Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

The hardest thing to copy....

Posts

The hardest thing to copy....

#1

The hardest thing to copy....

T Daniel

>You can't copy skill! You can learn some enhancements in a day or a week, others take a little longer and sure, if you keep doing them you will get better or quicker but learning to turn a high quality piece requires skills that cannot be copied; they must be learned. You learn by getting some instruction and then it's practice, practice, practice. There are no forms that have not been done already by someone in some media; there are no finishes that have not been tried, there is no color that has not been tried. The only thing that cannot be copied is Mother Nature. There are two ways to produce unique pieces: You can develope some unique enhancement or you can learn the skills to take what Mother Nature provides you and learn how to get the best from it. This requires taking a log and cutting it at various angles and studying trial turnings from each angle; it requires cutting a crotch into various angles and turning the pieces to see which give the most figure, it requires letting a log lay in a moist area to spalt and taking a trial cut every two weeks or so until you find just how long it takes for that particular species to gain the most spectacular spalting while not being too rotten to turn, etc. You cannot learn these things from a video, a book, or in a demo; you must put a piece of wood on the lathe. After learning the characteristics of different species of woods and how to cut and align grain you must learn how to cut a fair curve, how to maintain even wall thickness, where to place shadow lines and how wide they should be, proportions, balance, etc. You can't copy all of this; you must learn it! Sorry folks, there just isn't an easy way. I think it is very unfortunate that the turning mags are skipping this and spending all their pages on enhancements and then listening to all the talk about plagarism. You cannot plagarize skill! That's my story and I am sticking to it!

TD

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#2

and AMEN I say!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#3

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

Carole in VA

>Terry,

Could you elaborate a little on "shadow lines"? This is the second time I have seen that term mentioned in the past week and I am not sure I understand what it means, but I get the distinct feeling that it is something I should know/learn about.

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#4

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

John Lucas

>carol shadow lines are those areas that create a shadow when the light shines on it. For example, putting a lip on a bowl or a V groove in the side. These are details for sure but they also create a shadow which gives the illusion of more depth. It also pulls the eye to that area. This is discussed at great length in Mike Darlow's book on design. Shadow areas are very important in spindle turning and I think that may be how it got it's name. When you look at a table leg the light usually comes from above and creates shadow on the details. Spindle turners often use little details that by themselves don't do much but when you put light on it and it creates a shadow it adds depth to the turning.

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#5

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

Carole in VA

>Thanks, John. That's what I had thought but just wanted to be sure. I'm still a little on the fence about buying any "design" books yet. I know myself well enough to know that if I am told how things "should" be, it sometimes hinders my exploration, be it right or wrong. A little later in my turning career I should be able to study those things without putting myself in a box.

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#6

Re: OK Carole, now you're ready...

JamieDonaldson

>.. for the next somewhat related topic-"negative space" as a design element!

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#7

... an notan

e

>Notan is a Japanese word that means "lightness-darkness."

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#8

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

Dinyar Chavda

>"You can look at my playbook, but you still have to meet me on the field"

Vince Lombardi, Greenbay Packers.






"Execution, execution, execution"

Unknown.


Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#9

hate to meet you on the field, dinyar!

e

>

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#10

"Talent" is pretty hard to copy too!!

Gerry in Maryland

>

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

Keith Tompkins

>Terry, you are absolutely correct....and something many aspiring craftspeople do not understand. Unfortunately, when someone posts a photo of their work, or displays it in public, the viewer only gets a glimpse of the tip of the iceburg.

I my case, I started woodworking professionally in 1971. I worked for a company that produced 300 chairs a day, every day for two shifts, in addition to a regular furniture line. I have drilled millions of holes for chair seats, legs, stretchers, etc.. I have spent WEEKS on end bandsawing furniture parts. Am I good at the bandsaw? Yes, but you would be too. I have turned untold table pedestals, chair legs, etc. professionally. I designed furniture and chairs for years, built prototypes, and then the jigs and fixtures to begin production. I have spent a lifetime learning my trade...not all glamorous: many days were sheer drudgery. I feel I have paid my dues. I bet most successful craftspeople have a similar story.

Many turners don't understand the time that has been invested in order to produce a quality piece of work. There are no shortcuts to time spent learning a craft.

Re: The hardest thing to copy....

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: OK Carole, now you're ready...

Keith Tompkins

>Good one, Jamie!