Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Dang it! That hurt!

Posts

Dang it! That hurt!

#1

Dang it! That hurt!

Carole in VA

>I guess I have been initiated. I had my first significant catch inside a hollow form today. Thought for a minute I had busted my arm. I was using the gooseneck Scorpion and had turned the bit to "just a little more" of an angle to hollow up near the shoulder. :( I think I am glad I was not using the armbrace! Oh well, dinner and a little Advil and I will go get back on the horse - cautiously. At least the piece didn't blow up. Makes me wonder if that doo-dad on my DVR that is supposed to sense catches is working though.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#2

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

John Lucas

>Carol I broke a holly piece using my homemade arm brace. For a minute or two I though I broke my wrist because it hurt like hell and I couldn't move it but then it started to tingle and just sort of hurt so I knew I was OK. I was trying to thin out the inside through a long neck and just lost my concentration I guess.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#3

No armbrace and faceplate for me...

T Daniel

>I won't use the armbrace with the wood mounted to a faceplate. I hold the wood with a chuck and hope if I get a catch the wood will pull out of the chuck. I can see how the armbrace could break an arm when it pulls you around in a 360 degree arc.

TD

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: No armbrace and faceplate for me...

Keith Tompkins

>It would be nice if someone invented a chuck with an adjustable clutch mechanism.....the wood would simply stop spinning.As you know, on a high-hp lathe, the lathe won't stop.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#5

Armbrace....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, it could be that if you had been using the armbrace the catch would have been less severe. You use the armbrace to give more control, and that includes controlling catches. It's true that a very large catch in a deep vessel, with the cutter a long ways from the tool rest can cause a serious injury when using the arm brace. I've been using a Stewart tool since about 1988 and I can't remember anything more than a sore arm for a day or two. I have the standard 14-inch hooker plus a 21-incher. I quit using the 21 because it took me too far from the tool rest. When I'm turning a fairly deep piece I use a captive Nichols hollower. Much safer.

Since you've had the catch, did you think about that may have caused it? I think that it's important to do that so that you won't be as apt to repeat it.

Wally

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#6

Re: No armbrace and faceplate for me...

Carole in VA

>Keith, that's what my lathe is supposed to do. When there is a big catch it is supposed to just instantly shut down. I have it set on "normal". I think I might put it on "soft" for a while. I am surprised the piece didn't come out of the chuck.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#7

Re: Armbrace....

Carole in VA

>Wally, that's what is bothering me. I don't know exactly what caused it. It happened so darn fast! I had the tool rest back far enough so the straight part of the shaft was on the rest, like you would with any gooseneck tool. I wasn't in very deep because I was working the shoulder. When I go back out to the shop I am going to look and see if I maybe had the bit extended past the plane of the straight part of the shaft when I went for that little extra angle. Makes me think about some sort of captured system. :(

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#8

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

RussFairfield

>I see a lot of folks using the Arm-Brace with their arm extended way oput over the lathe. That is asking for trouble. In that position your arm is taking the full force.

If you work so that your elbow is held against your body, you will have full body support for the tool, and also better control of the tool. If you have a DVR, you should be twisting the headstock so you can do that.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#9

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

Carole in VA

>You are absolutely right, Russ. Having your arm extended away from your body is asking for trouble - something I discovered a couple of months ago with a less serious catch. This time I had the headstock rotated to the first detent and I did have my arm against my body. Had that not been the case, I think I might be having a cast put on right now! I still think that had I had my arm encased in a brace it might have been worse, but the brace is too long for my arm so I don't use it.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#10

Re: Dang it! That hurt- Go Outrigger *LINK*

georgetroy

>Carole you get in more trouble. I strongly recommend tools with an outrigger. I use what you have plus a BCT tool with outrigger. I also have outriggers on various 5/8" and 1/2" Hollowing tools. Al Basham makes tools with outriggers. I have the 1/2" and the 5/8" as listed on the Web site given. I also have 16" tool rests for my lathes so that outriggers are fully supported. My hand strength is not what it used to be, King Arthur rules. GT


Basham Tools

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#11

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

Mac

>Hi Carole, Thats not a bad catch! A bad one is when your feet keep hitting the ceiling as you rotate........

