Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

Posts

Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#1

Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

Jeremy

>Hello All,

I just bought the DES gouge; right out of the box it was fantastic to turn with but now I need to start to consider sharpening. Do you need the DEjig or can you get the 'correct' grind with any system (i.e., wolverine)?

I am still learning about the correct sharpening/grind angles for turning tools. I have come across people talking about a fingernail grind and a side grind. At times, it appears that these are two different types of grind but I thought they were the same. Are they the same type of grind or am I missunderstanding something?

jeremy

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#2

Ellis Walentine

Here's David's reply

Ellis Walentine

>Jeremy, I called David and he was kind enough to answer your question himself:

Hi Jeremy...The side grind you will get from the Wolverine system will give you a steeper angle on the bevel than I like to work with, that is, it's too steep which makes the edge so fragile that I find it difficult to control in the wood: it grabs alot!

My jig is specifically designed to give the proper angle for both control and durability throughout the five primary cuts the gouge is designed to perform. The good news is that you can use my jig in the Wolverine sliding arm, as directions come with the jig for this purpose,,,or you can purchase a special sliding arm from Vertical Solutions that replaces the Wolverine sliding arm and gives a perfectly shaped bevel on the tool.

Hope this helps and have fun with the gouge!

David

�VERTICAL SOLUTION�

[sharpening aid for Ellsworth sharpening jig]

Don Geiger

2606 NW170th St.

Newberry, FL 32669

352-472-5035

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#3

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

James McClure

>IMHO - You can get pretty close (which is close enough) with either the Wolverene or Tormek jigs. I would suggest using the Sharpie method where you color the bevel with a Sharpie marker and match up the gouge to the stone by rotating the stone by hand against the tool until you can take off the ink. The Tormek jig has numbers and I use mine on jig setting number 4 with the tool protruding 2 1/2 inches. The Wolverene jig doesn't have numbers, but I set it to about a 40 degree angle with the tool protruding 2 inches. Hope this helps.

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#4

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

Chris K in MD

>Not that I want to say that david doesnt know his tools etc after all i am only a young padawan in the turning area where is David is master yoda. However I bought a new DES gouge and found that I can get pretty close with my wolverine jig. Its worked for me.

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#5

It's only geometry...

TDaniel

>I can set my Wolverine or Sorby to match any angle that can be put on a gouge by any other jig. These jigs only give a nose angle and a side angle; everything else is done by eye. If I know what I want the end result to look like I can get it with any adjustable jig. The fixed adjustment jig does not perform any magic. It is still hand/eye coordination.

TD

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#6

Re: It's only geometry...

John Lucas

>If I'm correct all you need to do to match the Ellsworth jig with the Wolverine is extend the arm a little so it's longer and then find the angle that works on the wolverine. I haven't played with David's jig in a while because I made my own but If i remember correctly the arm length was the major difference between the two.

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#7

Re: It's only geometry...

Ed Moore

>There are only two points that matter in this geometric discussion and they determine an axis of rotation. They are the pivot point of the jig and the tip of the tool. By adjusting the angle of the jig, say on the Vari-Grind, you are affecting the angle of the tool relative to the axis of rotation.

Suppose you put a correctly ground DES in an Ellsworth jig and determine the angle between the line between the tip and the base point of the jig and the bevel on the tip of the tool. Suppose it is angle A. Then put that same tool in a Vari-Grind jig and adjust the jig angle so that the angle between the tip and the base point of the jig and the bevel on the tip of the tool is the same as angle A. Now put the tool in the jig into the Wolverine system and adjust the arm distance so that the tip of the tool is tangent to the wheel of the grinder. If you rotate the tool in the pivot and you have correctly duplicated angle A, then the bevel should remain tangent as the tool is moved.

Of course I am assuming that the grinder wheel diameters are the same for both systems.

Ed

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#8

What I did NOT say...

Ed Moore

>Please note that I did NOT say to duplicate the jig angle of an Ellsworth jig on the Vari-Grind jig. To do so will NOT produce the geometry that I referred to and it will not duplicate the grinds.

The numbers that one uses to put the Ellsworth jig in the proper place simply serve to produce the correct bevel angle of the tip. The correct placement of the tool into the Ellsworth jig and the fixed angle of the jig determine the "angle A" that I referred to in my post above.

Ed

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#10

Re: What I did NOT say...

ken chase

>Does that mean using the varigrind jig I am not truly duplicating the Ellsworth grind? If so, would you recommend getting his jig or is there an easy way to adjust the way I am not using the vari grind jig?

Thanks

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#11

For clarity

Ed Moore

>Here's a picture I just took to illustrate what I am saying about angle A. In my case, I seem to be using an angle of 24.1 degrees. I am not making a recommendation here, just reporting what I use in this case.

I wonder what the appropriate angle A is with the Ellsworth jig. Hmmm?

Anyone?

Ed


img

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#12

Re: What I did NOT say...

Ed Moore

>Ken, I do not know what the appropriate "angle A" is for an Ellsworth jig. Go back and check my post above with the picture if you do not understand me. As a mathematician I claim that the grind can be duplicated with a Vari-Grind jig. But I claim further that it is done by duplicating the angle A I refer to and not by duplicating the angle of the Ellsworth jig, which refers to the angle between the tool shaft and the pivot arm.

If you took a DES gouge and ground it according to specs in an Ellsworth jig and then placed it on the piece of paper in my picture with the tip of the pivot arm where I have an "X", moved the tip of the tool so that it touched the black centerline, then the bevel would probably determine a line that is not parallel to the magenta line because my "angle A" is different from the Ellsworth "angle A". If mine was the same as the latter angle, then the magenta lines would be parallel.

