Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Creativity vs. Plagiarism

Posts

Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#1

Keith Tompkins

Creativity vs. Plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>To me, it seems the problem really isn't plagiarism, but rather a lack of creativity and imagination. This lack of creativity often leaves no choice but to rely on the work of others for inspiration.

While I firmly believe design principles can be taught, harnessing one's creative side isn't quite so easy. Some people have an abundance of creative ability, some have very little.

When asked where he got his ideas, Henry Ford replied..."Ideas are everwhere..all I have to do is pluck one out of the air." He easily visualized new methods of production and better ways to engineer his products. He had a gift that isn't learned, it's hard wired in.

From my experience, it's fairly easy to show someone how to produce a good form. Even if it takes transferring measurments from one form to the next, or by using templates...it can be done. In that way almost anyone can produce a reasonable form. find a great form, and emulate it. Nothing wrong with that.

It's another story to ask a student to visualize a piece in their head in advance...and consider the effect that subtle changes would produce.Even harder, to visualize the piece, and mentally cut it in half. Then mentally rotate the pieces, examining them from all angles....then further cut it up and reassemble it. Many students I have seen cannot grasp the concept, where it seems to come naturally to me...my best ideas seem to come out of thin air.

Where does this leave those who haven't harnessed their creative energy? Can it be taught? Can someone learn to focus in on their creative abilities? Is creativity something that has simply been discouraged in us since we were in school..in favor of standardized education formats?

Have all the great songs been written? Have all the great books been written? Have all the great turnings already been produced? I don't think so..they are there, just waiting to be produced.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#2

Re: Creativity

John Lucas

>Keith I think it can be taught but takes time. You have to get the students to collect photographs, drawings, etc of things they find interesting. Then you work with them to try and show them how to make things from these ideas.

It really boils down to observing things around you. If you take notes of these things, whether it's little sketches or copying a photo out of a magazine, you will get a collection of ideas. I sit down occasionally and go through my file which is huge. I will often get an idea for something I can do to whatever style I'm turning at the present. Sometimes I get new ideas while I'm looking through these files and then I have to make some more sketches so I won't forget these ideas.

You would be amazed at how many turning ideas you can get from just looking through the Helig Meyer add sheet in the sunday paper.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#3

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

georgetroy

>Hi Keith,

I think these subjects of Creativity, Plagiarism, copying, etc. doing your own thing is being beat to death. If I see your work and others deep down that is an influence. When I go to a department store and see the glass work and pottery that is an influence. I have been turning for over 20 years taking lessons from the pros and going to regional symposuiums. I can turn, burn, carve , paint and do a good job with it. But it may not look like others work even through it is close. A curve is a curve some looks better than others. I can create a drawing on a computer and go excute it to a solid piece, segmented piece, pierced, painted, carved, but I will never be a Rembrandt or some other famous artist. I don't like to be reminded of that. Showing a simple drawing that a woodturner can do a lot with. Does it have a perfect curve. Has somebody else done it. Frankly I don't care. You want more drawings. I can do them by the hundred. GT


img

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#4

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It seems to me that creativity is like any other human attribute. People span the spectrum from �super-creative� to �tell-me-exactly-what-to-do-and-how-to-do-it�. The old bell-shaped curve. Education and/or training will improve innate ability, but can not replace the spark that simply isn�t there.

It�s been mentioned many times in past discussions: Truly creative people have too many ideas of their own to waste time copying someone else�s idea. They might independently create the same thing that someone else has � but that�s not plagiarism, it is independent invention. The proof is in the path taken, not the end result.

For others, creating something new is a monumental struggle. And then to discover that a dozen (or a hundred, or a thousand) other people have developed the same thing�. Well, what�s the point in working so hard to do something �new� only to find that it has already been done a thousand times?

There�s a good reason why woodworking magazines contain so many step-by-step how-to-do-it articles.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>HI George, Judging by the e-mails I received, this post may be offensive to some, although I certainly didn't mean it that way. Posts that pertain to design really get my interest; I may get a bit overenthusiastic at times.

My posts about drawing forms are primarily geared for the newbie turner, who make up a large percentage of the posters here. It's just one way to (hopefully) help someone appreciate design as well as technique. Many turners, yourself included, are past the point where they need to consider drawing each form they produce.

Thinking about it, I have had some bad experiences with one of my patents; someone basically stole one of my ideas...not related to turning. Naturally,the topic of plagiarism is a sore topic for me...and probably influenced my post.

I considered the topic of creativity a hypothetical one, not a personal attack. Just an observation that some people have trouble in that department. Since I teach woodturning on a regular basis, creativity is a topic that I'm asked about , and I attempt to help others expand their horizons. It's a difficult thing to attempt.

