Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Critique the old guy again, please.

Posts

Critique the old guy again, please.

#1

Critique the old guy again, please.

Allen Neighbors

>Please forgive the photography. I sold all my gear, and all I have left is a little digital and short tripod. With the built-in flash I can't bounce light well, and don't have a good place to take photos (that may come later). I stole the beaded top idea from one of you ladies on this forum, but I'm not taking credit for it, so I guess it ain't really theft, or is it? :o)

This is a worm-eaten Ash vase. 7" high, 4.5" widest. Don't have much of an eye, but tried the curve thing. Sanded to 600, then brown paper sack. Finish is one coat of lacquer. I'll put another coat, maybe two, but I was in a hurry. I'd like some more critiques, please. I need to learn the practice of seeing. Thanks, Al


img

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#2

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

Allen Neighbors

>Another view, showing the unwormy side.


img

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#3

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

Allen Neighbors

>Last pic, a better view of the top.


img

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#4

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

Kurt From Jersey

>I love it! Ash is usually very bland, but not this peice of art! Nicely done!!!

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#5

Looks good!

Mike Cunningham

>Hi Allen,

I like it. I think that it has a pleasing shape and a nicely done rim/collar. The grain orientation looks good. The relative dimensions look right to me. What are the actual dimensions?

Nice work!

Mike

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#6

Re: Looks good!

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks for your comments, Mike. The vase is 7 inches tall. The width at its widest, after measuring again, is 4 1/4 inches. The bottom is 2 1/16 inches, and the opening is 1 1/16 inches.

Thanks again for your comments. Maybe I'm not as far off as I thought....?

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#7

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I think it looks very nice Allen. Not sure what you want in the form of a critique, but I have two observations I'll share.

1. I think this piece would look even more pleasing with a flat or very low sheen. Not sure why I think this, I just do.

2. The base might have a little bit more of "tuck" to it.

But please do not mistake me, this is very nice.

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#8

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Very well done Allen. I like the curves and the proportions. I'm going to be a little picky since you want opinions. The curve seems to flatten out in the middle part. I'm very partial to continuing curves. That nice curve could continue in so the base is a bit smaller, making it a more sweeping curve. I think that you've done a good job of "tucking" in at the base. I like it.

Wally

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#9

Dick Hines

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

Dick Hines

>I don't know about the old guy but his hollow form is in great shape.

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#10

Re: I concur with Wally,...

JamieDonaldson

>......there is a flat area down the side that kills the flow of the good curves you have at both top and bottom. One way to improve seeing this problem is to roll a straightedge(like a 12" ruler)from top to bottom, and where the air gap stops for a certain distance relative to size is too flat. This piece is pleasing to me, but you should be aware of the flat areas on future works, and the ruler will help find them.

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#11

Great tip Jamie!

RevDoug

>

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#12

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

GeeSeaWhy

>I like the form, but not the finish. I'm not generally a fan of high-gloss finishes on turnings anyway. I think they look best on perfectly flat, flawless surfaces. Ash is too rough unless you fill the grain, even without the worm holes.

Just my opinion, and worth every penny you paid for it.

Graeme

Re: Critique the old guy again, please.

#13

Ric Taylor

Looks Very Nice :)

Ric Taylor

>