Ed

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#13

Possible correction

Ed Moore

>In the picture the angle between the tool shaft and the black centerline would be the same for a correctly ground DES gouge in an Ellsworth jig and the same tool in a Vari-Grind jig with the angle adjusted to duplicate the same grind. The resulting magenta lines would be parallel.

Please note however that the Wolverine jig, which supports the Vari-Grind jig must be moved in or out so that the bevel is tangent to the wheel. The position would be different for the two set-ups.

Ed

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#14

Re: vertical solutions link

Vicmarc.fan

>In a past issue of MORE WOODTURNING mag. One of the Tormec people sent this info to repro. the DE gouge grind. Make something to give a 3" overhang for the gouge on the multi-jig, make a block 2.05" wide to set the tool rest to wheel distance and set the jig to one more division after 5(the late one marked). I don't own a DE gouge so a friend let me use his new one to check this out. I put waterproof marker on the bevel and ran the wheel by hand. Worked fine. I can see though when I put my gouge in the jig to make an DE out of it no system is foolproof. There is more "meat" on the wings than on the nose so it is easy to get the thing too pointy if you aren't careful. I don't see why you couldn't use the marker thing on the Oneway jig. Adjust the long arm out till the wheel removes the marker on the nose, then swing the jig to the side and adjust the angle to take off the marker on the wings. This would give you where you needed to set up for the grind.

Ron

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#15

Re: For clarity

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I believe that David uses 65 degrees. I've settled on 60 degrees on my own gouges.

It's interesting to note the difference in nose angles that some of the "name" turners use. For instance Stuart Batty uses a 40 degree angle on his gouges. Ray Key once said that he uses 75 degrees.

Wally

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#16

much to do about little

TDaniel

>There is nothing critical about the jigs, use whichever you have or can get. They will all give you what you need to make good shavings. There is no magic involved. The nose angle really only affects where your tool handle is: a steeper grind will cause you to have to lift your tool handle a little higher. The most important part of the grind is the side angle and keeping the nose round. Keeping the nose round is not done by the jig, it is done by hand/eye coordination. Another thing that is important but is not done by the jig is keeping the top cutting edge convex....not concave. Again, this is not done by the jig; it is partially dictated by the shape and depth of the flute and the rest is hand/eye coordination. Let's not let anyone try to tell us that one jig is better than the others.....they all do the same thing.

That's my story and I'm stickin' to it!

TD

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#17

Re: For clarity

Ed Moore

>Wally,

I just calculated the angle between the tool shaft and the bevel and it is exactly 60 degrees. Now if I had tried to hit 60 degrees I probably could not have done it, but there it was. So, I am pleased to be in accord with your choice.

Ed

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#18

Re: much to do about little

Ed Moore

>TD,

At no point have I recommended either jig. The question was asked if the Vari-Grind jig can duplicate the Ellsworth grind. I have gone to some effort to give a cogent explanation of why it can duplicate it because an apparent newbie asked us. He can make his own choice based on an informed answer rather than blather. So what's your beef?

Ed

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#19

Re: It's only geometry...

Barry Turner

>I have the Crown PM with the Ellsworth grind. I've found I can duplicate the factory grind pretty dang closely by setting the vari-grind jig on the third notch and allowing the gouge to protrude 2 1/2" from the jig.

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#20

Re: What I did NOT say...

Barry Turner

>I'd say you can get so close you won't be able to tell the difference......of course, we could say only David Ellsworth can duplicate the Ellsworth Grind........:-)

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#21

no beef at all Ed

TDaniel

>Ed, I am on your side in this. What I meant was back up at the top of this thread where one person said that one jig would not do the same thing as another. There isn't enough difference in any of them for anyone to worry. Your mathematical calculations illustrate what I think perfectly. Again, anyone should use or buy whichever jig that they can get a deal on, they all do the same thing, not exactly, but certainly close enough for any difference to be so little that it has no real meaning. I have the Sorby on my Tormek and the Wolverine on my 8" grinder; I can take a tool from one grinder to the other with very little difference in the profile. I can also take a tool sharpened on the DE jig and I can set my Sorby or Wolverine to match it, again, not exactly, but close enough that most users could not tell the difference.

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: much to do about little

Keith Tompkins

>TD, when ground as you describe, with the wings seeming to curve inward, the gouge also makes a helluva end grain hollowing tool. The other way, straight sides, is disasterous when used that way.

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#23

Exactly!

TDaniel

>Through trial and error I found that I could grind my gouge to do all cuts. My grind that is pictured in the grinds library will do a complete bowl, from rough out to final finish cuts, outside and inside. I keep emphasizing the importance of hand/eye coordination in obtaining this grind; there is a reason for this emphasis: when I got my first "profile jig" I expected it to give me the fingernail profile. I quickly learned that it would not do this. These devices assist us in getting the grind we want, they give us a starting angle and an ending angle but that is all they do. If you know the profile you want these jigs are a tremendous asset in obtaining that profile but you must have a target shape in mind before starting. Much more important is the shape of the flute. Some flute shapes are very difficult to sharpen with any jig. I think maybe some that have posted are confusing the two. For those contemplating buying a jig I say again, any of them will do the job. Whichever you buy will need set up and adjusted and you will have to know what you want the gouge to look like when you are finished sharpening it for the jig to work.

Re: Ellsworth Signature Gouge grind

#24

Re: For clarity, Wally, T.D.,

W.C. Turner

>DE says between 55�, and 65�, but, he says he also settled on 60�, as "middle of the road".

T.D.: Too bad you didn't tell us all this before now.