George, If I upset you I certainly appologize. Keith

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#6

Previsualization

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>The need for previsualization when creating a form is most easily satisfied by looking at other people's work, and ways to get around that and avoid the copying scenario is to include in your teaching the use of tools that aid that previsualization and creation of form and design in a fresh, original way. Starting with a clean, white canvas, so to speak.

Like George Troy, and many other turners, I consider the computer a valuable tool for this. Just about every computer comes with a basic drawing program--the bezier curve can be used to draw one half of the profile, duplicated, reversed, and joined with the first in a process that's one of the easiest to learn for even the most computer-challenged.

For the more advanced folks, stepping up to a 3D graphics program opens up many new possibilities. There are many such programs available, some free. A few of them have a lathe feature--draw a profile just like in the 2D program, and with a couple clicks of the mouse, voila--you have a 3D shape that can be rotated, resized, stretched, or squashed in any dimension. Do a google for "lathe.zip" and you'll find one basic, free program that does quite well.

The more advanced 3D programs have a steeper learning curve but are well worth it if you are motivated. It took me about a year of playing around before I could create the graphic below, done with a freely available demo of FormZ:


img

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Previsualization

Keith Tompkins

>Ken, good ideas...the problem is, I'm terrible on the computer. Your image blows me away, I would be lost.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Brian, Luckily, we're all different. Building a reproduction grandfather clock may be the pinnacle of someone's career. The same project would hold no interest for another . there's nothing wrong with building something from a plan, the enjoyment of creating something with your own hands is the same. Good craftsmanship will alway show.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Creativity

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks John, I should go through my stacks of papers and drawings...

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#10

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism - check this *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>This guy did not even bother to turn a copy of my work, he just posted pics from my website as his.

Mark


http://www.thepenshop.net/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=341&PN=1

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#11

Unbelievable!

Carole in VA

>I still can't believe he did that Mark. I notice there is a "Report" button on the top right of each post. Did you report him?

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#12

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

Dinyar Chavda

>After reading all these posts on plagiarism/copying/creativity, both here and on WOW, I have distilled the arguments that have been made down to the following key facts on which there seems to be general agreement:

1. We woodturners make objects, almost all (if not all) have been made before, either in wood by people using turning or non-turning techniques (e.g., carving), or in some other media (pottery, glass, etc.).

2. If a woodturner duplicates an object that has been made by another turner, that is considered copying/plagiarism/lack of creativity, i.e,. a bad thing.

3. If a woodturner duplicates an object that has been made by a craftsman/artist who is not a turner, that may be creativity/art/craftsmanship, i.e., a good thing.

Conclusion: Woodturners have an incredibly myopic viewpoint, and we should, occasionally, venture outside our workshops.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#13

Creativity and spontaneity

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Until I started posting on forums and talking to other turners I thought everyone just threw whatever piece came to hand on the lathe and went for it.Starting out I had a hard time sketching a piece because once I had it where I wanted it I lost interest and moved on to the next idea.I had to force myself to make multiples in order to get over that.I was surprised to find most folks plan things out to the smallest detail.

I still will choose whatever blank I want to turn and don`t really plan anything till I round the blank up and remove whatever defects I can`t live with,align the grain/figure again if need be and then proceed.

I think TD hit it when he said the big challenge is in the wood.It takes years of experience to know where and how to cut in order to get the best from the material and it starts with selecting and dropping the tree.I`m amazed that some of the more advanced turners I`ve met have absolutely no idea how to process a log or cut for the best figure.A whole burl just throws them into cold sweats.

For me it`s being able to dictate what is going to happen right from the start,well before anything is even close to being put on the lathe.Maybe I was fortunate in starting out that way because that`s the way the few turners I knew did it.

BTW-Out of the several hundred local turners(some of them big names) I know who all seem to talk about plagarism I have only ever heard one actually accuse someone of it.When he did the rest of us thought it was rediculous and told him so.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#14

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism - check this

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Well, there's NERVE, and then STUPIDITY but when they're both combined, it's CRIMINAL.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#15

Patent infringement

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I've experienced patent infringement as well. Two competitors marketed products that appeared to be based on an idea that we had patented. One competitor settled out of court, the other went to trial and the final result was that they had infringed.

To me, that simply is the nature of the game in a competitive business environment.

The patent will expire a number of years from now. Then everyone will be free to use the idea. It will be in the public domain. Plagiarism and/or infringement will be issues that no longer apply. And that's the way that it is.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#16

Yes!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Great summary. You've captured much of my frustration with this issue.

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#17

Excellent point Dinyar!

Gerry in Maryland

>

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#18

Re: Contrary

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>to any popular belief, and probably good for the rest of us,

there are very few SMART criminals.

