Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Bending spalted wood

Posts

Bending spalted wood

#1

Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>I think I have proven today that it is almost impossible to steam bend spalted wood. I have been working all day on a project that requires that I bend the wood. I managed to get the first one bent after only 2 tries. It was 8" long and varied from 5/15 to 1/4" and had a long curve. The first one broke. I'm using the microwave and a wet rag to heat the wood.

The other ones proved tougher. I am turning 5" long spindles that taper from 3/16 to 1/8". I need to bend them 90 degrees with a small radius. I experimented with this a year ago and found out that you can't bend even green fresh wood this tight without doing some other technique. I decided to try putting a metal band on the outside of the radius to keep the wood under compression at the elbow. This worked great on my first test using fresh green wood. It worked on the first spalted piece. I've since broken 3 in a row trying to get the second one bent. The 4th one is soaking in water now and I'll try it again in a little while. I'm guessing that spalted wood has just lost a lot of elasticity. I wouldn't use spalted wood except that it needs to match the rest of the piece.

If I ever get this piece done it won't be allowed anywhere near a church for at least a month. It will take that long for the language to wear off.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#2

Re: Bending spalted wood

Lan Brady

>John,

It is a good thing that wood cannot talk!

Lan

Re: Bending spalted wood

#3

Re: Bending spalted wood

Dennis Y

>John, I assume that the spindle is long grain. Have you checked on the orrientation of the growth rings to the bend of the curve. It might make a difference whether they are parallel or at 90 degrees to the radius of the curve. Do I make any sense? Dennis

Re: Bending spalted wood

#4

Re: Bending spalted wood

RevDoug

>You might try actually steaming the pieces. Make a box that they can go into. Boil a pot of water with a steam vent that empties into the box. After 2 or 3 hours the pieces ought to be ready to be bent.

Since they are so short, you might try boiling the pieces for a while. I know the bowls I've boiled were pretty pliable for a while after taking them out of the water. If you take the rods out of the boiling water and go straight to the form you should have pretty good luck with it.

Taking guesses here, but at least it sounds plausable.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Bending spalted wood

#5

Re: Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>Makes perfect sense. I've tried both ways, grain 90 degrees to the bend and graind parallel to the bend and they both seem to break. They are long grain and I rived the pieces so the grain is continuous. Those were the first 2 things I looked at for problems.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#6

Re: Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>revdoug I am willing to try anything but I don't think it will work. By wrapping the piece is a wet rag and microwaving I'm actually doing both + heating the wood. I've had very good success with this on green wood and even dry wood. In fact on small items like this it worked better than steaming. I tried steaming and boiling last Year with much less success. I also tried soaking in ammonia which works really well for dry wood but didn't fair any better on the spalted wood.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#7

Re: Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>Ah but it does talk. It's telling me it doesn't want to do this, and it's telling me loud and clear.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#8

Re: Bending spalted wood

Bill Crommett

>John: Try tuning a spindle with the pith at the inside of the bend and not in the center of the spindle. In what little bending I have done the pieces that were better bent had the pithon the inside of the bend and therefore did not resist the compression that couses the outside to splinter when stretched. I hope this sounds clearer to you than it does when I re-read it. Rev Doug is correct, that boiling will do more than steaming, up to a point, and then we have to use a pressure cooker to get the water vapor deep into the wood.

Bill

Re: Bending spalted wood

#9

Re: Bending spalted wood

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>John, the ultimate technique for bending wood that I've heard about is using full-strength ammonia. Something I don't have any great desire to work with, but there's a pretty good tutorial on this over on the WoW site, by Eugen Schlaak. You definitely need a good respirator, but I've heard of nothing better for plasticising the wood as using that awful stuff. It turns wood into rubber for a few seconds of critical time.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#10

Re: Bending spalted wood

Juergen

>Check out Tania Radda's folder on WOW. A product she used called compressed Hard Maple apppears to be very easy to bend and manipulate. If it needs to look spalted you can do a faux process after you've achieved the shape your're looking for.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#11

Re: Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>Ken I tried household ammonia which has worked before on regular wood. I may try to get some full strength.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#12

Re: Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>I talked to Tania. This would work but has the same drawback as stack laminating(which is cheaper and easily available to me) That is I would have to use faux finishing techniques to achieve the final results. This is what I will probably do today because the next piece requires 2 bends, one greater than 90 degrees and the spindle will be 7" long instead of 5. I don't relish turning more than 1 or 2 3/16 spindles that are this long. Wouldn't be that hard if I didn't need a ball shape on each end. I could just feed a 3/8" dowel through the chuck and cut as I go but with the ball shape on each end I have to turn it between centers. Well actually one end is in a chuck.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#13

Re: Bending spalted wood

Barry Irby

>Turn and Bend them green and then spalt them. Some wet spalted shavings in a plastic bag for a month or two and Voil�! Might be faster than what you are doing now.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#14

Re: Bending spalted wood

Jorge Castaneda

>John,

I don't think spalted wood is a good candidate for turning, I've bent wood many times making lobster traps, and boat planks ao boat frames, mostly using q/s green oak, steaming it , lots of hot wet steam for the boat plank and boiling it for lobster traps. Tri wrapping the wood in rags drenched in boiling water, that may help, and th emetal band is a must to bend traps.

Good luck

Jorge

Re: Bending spalted wood

#15

correction

Jorge Castaneda

>I meant bending, not turning.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#16

Re: Bending spalted wood

Dale Cook

>Hi John. I've bent some regular maple by boiling it for at least 30 to 40 minutes. You only have a short time out of the pot to get the bend you want,or put it back in alittle longer.I used insulated rubber gloves to grab the piece,and some will still break.Good luck.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#17

Re: Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>Barry excellent idea. Maybe next time. Right now I'm committed (or should be at least) I did get one bend successfully this morning. I have 3 more turned and boiling right now.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#18

Re: Bending spalted wood

John Lucas

>Jorge I think I have 2 problems other than the spalted wood. One is the wood cools off very quickly. it's only 3/16 diameter. The other is that I can't clamp the metal strap strong enough. There isn't enough time to use a screw clamp, the wood cools, so I'm using a strong hand clamp. I think the wood slips in the clamp a little and doesn't keep the wood under tension well enough.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#19

Re: Bending spalted wood

Ed Karch

>John the glue that holds the wood together is lignin this is also what you soften up with steam to enable bends. The problem is it is also food for some spalting fungi. I think the spalting would have to be at a very early stage to pull this off consistantly.

Re: Bending spalted wood

#20

Re: Bending spalted wood

Jorge Castaneda

>John,

If the wood is that thin, maybe you could try bending it like we did bend the boat frames, yue need a form, then when the wood has been in the stam or boiling water enough, you quickly put it in the form with one hand and push with your thumb in the middle of the widest gap and then with the other tap down the edge, (in a boat the bottom of the frame gets jammed against the keel) and when you cannot see light anymore clamp starting from the very top.