Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Mystery Wood *LINK*

Posts

Mystery Wood *LINK*

#1

Mystery Wood *LINK*

NotsoDull!

>Okay all you wood experts, I need your help.

I scrounged this piece of fire wood from a Pacific Northwest woodpile.

The bark was very stringy like cedar, but it's definitely not cedar.

It is quite soft and had a real tendency to tear out.

Mild smell.

It was fairly dry and didn't have many splits, which is what attracted me in the first place.

(that and the mild spalting)

Any ideas?

Rick

"Life shouldn't be dull."


img

http://www.notsodull.com

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#2

Re: Mystery Wood

NotsoDull!

>Here is the bowl I made from it.

It's approximately 6" wide by 5.5" tall.

Comments requested - good or bad.

Thanks,

Rick


img

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#3

Re: Mystery Wood

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Cottonwood?

Wally

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#4

Yup, I'd go with cottonwood too.

Molly Winton

>

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#5

Me Too

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#6

Re: Mystery Wood

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Rick, a little critique on the form, since you asked.

I see a bit of a flat spot just below the widest part of the belly, and also I think it would look better without a foot. Otherwise, very nice shape overall and well done!

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#7

Re: Mystery Wood

NotsoDull!

>Thanks for the input Ken.

I tried the foot for a change. It seems most of my bowls are kind of squatty, so I thought I would experiment a bit.

Yes, there is a flat spot where I had to power sand the tear out.

That's still my biggest challenge - tear out both inside and outside the bowl.

I know my tools are sharp, which leads to the obvious conclusion:

operator error.

Cottonwood seems to be the consensus; there's lots of it up here, I'm going to go visit a live one to see if the bark matches.

Anyone else ever turned cottonwood?

It had worse tear out than any type of wood I have ever worked with.

Rick

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#8

Cottonwood

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Cottonwood is very prone to tearing out especially when real dry so don't feel too bad.

Re: Mystery Wood *LINK*

#9

Re: Mystery Wood

Molly Winton

>Cottonwood is one of the worst for tearout. It has a very loose fiber structure. I can't imagine anyone turning it without that problem. I don't even bother with it. If you've got nothing else to turn it'll give you something to practice on, but I'd just use it for the firewood it was intended. A trick to help prevent tearout (in any wood) is to oil the trouble spots. This lubricates the wood as well as helps the fibers stand up to cut better. If you're going to use an oil finish for the bowl, just use some of that. Then as already stated, use a sharp gouge. Good luck.