Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

Posts

Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#1

Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

T Daniel

>Earl, can you post a pic of the bottom of the bowl I sent you (side and bottom views)? This bowl has my standard dovetail foot which allows remounting so that I can easily do multiple coats of oil and multiple sandings. I have played with the design of this mounting ring and I personally think it fits the piece. Many think the dovetail must be removed. First, Earl, you have it in your hands, does the dovetail need removed? Others, after seeing the pic (hopefully) what comments or criticisms do you have? Reason for this post: I have a lady on the way here this morning that bought a bowl a few months ago and left a winter squash in it too long and it rotted and stained the bowl. I give a lifetime guarantee on my finish so I will remount this bowl with the dovetail and sand or shave away the stain and then re-oil. Without the dovetail it would take too long to do this to make it practical; with the dovetail it will only take minutes. Comments after the pics please.

TD

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#2

Question, not a comment

Carole in VA

>Terry, I know you said comments after the pic, but this is a question. :) How do you keep the chuck from marking the foot when you remount it, especially if you have to mount it securely enough to use a cutting tool like a scraper to remove a stain? I tried wrapping with tape but that didn't work too well. I thought I could chuck lightly with padded tailstock support but then I couldn't get to the spot I needed to repair.

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#3

jaw marks

T Daniel

>Carole, I use stainless steel or plated jaws and try to make the dovetail as close as possible to fit the jaws with them being almost closed. This keeps the entire circumference of the jaws touching so that the pressure is distributed to as large an area as possible. My dovetail pocket is cut with a slight taper so that the deepest portion is a little larger than the face of the pocket. I put finishing oil in the pocket before finish turning the inside of the bowl. I think we are going to start a series of design tips over the next few chats.

TD

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#4

Carole..

DWR

>... In the past, many years in the past... I used a Richard Raffen chuck, and to eliminate the jaw marks, I put a circle of fabric around the dovetail and set the jaws. With the taper of the dovetail and making sure there were no "wrinkles" in the fabric, it held surprisingly well and I rarely had any marks to deal with. If I got an exceptionally large "dig" I might have to re-square the blank, which took a couple of minutes, but I never lost a bowl...

Dave

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#5

Another Question, not a comment

Stuart Johnson

>Do you have any problem with it going slightly out of round due to wood movement?

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#6

yes

T Daniel

>Stu, I always re-cut the dovetail after the blanks has dried. Sometimes I re-cut the top of the bowl first and sometimes I have to re-cut the dovetail first, it just depends on how much warpage occurs. Another thing I do is trim the dovetail down once the vessel has dried. I normally do a number of vessels at a time, truing tops first, then bottoms or vs./vs. When all of the turning is done I cut the dovetail very shallow leaving just enough to hold it for sanding and oiling. On most woods it only requires about1/8" depth for this.

TD

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#7

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Sorry TD, I couldn't wait for Earl's pic. I'd say if the pocket is only 1/8" deep, it probably looks OK but why not use a vacuum chuck if it's only finish work that needs doing? Instead of a pocket, make a small beaded foot that aids in centering the bowl in the chuck.

Just my premature 2 cents worth.

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#8

Ken....

T Daniel

>Vac chucks don't work well with wood with voids. I could tape up the holes but that takes more time than using the jumbo jaws. My jumbo jaws are on a dedicated chuck so it does not take long to mount something this way. I am not saying I am right and everyone else is wrong; this is just how I do it.

TD

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#9

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

Earl Eyre

>Here are the photos. Let me know if you want better ones or from a different angle. I really like the dovetail. I think it makes a very professional finish to the bottom. I have used them on platters but have not thought of using them on bowls. I do know the wood has to be really dry or they do show when it finishes drying. The dovetail within the slight foot is an especially nice touch.

Earl


img

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#10

Second photo of the foot

Earl Eyre

>Guess you can't post two photos at once. Here's the other one.


img

Re: Question for Earl Eyre (and others)

#11

Thanks Earl, and an explanation...

T Daniel

>Things to note:

The bottom of the dovetail must be on the same plane as the bottom of the bowl....like the bowl was finished and then the ring was glued on.

The 1" of wood necessary to hold the piece on was divided in halves, reducing the apparent width to 1/2" although it is still 1".

Remember to reduce the depth and concave the "foot" to complete the process.

I use the Vicmarc dovetail jaws.

TD