Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

From a camera's point of view

Posts

From a camera's point of view

#1

From a camera's point of view

Lan Brady

>When we look at a photo of a turned piece, we are looking for a nice smooth curve. Knowing that a camera sees the shape from one point, are we really looking at opposing sides, 180 degrees apart. Or does the camera point of view taper toward the front of the project as the diameter widens? I don't have a clue myself!

Lan

Re: From a camera's point of view

#2

Re: From a camera's point of view

John Lucas

>Lan A camera turns the object into 2 dimesions. Anything the same height as the lens will not be distorted. Anything above or below the center of the lens will be. With telephoto lenses there is less distortion because the angle from the top of the piece to the center will be less. With a wide angle lens the angle is greater thus there is more of a chance for distortion. Use a very wide angle lens to shoot a group of poeple. Then look at the heads of those on the edges of the frame. The people on the edge will have distorted heads. (I always put the people I don't like on the sides of groups)

The angle you shoot from also distorts a vessel. This is most easily seen if you shoot a tall building with parallel sides. When you look up at the building the top will be smaller than the bottom and it appears as though it were falling over. The opposite happens when you look down on vessel. The bottom will appear smaller than it really is. This affect is reduce by using a moderate telephoto lens to shoot your vases and hollow vessels.

The old saying that photos never lie is about as far from the truth as you can get. If you study forensic photography you learn a great deal about trying to keep a camera from lying, or at least showing the object or schene as close to what we would see if were standing in the same location.

The short answer is yes a camera distorts your piece. How you light it will also affect the shape. On camera flash flattens the piece and takes away the shadow lines that Terry mentioned the other day. A light from up above and to one side will give roundness to the piece and will cast shadows from rings and v grooves giving more clues to it's shape.

Re: From a camera's point of view

#3

Re: From a camera's point of view

Allen Neighbors

>Having once been a professional photographer for too many years, I can attest to the accuracy of John's statements. Maybe I can add just a little. On a 35 mm camera, a 50 mm lens sees closest to what the human eye sees. Being new to digital photography, I'm not sure if the same conclusion applies.

Another way to explain some of what John said is that a telephoto lens compresses distance, and a wider angle expands distance, so it is natural that there will be less distortion with telephoto (unless the object is like a roadway that runs the full depth of the scene).

The reason my photos in the below post are so lousy, is because I don't have anything left of my photo equipment. I had to retire from photography due to a benign familial tremor (I shake like an aspen leaf). I purchased a small digital camera, and the attached flash is the only light I have. My present setup stinks. John's right. A main light higher than and right of the camera lens, will add depth and shadow. Another light about the same height as the subject, and to the left, and twice as far away from the subject as the main light, will help the situation even more, by giving you a 2:1 lighting ratio. Keeping the subject at a greater distance from the background will help also, if you can't control the depth of field with your lens.

Hope this doesn't confuse you.

AL

Re: From a camera's point of view

#4

Re: From a camera's point of view

Molly Winton

>So at the next symposium when you take the group photo, I'm going to be studying VERY closely to see who you put to the outside of the group!

Re: From a camera's point of view

#5

Re: From a camera's point of view

John Lucas

>having said what I did I will have to use an extra wide lens and make sure there's nothing but space on the edges of the photo. Either that or put everyone on the edge so there's no bias.

Re: From a camera's point of view

#6

Re: From a camera's point of view

John Lucas

>Allen I feel for you having to use non-professional equipemt. When digital first came out my Boss had to have one. We bought one of the first digital Nikon's. It was a nightmare to use. All the overrides took a computer person to figure out. The time lag between when you take the photo and when the camera decided to take the photos was as much as a full second and varied. I had to shoot sports with that damn thing. The newer generation of point and shoots do a much better job in Program mode but have most of the same drawbacks in manual mode. Most of them do let you turn off the flash.

I bought a Canon digital rebel for myself (it was all I could afford) It does pretty good but has one terrible flaw. When you use a flash on the hotshoe with the camera in manual mode it will change the shutter speed to expose for the background and not tell you. It still shows 1/60 of a second but may take a photo at 1/4 second. I ruined a bunch of photos at one symposium because of this.

Re: From a camera's point of view

#7

Re: From a camera's point of view

JamieDonaldson

>The field of view of any focal length lens is a cone that originates at the optical node(center of the lens) and extends outward. A telephoto would show more of the actual profile of a turning than a wide angle lens, and the usual barrel distortion of a WA makes the distortion even more pronounced, especially close up!

Re: From a camera's point of view

#8

Re: From a camera's point of view *LINK*

JKJ

>To figure out exactly what edge the camera will see, draw a circumference of the object (top view) on a large piece of paper. Place a point the same distance away as your camera, or more precisely, the nodal point of the lens. (Some cameras have the nodal point marked to aid with panorama photography.) Draw two straight lines from that point tangent to either side of the circumference. From this, you can see the error is higher with a wide angle lens since the camera is closer for the same image width.

Note that this shows the edge the lens will see and has nothing to do with any distortion in the lens, such as barrel or pincushion, which is a different issue entirely.

You can draw similar lines from the side view to see the top and bottom edges that will be captured.

Fortunately, the edge the camera captures is the same as you see with your eyes at that distance (or at least with one eye closed) so the image looks entirely natural except at extreme camera distances.

Dept. of Mostly Useless Information: There is a way to take the photo with a special camera that captures EXACTLY the edges on the diameter, 180 degrees apart. Using a vertical slit in a focal plane shutter curtain, the camera or object is moved in sync with the shutter such that light path through the slit is always perpendicular to the object. (50-60 years ago photographers used the slow FP curtain shutters in Speed Grafix 4x5 cameras to do tricks with moving objects!) This is somewhat similar to the way a flatbed scanner works with 2D objects and has been used with lasers for precision work with 3D objects.

Dept. of Remotely Related but Interesting Information: Forestry people use something called a Biltmore Stick to measure the diameter of a tree by sight. The markings on the stick compensate for the perspective error you mention. The diagaram under "Measuring Diameter" in the link below illustrates the angles, just as with a camera lens.

JKJ


Biltmore stick