Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Does anyone know this wood?

Posts

Does anyone know this wood?

#1

Does anyone know this wood?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I gathered this a few weeks ago and just started cutting it up to take to FL.

I managed to recover some twigs with buds, chased through a couple of different I.D. keys, and am convinced that this is elm. I'd just like to know which one. The pictures of buds and twigs lead me to believe that it is Slippery Elm, but the one book I have that shows bark pictures contradicts that conclusion.

I appreciated the help,

Gary


img

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#2

Re: Does anyone know this wood? Pic 2 

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>


img

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#3

Re: Does anyone know this wood? Pic 3

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#4

It helps if you actually post the picture. 

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>


img

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#5

Could be elm...

David Propst

>Hey Gary,

It looks like elm to me, but the only elm I have ever encountered I brought back from Sophie's.

It sure does make me want to do this to it! (see below). Make it an add-on to that last e-mail!

David


img

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#6

Re: Could be elm...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi David,

That is a good idea. I was planning on following up on your e-mail, anyway, when the time comes.

While I've got you on the line, what is the penalty for not delivering the turning exchange on time, besides ostracism from the board, and extreme guilt on my part?

There is no way I can finish my piece and get it shipped in time. Preparations for the FL trip have slowed my production considerably, not to mention the fact that I can't get to the lathe right now due to a pile of blanks stacked in front. 8^]

I wanted to let the recipient know and beg forgiveness, but I think this is supposed to stay anonymous until the person receives their turning. What's your advice?

Gary

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#7

Re: Could be elm...

David Breth

>It looks kind of elmy to me, but speaking as the guy who started the stinkywood post a couple of months ago, I would suggest the owner of the wood give it a giant sniff to see if he is reminded of a beautiful green pasture, filled with cows, each of which is filled with something else, which smells remarkably like "elm".

There are other woods that stink too, I'm just tossing in my 2-cents-but-you've-got-change-coming on the topic.

Daivd B.

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#8

Re: Could be elm...

David Breth

>It looks kind of elmy to me, but speaking as the guy who started the stinkywood post a couple of months ago, I would suggest the owner of the wood give it a giant sniff to see if he is reminded of a beautiful green pasture, filled with cows, each of which is filled with something else, which smells remarkably like "elm".

There are other woods that stink too, I'm just tossing in my 2-cents-but-you've-got-change-coming on the topic.

I can't resist this really bad joke I just thought of - sniffing this wood is part of the @ssid test.

Daivd B.

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#9

Re: Could be elm...

David Propst

>Hey Gary,

There is no penalty, but if you cn't get it out by sometime next week I'd send them an e-mail. No reason to apologize though, life does get busy and I'm sure you are working OT to get ready for the Florida Symposium.

I'm not sending mine out till Saturday, trying to let the oil cure as long as possible before buffing.

I posted the pic of Gabrielle under the post you mentioned it. Did you see it?

David

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#10

Brad Vietje

'Course there are a few different Elm's, too...

Brad Vietje

>This looks like a very fast-growing tree to me. The American Elm we see here in VT doesn't grow that fast, but maybe one of the others (Slippery, Wych, Russian, Chinese, etc...) I'd be tempted to look into the cottonwood relatives, and other fast-growers, too.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#11

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

Jim Swank

>Sure looks like slippery or red elm (ulmus rubra) to me. If the bark slips off easily, with a slimy inner bark layer, that would be almost conclusive. See http://www.museum.state.il.us/muslink/forest/htmls/trees/U-rubra.html for more on the tree.

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#12

Re: Could be elm...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi David,

This wood has no appreciable smell, and I've cut up a lot of it. My understanding is that typically when wood has an onerous smell, it's because the tree had a bacterial infection while it was alive. Consequently the wood gets a bad rap for it's smell.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#13

Re: 'Course there are a few different Elm's, too..

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks, Brad,

I'm convinced it's elm from my use of the ID keys, as well as the examination of the twigs and buds. I'd really like to know what kind, though.

Part of the reason for the fast growth could be the fact that our growing season is 8 months long, while yours is 1. 8^}

Thanks again,

Gary

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#14

Re: Could be elm...

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Gary

Slippery Elm is also known as Red Elm. I had some that was air dried. It does have more Red color in the wood than American Elm does. The Red Elm that I turned had has an a hint of spice small to it. I've had some American Elm that when it was green, smelled just like dog crap. Here is a picture of a box I made. It his red (slippery elm) with a burl insert in the lid. The picture quality isn't the best, sorry. Hackberry is also in the Elm Family. In all of the Elm varieties you can see little w's in the grain patteren. These occur where you view the transition from side grain to end grain. maybe someone can explain that a little better than I can.

Tom


img

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#15

Re: 'Course there are a few different Elm's, too..

Kenny

>Gary,

I was browsing and I saw your question about the elm. Could it be Rock Elm. Slipery elm and rock elm have simular buds. The barks are different. Do you have pic of bark?

Good luck in Florida.

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#16

W's

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Another and better pic of the W's in Slippery (RED) Elm. This is a cup I made for my buisness cards.


img

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#17

close up

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>The w's are where the flat grain blends into the end grain.


img

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

#18

Re: Does anyone know this wood?

Ernie Miller

>is it green? how does it smell when it is turned? I'm betting red elm it turns pretty nice I just sent some burl to Dave P