Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

Posts

Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#1

Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

T Daniel

>Starting this Wed we will offer some basic design pointers to help newbies get started and the intermediate to take a step up the ladder. We'll start with bowls. Please post a picture of your best bowl and comment on design features that you think are important. I will start it off with a pic of a bowl made to the thirds rule of proportions. The base is 1/3 the max diameter. I like my bowl heights to be between 1/3 and 1/2 the diameter. I feel when the height exceeds 1/2 the diameter that it is on longer a bowl but not a vase either. Comments welcome.

TD


img

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#2

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

Ron in Drums PA

>Terry, you do BIG stuff!

What are the specs on this?

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#3

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

T Daniel

>This one was about 14" diam x about 4" tall. base diameter was about 4.5".. The piece is long gone and without seeing its assigned number on the bottom I cannot identify it on my list. I just pulled this pic from an old list.

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#4

Don't think I'll be there but

Carole in VA

>Ya'll can pick apart one of my bowls if you want. This is a little Black Willow utility bowl. Don't own it anymore so I can't look at it again. It was 6"x3" with a consistent wall thickness of 1/8". The diameter of the foot (actually no foot, but a concave area) is about 1 7/8". Finished with Tried and True Original. If I had it to do over again, I can't decide if I would put a tiny foot on it or not.


img

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#5

Bottom 

Carole in VA

>


img

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#6

Re: Don't think I'll be there but

Barry Turner

>I like it with no foot and just a concave area for the bowl to sit on. There are fewer recesses and corners for dirt and food particles to collect in. Makes washing and keeping the bowl clean easier. (This is probably my 33 years of working for a health department speaking). I use this type of a foot (or no foot) on my bowls quite often. Nice bowl.

Barry

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#7

Re: Don't think I'll be there but

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carole that is a really nice looking bowl. You amaze me at how quickly you've risen up the learning curve in the short time that you've been turning. It's really inspiring!

Jen

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#8

It absolutely boggles my mind....

Molly Winton

>that you would even hesitate to question your turning skills as a newbie turner, when you produce such beautiful work! The form on this is wonderful, and what I can see of your technical skills, it's just as good. You've mentioned your anxiety about sending out your turning exchange.....ppphhhhhtttt!!!! Be proud girl, and send something like this! Your recipient will be tickled pink!

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#9

Mine too!!

Nick Stagg

>I don't think she climbed the learning curve, I think she jumped on top of it!!

I'm amazed at her progress and skill level, in what, just over a year? That's a very good bowl and you should never question your ability.

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#10

Molly's Right!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#11

Beautiful form

Jack Savona

>I just came back from a bowl turning weekend class with Dave Lancaster. His simple 'recipe' for shaping a bowl was: form the outside diameter; determine the inside diameter, then connect the two with a pleasing curve. Carol, that form is exactly what I see in your beautiful bowl.

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#12

Thoughts on turning

Carole in VA

>Well thanks, all. But, believe me, I did not just jump on top of the learning curve when I turned my first bowl 11 months ago! LOL I spent a lot of time experimenting, making shavings and learning and will continue as long as I am able to stand in front of the lathe. Since I may not be around Wed night, I will share a couple thoughts on turning that I consider the most important revelations to me as newbie: I learned that the key to achieving fair curves is body movement. I know now that if I just pick up a tool and manipulate it while I stand there like a stump, nothing good is going to happen. My whole body has to become one with the tool. (That's why I had a problem standing on the milk crate at Dick's shop...my movement was restricted.) I also know that if I just look at the tool as it cuts rather than the profile of the piece, it's like driving down the street while looking at the steering wheel instead of the road ahead. The inevitable result is that I am not going to get where I want to go and more than likely I am going to end up with a mess. That Willow bowl is one I turned not too long after I had accepted and internalized and those two concepts.

I have been a "curves" person for as long as I can remember. I can't draw, but from childhood on, my unconscious doodles on paper have always been non-sensical series of flowing curves as opposed to boxes, triangles, figures, etc. I am just sorry that it took 56 years for me to discover the curvey joy of that spinny thing! :)

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#13

Re: Thoughts on turning

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Very well said Carole. You have learned, and put into practice some very important things that some more experienced turners never do. Your work shows it.

Wally

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#14

Re: Thoughts on turning

David Propst

>Hi Carole,

Your are on exactly the right track. As Wally said, some folks have turned for decades and not got those basic concepts of form and movement down. It is so important

I really encourage you to get Richard Raffin's "Turned Bowl Design" book. I know you mentioned that you have avoided books, but this text is not a "how-to" book. Based on what you said about your facination with curves I think you would really enjoy it.

It is exciting to see posts of your work. Keep them coming!

David

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#15

Re: Thoughts on turning

Arch

>Carole, Your post is a sure keeper. I think you said more in fewer words and put it better than any other "thoughts on turning" I've read in a long time. Your learning curve has certainly been a fair one.

Thanks, congratulations and best wishes, Arch

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#16

Re: Thoughts on turning

John Lucas

>Carol I love your analogy of driving down the road. that is a very clear way to put it. I hope you don't mind if I borrow that the next time I demo. Reminds me of walking on a balance beam. You have to look ahead not at your feet. Same idea.

Re: Topic for Wed.....Design elements...sample

#17

Re: Thoughts on turning

Carole in VA

>No problem, John. You can tell them it's in my book "Dancing With Wood: Reflections of a Novice Turner" ;)) Just kidding! Actually I had to start using analogies extensively when I started teaching senior citizens how to use the computer. It was a very effective way to get something across that was totally foreign to them. I've been doing it ever since.