We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm talking about a "standard" transverse mounting for a bowl blank. For moderate size bowls (up to, say, 10" or so), I like the idea of starting the blank out between centers on a simple spur drive, rather than going to the trouble of getting a smooth, flat surface and mounting a faceplate.
I start by roughing out the bottom first, on the tailstock side, while adding a tenon for later reverse chucking. I can do the early roughing from outside to inside (against the grain), but this leads to tearout. When I start getting close to the desired profile, I can't accept the tearout any longer. I want to cut downhill (inside to outside) with the grain, with my bowl gouge. But I can't. The tailstock is in the way. I can come in from the side and do shear scrapes (handle perpendicular to the ways), but that takes forever. I want to use the gouge the way it is meant to be used, but the handle has to be where the tailstock is.
So what's the trick? Or is this just an unavoidable drawback of this approach?
>Gary I would probably have to show you a photo to make this more clear but I use the side grind and a pull cut. Keep the handle low, you may have to lower your tool rest. After placing the tool on the tool rest move the gouge into the wood with the flute up and handle down. The side bevel of the tool should be on the wood with the cutting edge away from the wood just a little. Now rotate the tool CCW until the edge starts to cut. The handle should be ahead of the cut so that you are pulling the gouge instead of pushing.
You can do the whole bowl bottom this way or you can pull it out to the point that you can switch to a push cut. You won't be able to go all the way to the foot with this technique. I use a push cut to clean up the last 1/2" or so to the foot.
If that isn't clear I may be able to go in the shop tonight and take a photo. It will be cold as hell so I won't be able to stay long.
That's what I like about this forum: ask a simple question, and get a simple answer, fast! I love it.
Your answer is very clear, and I understand it. No photo necessary, but thanks for the offer. I've always used push cuts, but suddenly the light bulb has appeared, and because of your excellent description, I now "understand" the pull cut. Sounds like fun!
Of course "knowing" it and doing it are two separate things. So as soon as it warms up (my "shop" is the back patio), I'll get out there and practice my pull cut.
Thanks a lot for your usual attention and quick, excellent reply.
The pull cut John described is a terrific cut but is can lead to a nice catch. Another method is to
1. rough the outside as you are accustomed to doing and make a nice tennon for the chuck.
2. Mount the bowl in the chuck and clean the face of the bowl. This will make the wood fairly balanced.
3. Cut a tennon in the face of the bowl
4. Mount the bowl on the new tennon and make your cuts to the outside in the usual way with the tailstock out of your way (push cut). Once you are satisfied with the outside of the bowl (you can even sand the piece if the wood is dry)
5. Mount the bowl on the foot tennon to hollow out the inside.
This sounds like a lot of mounting and remounting. But in practice it goes very quickly and it eliminates you tool access "issues".
One other think you might consider:
Start the mounting between the live center and the chuck. Unless the bowl top is particularly irregular the chuck jaws will easily drive the blank for the initial roughing. Capturing the blank between the chuck and the live center will provide good security. As a collateral benefit the chuck may spin on the blank while roughing which causes a mark the same size as the chuck jaws. This will give you a good guide for sizing the tennon in the second mounting.
>Good idea richard. He does have a point on the pull cut. Ideally you do this with the handle low. The lower you get the handle the less chance you have of a catch. Sometimes however, either because of your tool rest, the size of the bowl, or a combination of the two you have to do this cut with the handle fairly high. I still find it quite controllable but don't take a big bite. A big bite could twist the tool in your hand and then you will get a pretty good catch. If I have to start a cut like this I drop the handle just as soon as I can. When the swept back grind is cutting at 60 degrees or less a catch is virtually eliminated. TD does this cut at 30 to 45 degrees and he'll tell you that the tool won't catch. The wood simply pushes it away.
I appreciate the warning and further info. It begs a couple followup questions:
John: Please explain which angle you are talking about: the nose angle on the tool or one of the angles of the tool with respect to the horizontal (or vertical)?
It the answer to the above is other than the tool nose angle, what tool nose angle would you recommend for the pull cut? How long do the wings have to be? Right now I'm using my larger 5/8" (1/2") BG with a 65-degree angle more appropriate for bowl bottoms, and I suspect this might not work very well for a pull cut. (But you tell me.) I plan to buy another one and make it 45-deg. I have a 3/8 at 45-deg now, and I like it.
Rick: I'll be out of town on the 11th, but I hope to see you for the February CAW meeting and talk more about this.
>Gary The angle I'm talking about is the way the wing is cutting the wood. For example if I said 90 degrees the wood would be hitting the cutting edge like you held a wood chisel up to it. 0 degrees would be the edge is so straight up and down that you aren't cutting. 45 degrees is a slicing cut.
My tools are all sharpened a little different but basically the nose is about 65 degrees and the wings are ground back about 3/4" on one gouge, shorter on another and much longer on one. The length doesn't really matter that much although too short makes it hard to control on the pull cut. The sharpening angle of the wings depends on the shape of the flute and the angle you use on your sharpening jig.
>Rick, Thanks for the interesting ideas. I'll give them a try. I hadn't heard about using the chuck as a "spur" before, but I like it. It sounds like it might give some added flexibility on an irregular surface. I'll give it a try as soon as it warms up. See also my reply to John (and you) (below John's second reply above) for another note to you. Cheers, Gary