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#12

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

gary s clarke

>that is one reason that I like the Don Derry hollowing rig, IMHO I think it is safer, but more expensive. Just my .02 worth.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#13

Torque slip..

John Lucas

>Keith That's a good idea. Just modify a good torque wrench or possibly the same clutch limiting mechanism used in drills.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#14

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

Bob Elliott

>Carole,

I can remember in my early hollowing days using a small hand held tool just inside the opening / neck / shoulder area and got a hell of a catch. Turned a fingernail purple. As near as I can tell, I was pulling the tool out and cutting at the same time. Then, WHAM! Learned real fast NOT to do that again!

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#15

Re: No armbrace and faceplate for me...

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Del Stubbs had a foot pedal connected to the belt tension mechanism on his lathe, I think that's what most turners did in the "old days".

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#16

Been there, done that...

Peter Teubel

>...built a captured bar hollowing system. I've done many hollow forms "freehand", but like comparing freehand sharpening to a jig system, there's no going back after you've experienced it (IMO).

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#17

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Russ,

I am one of the ones who does this....if there's one thing I wish my General lathe had it's a swiveling headstock. I never thought it was a big deal until I started hollowing. My shoulders and back are feeling it.

Jen

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#18

Re: Armbrace....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>...also Carole, I've had the set screw wiggle loose and the cutter actually turned in the holder. In my case....it didn't catch..it just didn't cut.

Jen

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#19

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

Matt Birchfield

>With your elbow tucked in, touching your body the arm brace is a safe tool.

I do my large turning on an old Oliver 20C which has a 5HP motor and 4" flat belt drive. I've had a catch or two using the arm brace while extended a long way out over the tool rest... any one of them would have caused serious injury to my shoulder if I hadn't had my elbow tuching my side.

Because I use safe technique the only injury I suffered was because my head bumped the low rafter I was standing under (I'm 5'10" tall and the rafters in my basement shop are about 1/2" to 3/4" higher). Needless to say this is a laugh-getter when I demonstrate for clubs.

Even with the worst of catches on a 5HP lathe with a very positive motor drive system (the big flat belt) the belt did slip and my arm and shoulder were not hurt.

IMPORTANT: The arm brace fits my arm very well and I weigh over 200 pounds. A smaller person with a poorly fitting arm brace may have problems with a smaller lathe regardless of technique. I am also very comfortable with what my tools are doing at all times because I have used them for a long time every conceivable way (at least every way I can think of).

Matt

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#20

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

Ed Karch

>OK I confess I got hurt last week. I was working on a large pith center end grain bowl. (16"diameter is large to me) I was using a termite on this lovely end grain ambrosia maple when I descovered what pin knots are. A two HP catch smacked me in the chest with the handle (still have the bruise) and the business end wacked me on the back of my left hand. This was probably the only time I have worn a glove on the left hand. It was only a small hole and some bruised tendons. Had to dig some glove fibers out of the wound but all is well now. The bowl is fine, now being finished but I am sure that my education is not yet complete.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#21

Maybe I won't improve my motor mounting setup.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>The old Atlas lathe I'm learning on has the motor on a hinged bracket so thet the moor weight creates the belt tension. I don't like this at times as the motor whips a bit on startup especially at high RPM or with a large (sic) (in my case 8" dia. piece). I have noticed that when I would get a catch (less frequent now) the piece would just stop or just detach itself from my chuck. I was going to make a more rigid motor mount with an adjustable tesnion, but I think I will just leave it alone and consider it a safety feature.

Re: Dang it! That hurt!

#22

Good idea Ed

T Daniel

>I am not a proponent of someone starting on a 2 hp lathe unless they get some very good instruction first. Catches are no big deal with a 1/3hp motor mounted on a hinged platform like us old timers learned on but now with rigidly mounted 2 and 3 hp motors there is a much bigger chance of very serious accidents. Some of the better lathe manufacturers are programming their controls to sense a catch and reduce power to the motor but then that creates another problem because a heavy cut is seen as a catch and the power is reduced, thereby reducing the effective hp output of the machine. Many advocate starting with the most hp you can afford but I disagree with this; you need to grow into the 3 hp machines.

TD