We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>This is a chunk of Mesquite that I didn't want to burn. It was barely over 5" diameter, and I could have turned a goblet, but I opted for something I'd never tried before. I cut the ends at a slant, but parallel, and mounted it between centers, but off centered. Make sense? ...so the vase would be turned off axis from the pith... that's the best I can explain it.
Anyway. This vase is 9 1/2 inches tall. It's big mouth/spout thing is 5 1/4 inches across. The bottom is 3 1/4 dia. The foot is 2 3/4 inches. The foot isn't flat, though it appears to be in my lousy photo.
Proportions looked so bad to me, that I was going to put it in my stove. But something made me finish it, and my wife saw it. She liked it. Showed it to some of her friends, and they liked it, too. I know the proportions aren't kosher with givens, but...
Take your shots. I need opinions of other turners. Thanks, AL
>Honest critique? The vase shape is good. I don't really like the proportion of the foot to the vase body. I feel that the stem/foot looks squatty. My $0.02. Beautiful piece of wood.
My reaction is that the lifting base doesn't work with the rest of the form. The body might be better served to be more 'pear shaped' and wider than the rim with no lifting foot.
I think it's pretty, and if your wife and neighbor like it too then you must have done quite a few things right ! The bark edge looks very well done.
I come from the position of one who makes quite a few natural-edge vases, often turned right on the pith -- which really screws with the critics, 'cuz we're not supposed to do that, right ? However, you probably can get away with turning on the pith more easily with Mesquite than almost any other wood, so I recommend more experimentation.
As for the angled bark edge -- usually for the best visual effect a natural edge needs to be either even and balanced, or off far enough that the slant is clearly intentional -- you've certainly done the latter, and its clear that the angle is what you intended. With Mesquite you ought to be able to turn right on the pith if you're careful to keep everything thin and uniformly so (including the foot). Thus, if you desired to do so, you could have an angled top and the symmetry that comes from turning on the pith. With most other woods this is real tricky and chancy, but Mesquite is so stable you should be able to pull it off.
I'd say make a series and change some of the demensions, maybe a thinner "waist" or neck, and explore what you like best -- you're off to a great start with a pretty piece !
>I really do appreciate all the comments. I've thought the same things I've been told, but I guess I needed to hear it from other turners. All these comments make me think that if you're gonna deter from what's normal and in good form, you need to do so very radically. But I really think that what I should do first is try to get consistant with good form. It took me forever to mess this thing up. :o)
I wish one of you pros lived close enough to give me some one on one advice. I'm going to have to spring for a class, sometime. Better sooner than later, but I didn't make it to my first million, like I had planned, before I retired. Bless all of you for helping out the old man.