Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Tool rest question

Posts

Tool rest question

#1

Tool rest question

Wolf Kiessling

>After looking at Bill Grumbine�s post regarding the tool rests he purchased from Monster Wood the other day, it got me thinking that I need a new tool rest myself. It appears that I have three options and I would like some input to help me make up my mind which option to pursue.

First of all, and this is probably immaterial, I have a JET 1642 with electronic speed control and I am using the standard tool rest that came with the machine. Lately, and probably in the future, I am mostly turning natural edge bowls in the 12 � 13� diameter range by about 10� or so deep.

The options that I am aware of are an S-curve tool rest such as the one sold by Craft Supplies. The ones that Monster Wood has, that I am interested in, are the 4/8� offset and the curved tool rests. Randy tells me that the curved tool rest, the 1� Superbar, is 9� long from the centerline of the post to the end of the curve.

My inclination/intuition tells me that the curved Superbar is probably the way to go. However, before I shell out 95 bucks, I would appreciate it if anyone could either confirm this opinion or set me straight or just give some advice in general. I have been experiencing a great deal of trouble finishing off the inside of these bowls as I get near the bottom. I pretty much use scrapers all the way.

Re: Tool rest question

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tool rest question

Keith Tompkins

>HI Wolf, using a scraper, you certainly need the curved rest..too much overhang for a scraper using a straight rest. Curoius...Why don't you use a bowl gouge?...Faster, actually easier too.

Re: Tool rest question

#3

Re: Tool rest question

Wolf Kiessling

>I do use a bowl gauge on the outside but have not had much luck using one on hollowing. Lack of talent. I'm always gauging the inside when I use the bowl gauge. Get lots of catches. Most of the wood I turn for large bowls is very punky because it is usually heavily spalted on has outstanding figure and color. I'm too lazy to really get down and practice using the bowl gauge for hollowing. Find it much easier to use the scrapers. I suppose if I were to go take some lessons it would likely help. I'm really not near a turning club, nearest one, actually two in different directions, are nearly 100 miles away. Larry Hancock came to my place a couple of times and helped me out but mainly it's lack of practice. I know what to do, just can't perform. Oh well, the woes of living in a small rural community......

Re: Tool rest question

#4

Re: Tool rest question

RussFairfield

>This is just one guys opinion on tool rests, so take it for what its worth.

I have a problem with all of the aftermarket tool rests, and a few particular problems with the commercial curved tool rests in general.

My problem with the after-market toolrests is that they are ROUND, and a 1" diameter bar gives me 1/2" of tool overhang before I have even started making a cut with the tool. I prefer a rest that supports the tool closer to the wood.

My problem with every curved tool rest that has ever been made is that I have yet to find one that fits the curve of the inside of a bowl very well, and most of the time not even close enough to be more useful than a straight toolrest. The basic problem is that these toolrests are always made with a circular curve, but I don't make bowls that have a spherical shape.

There are also 2 other problems with the commercial toolrests, the first being that the curve always starts at the tool post, and the other is that the long unsupported end of the curved rest makes it very flexible near the end. The 1st makes it more difficult to get the rest into the bowl that isn't a circular form, and the 2nd makes it more difficult to control tool chatter in the bottom of the bowl.

The biggest problem I have had with scrapers is that they come with handles that are always too short for working the inside of a bowl. I replace the short stock handle on a heavy scraper with one that is about 30" long, and I make it from Hickory so it is both stiff and heavy. This handle gives me better leverage and control, and I find almost no need for a curved rest, except for those special cases where nothing else works.

To me, a "better" tool rest would have an oval curve or that of a "French Curve", and the "perfect" toolrest would be one that was adjustable to fit the curve of the bowl I am turning. Until I can buy either of those, my opinion will remain unchanged that the curved rests on the market are a waste of money because they have such limited use.

The hidden message here is that the more useful curved toolrest will be the one that you make yourself to fit your needs, and not one the you can buy from a catalog.

Others will not share my opinion.

Re: Tool rest question

#5

Re: Tool rest question

Wolf Kiessling

>You make some very thought provoking points that are well worth taking into consideration. Thanks......

Re: Tool rest question

#6

Re: Tool rest question

Pat Mulligan

>I like my oneway curved rest.

Re: Tool rest question

#7

Re: Tool rest question

bob davis

>the "s" from craft supplies is flat on top,,works wellfor me with scraper or bowl gouge

Re: Tool rest question

#8

Re: Tool rest question

Randy Privett

>Russ,

I really appreciate your opinion on tool rests, and you are right in saying that you lose 1/2" in the bottom, but to say that all curved tool rest curves start at the post isn't quite right,with the ones we make anyway. I didn't like the way the aftermarket bowl rests were made either, so we set out to alter the way they were made. Ours start the curve for the 3/4" bowl rest it is 3 1/2" from the center of the post and the 1" we start it at 4 1/2". This way you can extend it somewhat inside the bowl. We have also added a center brace trying to keep the vibration to a minimum. I would love to figure an adjustable rest so it would cover all the coutours, but that I feel it would be impossible. Thanks for your opinions and comments I always come away with good information from your posts.

Thanks

Randy

Re: Tool rest question

#9

Re: Tool rest question

RussFairfield

>Sorry Randy, I haven't seen one of your tool rests. You have addressed 2 of my problems with the previous commercial tool rests. That should go a long way towards making the rest more useable.