Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

Posts

REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#1

REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

Ruth Niles

>Mark Kauder posted this in Keith's thread about plagiarism but I think it should be in it's own post. This guy just took Mark's pictures from the AAW site and posted them as his own. Check out the few "new member" responses on this penshop forum; we do protect our own. http://www.penshop.net/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=341&PN=1

Mark can give more details.


http://www.penshop.net/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=341&PN=1

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#2

First Degree Plagiarism!

e

>couldn't be a better example!

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#4

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

georgetroy

>This is the real thing here. Mark got ripped off. No copies or attempting to make something like it. Showing Mark's work like his own is downright disgraceful. I know how much work goes into these segmented turnings. Mark has built up his expertise and is just know getting recognize for it. Just keep raising the level Mark. GT

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#5

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

Chuck Ludwigsen

>Ruth and -e-, thank you so much for posting this link. I signed up on that website and added to the call to have that person taken to task for what he did.

While, in general, I am for someone who is learning or practicing his/her skill turning a copy of something they saw done by someone else, I am NOT for someone claiming credit for an item or an idea that was not their own.

This post has also made me wary of what I see posted. I, for one, if I see something that looks too good to be true - from someone I don't recognize, I'll at least think twice first. I am VERY thankful that Mark had such an extensive website that you were able to make quick identification of this.

Again, thank you both for being on the ball.

Chuck in Memphis, TN.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#6

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

Carole in VA

>The Moderator has removed the photos and "attempted" to lock the thread. It's a little fishy the way the guy introduced himself to that forum as GregD from "that other forum" (IAP). I am wondering if this is the real GregD or if this guy is giving him an undeserved bad name? You never can tell. Might have been some punk trying to get someone else in trouble. He also used a nick "Penwerks" that is one letter different from a respected pen turner on IAP called "Penworks". Sick puppy.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#7

actually it's Mark who showed us ...

e

>thanks to Ruth for elevating the thread ... i just sweep-up.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#8

they can run, but they can't hide

e

>i copied the web page thread so i have it on record ... it's such a perfect example of stupidity.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#9

Re: REAL Plagiarism here -- I think not

Dinyar Chavda

>I looked at these links, and my suspicion is that this is Al Kyder's younger brother "having fun" at the expense of turners, and tweaking us. With the benefit of hindsight, some of his responses were just too glib to be real--e.g., he "just wings it and tosses it on the lathe", and then tests and "highly recommends Woodturner Pro" in a day!

You could label this as theft, fraud, or pulling our legs, but, IMOWISNU, it is not plagiarism as has been discussed in the recent threads.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#10

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

oldgriz

>I am a moderator on The Pen Shop... and please believe me that we take this kind of thing seriously...

If this member can not explain his actions he will be banned from the site... and considering the fact that I can think of no explanation for what he did... he probably will be banned...

Most of the members of the site are strictly pen turners and do not do other work at this time... so they most likely did not know Mark's work...

As a moderator of the site I would like to apologize to Mark and please do not let the stupidity of one person blacken the image of what we are trying to accomplish there...

Tom Mullane

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#11

Fraud and/or copyright infringement

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>You are right. That isn't plagiarism, it is fraud and/or copyright infringement. Different animal.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#12

Re: better link

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>That has to be the lowest thing I have ever seen on a forum short of a flaming war.......pretty sad statement to a person's self esteem if they consider theft to be acceptable....still shaking my head.

Sorry it happened to you Mark....

Take care,

Jim

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#13

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Tom,

I don't think I'd wait...it would be automatic expulsion in my mind...you should also be able to get a trace their ISP and ID.

Take care,

Jim

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#14

Now THAT'S plagiarism!

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>What a lowlife. How could someone think they'd get away with a stunt like that and more importantly, how would their conscience allow such a thing? WAY different that turning an item that resembles someone elses.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#15

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

Glenn Hodges

>I first saw Mark's work at a symposium in the Georgia mountians, and was I impressed by it. I seldom post on this forum, but read just about each one, and look at all the pictures. I have watched his work improve and always admired his character. I detest anyone that will lie or steal, I only wish I could be on this criminal's jury one day.

Nashville, GA

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#16

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

RTJW

>I am the owner of The Pen SHop. I totally detest this kind of thing and it will not be tolerated on my site. I am now waiting for him to explain his actions or apologize. After that I have a good feeling he will not be back on my forum neither will he be rejoinging our group because his IP address will be banned. We will not tolerate these type of people. The good thing is he has been found out and every forum he is on will know what he has done.


http://www.thepenshop.net

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#17

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

Ron in Drums PA

>He hoodwinked me, I'm real sorry Mark, I should have realized by the quality they where yours.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#18

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

Johnny Wooten (RTJW)

>I have received an email from him. He will be posting again on the site today he said. If you wanna have a really good discussion please come join in. It ought to be fun. he says that those bowls are actually his and he worked really hard at doing them to look exactly like Marks. he said that should be a testament to his knowledge and skills. I will let the discussion go so that everyone can have their say, then I will take care of the matter! I think it is an issue that needs to be discussed about and that it should be taken seriously. Plagairism will not be tolerated on our site and I dont think it should be on any site.


http://www.thepenshop.net

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#19

well, if he's claiming the pictures are his own ..

e

>.. then he's a sick wacko ... pixel-by-pixel, the photos are EXACT copies from Mark's web site --

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#20

a public apology has been posted

e

>however rather inadequate ... i wanted to see much more pleading!

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#21

Re: a public apology has been posted

Chuck Ludwigsen

>I want to see more humility AND MARK'S LAST NAME SPELLED CORRECTLY before I'll even consider the apology as genuine. The form of the mis-spelling was insulting but could have been and accident. Given his actions, I doubt it.

Chuck in Memphis, TN.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#22

Re: well, if he's claiming the pictures are his ow

Carole in VA

>Exactly! Right down to tiny reflections and dust specks! I can't believe that guy!

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#23

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

Molly Winton

>Hey Tom, I agree wholeheartedly with Jim. This is not something that can be 'explained' to any level of satisfaction, and he should have been swiftly banned. Your site has very clear parameters to register and be allowed to post. You can't post unless you agree to them. He blatantly violated that agreement. End of story.

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#24

Hey John

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi John,

Well He's soon found out that woodworkers and woodturners are a tight community....but don't cross us....I respect that your site has been the place that it happened, it looks like it could happen anywhere...given that I do hope that your new site suffers no ill will and is successful!!

take care,

Jim

Re: REAL Plagiarism here *LINK*

#25

Re: REAL Plagiarism here

RevDoug

>It is a real shame that this troubled troll has access to a computer. Way too many issues to discuss in this forum. As soon as I saw Ruth's message, I went to the site. The pictures had been returned so that folks could see what the fuss was about. I knew the pieces. They could only have been Mark's.

Mark you do such nice work. Simply beautiful. It should be a real compliment to you that it was recognized so quickly. You have truely developed a style and level of recognition so many of us are striving for. I thank you for raising the bar on segmented material to such a level.

This troll will get his due.

Turn 'em round,