M

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#19

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism - check this

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Mark

I've been where you are. It was almost 10 years ago, and there were only five of us on the web selling wood pens. I used to visit the sites of my competitors on a regular basis, and I am sure they did the same - especially the one guy. I signed onto his site one day, and there on his front page was my wooden box! It wasn't just a box I made, it was one that I had sitting on my desk, laser engraved with my company logo and name! He had taken my picture, electronically erased my company name, and replaced it with his own, keeping the tree logo!

Not only that, he was representing it as a box he had for sale. Now, my boxes were different than anything anyone else was selling or making, but even if he had copied me, he had copied it all, right down to the very small defect in the one corner of the box. And his prices made it very clear that he was not making boxes like mine.

I wrote him a very blunt email, and then called him on the phone (long distance to Californa) and left a message. To his credit, he called me back in very short order and apologized profusely for his act. He said that his desire for a good picture overruled his judgement, and he took the picture. He also told me his wife the lawyer ripped him up one side and down the other for doing something so blatantly illegal. Things can get weird, and we actually ended up corresponding on a friendly basis, to the point where he warned me off from a scammer coming from the far east, who ordered pens in $5000 quantities, and then did not pay. Sure enough, the guy contacted me, just like those Nigerians with millions of dollars from long lost relatives.

I hope this all works out well for you, and that the criminal is duly taken to task for his transgression. Unfortunately, people like this often show they have no conscience whatsoever, and he may be signing on as someone else in short order. So much for anonymity.

Bill

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#20

Re: Different Trees, Different Fruit

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Brian,

Don't confuse patent rights with copyright issues. Patents "live" for a set number of years; 17, I seem to remember. They are essentially restrictions on potentially commercial ideas for products or processes and the relatively short time span is based, in part, on the theory that the idea will be useless after that time because it will have become obsolete or "old technology" with no commercial potential.

But copyrights can last forever, or at least for the life of the creator. Authors and image makers can go after someone who "uses" their work (for monetary gain) without permission at any time. Jamie Donaldson will share his trip down Intellectual Property Lane with you if you have a few days to kill.

In both cases, it is the originator or holder of the idea's "rights" who may go after the misappropriator to halt the use and obtain money damages.

Plagiarism is different from the other concepts because it is a "charge" brought by third parties, and can arise anew at each instance of the violative behavior FOREVER. It is completely independent of whether the idea, image, or thing is patented, copyrighted, or whatever. Were I to lift a line from a Shakespere play and insert into my own writing WITHOUT ACKNOWLEDGING WHERE IT CAME FROM, 'Ol Will's not around to sue me for copyright infringement. However, I'm likely to get kicked out of school, or at least get a "flag" in the course, or be held up in the literary/academic community as dishonest and an idea thief who cannot be trusted to put forth original work. I avoid the entire problem by simply writing "To be, or not to be! [W. Shakespere, Hamlet, Act#/Scene#]"

Plagiarism is NOT my illegal/unauthorized USE of some else's ideas, it's the FAILURE TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE FIRST PERSON'S ORIGINALITY because the failure to do so gives the impression to others, intentionally or otherwise, that the idea/image/work is new and original work by me.

The whole issue is easy to avoid. Say I like Andi Wolfe's work. I go to a demonstration or symposium, and watch and see how she does things. I go home, dive into the shop, and out comes a carved bowl with Prismacolored oak leaves. Now I flip it over and put "Mark Mandell, 01/05/06" on the bottom. If I'm going to avoid the charge of "Plagiariser!", I also put "Inspired by Andi Wolfe" on the bottom. Done. |;-}

"Okay," you say, "So if you don't put your name on it, then you don't have to put Andi's on either, right?" Wrong. If I'm going to acknowledge that I made the bowl, I must acknowledge Andi's influence. Remember too, that simple acknowledgement does two things. First, and MOST importantly, it signals to everyone who looks at MY bowl, that I am a fundamentally honest person who can be trusted. Second, it confirms that I have due regard for my fellow human beings and have the right to expect others to treat me in the same way.

"Okay," you say, "So if I use 150,000 year old cave painting images as enhancements on my pot, I'm supposed to acknowledge some hairy proto-human knuckle-walker whose name, if he ever had one, is long gone in the wind?" Nope. But if you think about it, you'll see that the question is obsurd in the context of what we're all talking about.

Rant OFF

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#21

I agree

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Three different animals, three different sets of rules.

Unfortunately, they sometimes are confused. I hope your "rant" will help clear the air.

Brian

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#22

PS

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I think the life of a patent was changed back in the early 90's and the number 28 years keeps popping into my head. But I've been out of that game for years. When in doubt, consult a patent attorney. ;-)

Re: Creativity vs. Plagiarism

#23

Good Advice

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But it'll cost you!

|;-}}}