Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Lathe problem/question

Posts

Lathe problem/question

#1

Lathe problem/question

Charlie Anderson

>I have a Jet 1236. I currently have a 10" bowl mounted in a SuperNova chuck.

My problem is that I'm unable to turn the bowl round. If I use a pencil to mark the bowl, the mark is only on half (or so) of the bowl.

I also noticed that if I put a dead center in the headstock, I can see a slight movement in the point of the dead center.

I haven't had this problem all the time but don't know when it began.

Can anyone tell me a possible solution?

(The wife isn't buying into the 'I need a better lathe' story)

Re: Lathe problem/question

#2

Re: Lathe problem/question

chris rolke

>1 make sure that your headstock is in alignment with your tail stock

2 greenwood or dry wood? i have had green wood warp bad enough on the lathe to do this

3 do you have a good tenon or recess on the bowl? and the chuck is tight ?

those are sopmethings i can think of right now

Re: Lathe problem/question

#3

Re: Lathe problem/question

Pete in Holland, MI

>Head stock tightened down? Tennon for your chuck straight with no taper? Is the tennon of softer wood, or have soft wood on one side? How long have you been turning the piece. Can't expect a green piece to stay put if you walk away for a little while.

Keep us posted on your findings.

Re: Lathe problem/question

#4

Re: Lathe problem/question

DWR

>Charlie,

With movement in the dead center you placed in your headstock, makes me think something is bent. If the dead center rotated smoothly, than I would have focused on the tenon or recess in the bowl, but since you are getting wobble in the dead center, it sounds like something is bent...

Try this: Make sure that your Morse Taper is clean in you head stock, as something could be "off-setting" your dead center, making it wobble. If your Taper is clean and there was no debris, put another center in your headstock to see if it too wobbles. If it does, then you most likely have a shaft issue. If it doesn't, then you might have a bent dead center and the shaft should be fine, which means you need to look at the threads on your shaft (for foreign material) or look at your chuck for any loose parts...

If you are turning Green, you will have warping as you turn. If you are turning dry, attach the chuck with out any blank attached and the jaws closed completely, so you don't have any openings, and the lathe at it's slowest speed, and take the back end of your tool handle and use it as a "dial indicator" and slowly, gently place the handle against the chuck (using your tool rest) to see if you are getting any run-out on the face of the chuck...

Discount any "tick-tick" sound you get from the seams in the closed jaws. If you are getting a tick-tick sound that is lower in the sound range and appears to be between the jaw openings, turn off the lathe while holding the handle against the jaws and as the chuck slows down, you can see where the high spot is and then research what is wrong with that specific area...

If your shaft is true, your dead center is true, and your chuck is true... ??????

Re: Lathe problem/question

#5

Tennon straight ?

JohnD

>I don't understand the ? tennon for your chuck straight. I always have mine tapered where the jaws contact and then flatten the rest. Assume a 1/4 inch tennon, maybe 3/32 tapered and the rest flat. Is that not right?

Re: Lathe problem/question

#6

Re: Tennon straight ?

David Breth

>More or less a follow on - if your chuck is only grabbing a small amount of surface area on the tenon (jaws too small or tenon too big), when you compress on the tenon, you may be crushing the wood with the chuck rather than grabbing hold. If this is the case, then you may find that one of the four jaws of the chuck are crushing a softer area of the tenon, and therefore causing the bowl to become slightly off center. You would also be incurring some instability in general.

There's 2-cents for you, but you've got change coming.

David B.

Re: Lathe problem/question

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Tennon straight ?

Dick Hines

>Good try with the new lathe thing Charlie. Like everyone else I think your trouble is with the tenon. Wet wood compresses at different rates on the end grain side of the tenon. Also your chuck may not be seated square on the tenon.

A question for you> Did the bowl turn true before you put it in the chuck? If it did your toruble is the tenon or chuck.

Re: Lathe problem/question

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tennon straight ?

Keith Tompkins

>Make sure the tenon is held securely. then, if after turning the blank, any minor imperfections in the tenon should be compensated for. That should compensate for any runout in the chuck as well.

do you start your blank between centers, then transfer to the chuck? If so, a bit of wobble is normal. A couple of passes with the gouge should clean it up. If not, measure for a bent spindle.

Re: Lathe problem/question

#9

Thanks guys

Charlie Anderson

>First off, this is dry wood. The bowl was rough turned about a month ago and alcohol soaked.

I put a different dead center in the headstock and it was fine. Therefore, it seems like it should be the tenon.

I took the bowl out of the chuck and didn't find anything wrong with the tenon. It could have been a bit better but the chuck did seem to have pretty much equal indentions on each of the jaws. I then remounted it, taking care to make sure it was seated properly.

This seems to have helped but I still couldn't make it completely round but I can live with this for now.

The bowl is for the turner's exchange and needs to get done soon!

Another question! Could this be a symptom of the problem?

When turning pens, I get a 'vibration in the center of the mandrel. Figured it was the mandrel problem and bought a new one, but the same thing happens. I've been very careful not to make the tailstock too tight or turn the brass nut too tight. Now I must say that the tailstock and the headstock don't exactly line up but they're pretty close - maybe 1/32 of an inch off.

Re: Lathe problem/question

#10

With respect to...

DWR

>... the head/tail stock not lining up:

Question: Does the 1/32" deviation change as you rotate the spindle or does change? If it changes, then the spindle might be bent. If it remains in the same position and at a consistant deviation, then the headstock/tailstock axis need adjustment.

If the points are off by 1/32", you will get some "off center" whipping which will create vibration and less than round turnings.

When you use both the headstock and tailstock, the material is spinning around two different axis because of the 1/32" differance.

So as one end is up, the other is down (assumming the 1/32" deviation is vertical and not horizontal) If it is horizontal then one side is right when the other is left.

You need to find out where the deviation is... the headstock or the tailstock. Try shimming one or the other until you get them spot on (assuming you have eliminated a bent spindle). I have used sandpaper on my tailstock with success. Then try a pen and bowl and see what happens.

Re: Lathe problem/question

#11

Re: With respect to...

Charlie Anderson

>When I changed dead centers, the rotation went away so I don't think there's a problem with my spindle.

I'll try shimming the tail stock and see what happens.