Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Wally, critique from thread below

Posts

Wally, critique from thread below

#1

Wally, critique from thread below

Ken DeMarco

>Wally,

Here is the picture of a hollow form I did a while ago, cherry turned wet and allowed to warp, I really like the shape it took and the feel of the grain and the ripple it has where there is curl. the biggest problems I had where the discoloration of the sap wood and gitting the base just right after turning it around. ( i used a jam chuck. it is 6" tall 6" wide 3/4" opening base 1 1/2" Sanded to 800 grit, dried for a month then hand sanded with 6 and 800 grit finished with 5 coats watco then buffed with beal system I look foward to hearing your comments, and like I said I am looking for an honest critique. any questions let me know.

Thanks

Ken Demarco

ps if anyone else would like to chime in thats OK by me, this started in the thread about critiques below


img

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#2

Brad Vietje

Fabulous, Ken

Brad Vietje

>Ken,

That's a real beauty -- please do tell more about your trouble with the sapwood -- it looks stunning just the way it is. From one hollow form turner to another -- that's beautiful work.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#3

one more

Ken DeMarco

>here are two veiws of another I am currently working on, no finish yet maple 5" by 2 1/4" base is 2" and opening is 5/8", I'm not as sure about this shape, seems to lack something maybe? the opening has a slight recess to it, my wife, who has only seen my turnings thought it would be better if I curved the opening inward (kind of like Ellsworth) Thought it was interesting she came up with that. Let me know what you think

Thanks

Ken DeMarco


img

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#4

Re: one more, different view

Ken DeMarco

>Here is shot more from the top, yes I am working on better pictures and will be building a photo tent this weekend ( questions for Mr. Lucas to surely follow ;^)

Thanks

Ken DeMarco


img

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#5

Okay, Here's What I Suggest...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Hi Ken....It's a little difficult to discuss a photo when I can't see it at the moment.

First, I think that it's a very attractive, well done piece. I like the way the color changes, the light color on top that darkens as I look from top to bottom. The curve seems very good except that it appears to flatten out near the rim. It does at the foot also, but that's not as important as the rim. The piece has nice color but not much figure. Partly because of this, I suggest the rim be the focal point by accenting it in some way. A single black line, burned in about 1/2-inch from the rim would do a lot I think. Or 3 very fine grooves close to the rim. Some will suggest a collar of contrasting color. That might work but I think that I like this one without. Instead a turned design in the wood, shaped like most collars, with a small fillet, then a tight upward curve that appears to be a continuation of the curve in the vessel.

What do you think so far?

Wally

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#6

The Second Piece...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I think that you're right. There is something in the form that isn't quite right. The widest part of a hollow form should be either above or below center. This one appears to be almost on-center. Some turners use the rule of thirds, and that's usually okay, but not always. It depends on the individual piece. One very good way to inspect a form is to look at it upside down. If it doesn't look right that way, then it probably isn't. Good form is good form, no matter how you look at it.

The piece appears to sit flat with no foot to give it lift. That's a very important part of good form. Seems to give it life. Since it's a fairly plain piece of wood, you might think about applying my comments on the rim in the taller vessel.

Wally

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#7

Both great

Ed Karch

>Since you invited chime in, I will. Wally has covered every thing that caught my eye. I like his suggestions. I can see a very slight reverse curve on the neck of the cherry. This could be a stronger ogee and that would help around the neck. I like the way you centered the sapwood, this gives a nice balance to the piece. Ditto Wally on the maple piece.

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: one more

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ken, I will comment on the second piece you posted. The image reminded me of bread dough as it is rising. The base appears to be compressing into the table from the weight. I think visually, the piece should appear to be rising from the surface, not being drawn into it. A smaller foot with a smooth, flowing curve upward would help.(compare this piece with the first you posted) Wally noted, the emphasis point is just about on center...and doesn't generate much excitement. Your pieces have a lot going for them, these are small details that would really make the overall form "POP!"

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#9

Re: Okay, Here's What I Suggest...

Ken DeMarco

>Thanks Wally,

So far, exactly what I am looking for. After reading this I took a while to look at it and think about what you said. I don't think I noticed the flating out of the curves too much especially towards the foot, untill I turned it upside down, becomes very obvious there. I think I understand about the rim, perhaps more like the pic below, but with even a more pronounced reverse curve? On the maple piece, i was thinking of adding a contrasting collar, but don't think that will make this one, I was trying for the center of the curve centered on this one, but dont think I like it too much on this one. (not that I won't try it again) The cherry is still one of my favorites, but I know there are always ways to improve, I hope you could tell my big influence on this (that would be you :^)). This is fun! thanks for your comments, I hope others are getting something out of this also.

Ken DeMarco


img

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#10

Re: Okay, Here's What I Suggest...

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Ken,

It looks to me like you have your camera set on daylight. Could you try setting it on tungsten?

Gary

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#11

Re:Now, my photo 2 cents....

JamieDonaldson

>... worth. The color setting has already been mentioned, and exposure setting of +1 if your camera allows, would give better rendering of the subject. Check the viewfinder so that the subject is centered without edges of backdrop showing.

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#12

Re:Now, my photo 2 cents....

Ken DeMarco

>Wow, Thanks Jamie and Gary, just retook the pics, amazing difference

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#13

Re: one more

Ken DeMarco

>Thanks Keith!

I really appreciate the comments. and the way you put it gave me chuckle.

Thanks,

Ken DeMarco

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#14

Re:Now, my photo 2 cents....

John Lucas

>Ken Good job on the work. I like Wally's suggestions. Jamie's suggestion of using the Plus 1 setting will be good sometimes especially if you use a white background but with digital you have to be careful with that because it's kind of like shooting slide film overexposure hurts and can't be saved by software. That being said when shooting on a white background you camera will often underexpose the scene and +1 will help. I suggest bracketing by purposely overexposing and underexposing. Then it's pretty easy to pick the best one when you get to the computer. Digital isn't like film, it doesn't cost anything to bracket and you can just throw away the bad ones.

It's already been suggested that you should use the tungsten setting with those lights.

Change your light positions. You'll notice the headlights in the first photo. Take one light and put it up higher. You didn't say if you were using a translucent booth like I teach or a reflective (opaque) booth like Jamie teaches. Usually I start with one light up about 45 degrees to the left and 45 or so toward the front making sure it still shines through the fabric. The second light should be dimmer than the first, in your case they are both the same power, thus the headlight look. Move the second light further away or if you can't do that mask off part of the light (use flame proof material) or simply aim the light less directly at the piece. The second light should simply fill in the shadows from the first light and consequently needs to be considerably less powerful. Your vessel will appear more rounded if you do this. We only have one sun so ideally you need only one highlight and one shadow. Sometimes this is difficult to do by try to minimize them.

Re: Wally, critique from thread below

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: one more

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Ken, my wife spent many years as a baker...I've seen lots of bread dough! Nice work, Keith