safe" dna. It's only 45-50% ethanol, rest is 50% Meth, and up to 5% methyl [whatever] ketone.

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#12

I don't have an explanation.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Ron,

My friend Roger Dunn has turned some large pieces with success. The exception is madrona which has caused him considerable problems. I haven't heard form Roger about recent exploits with madrona. My problems with madrona were solved by making the walls thinner and making sure the soaking solution had a high concentration of alcohol.

I know there are several people who have turned large pieces and dried them with the alcohol process and experienced no problems.

Good luck.

Dave Smith

Getting beat up by my computer in Longview, WA.

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#13

Re: I don't have an explanation.

Ed Karch

>Dave I have alke dunked four bowls in the 16-20" range of red and silver maple with no cracks.

Re: Alcohol alternative in Western Washington

#14

Roger Dunn

Go ahead Dave. No worries.

Roger Dunn

>