Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Dave Smith or others - Help

Posts

Dave Smith or others - Help

#1

Dave Smith or others - Help

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>I turn a lot of wet wood and use alcohol (methyl Hydrate) to dry my rough turned pieces. I must say that it works great. Your drying system is the best of any.

My question is: I have some spalted maple that I am in the process of turning. Will the soaking in alcohol or MH kill the fungus, making it safer to finish turning when dry?

Thanks,

Norm

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#2

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

Dale Cook

>Hi Dave, I believe that when the wood gets below about 20% moisture the fungus dies or can't exist.So between the alcohol and drying well below that it should stop.

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#3

Alcohol should take care of the fungus.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Norm,

Most living organisms don't like to be dehydrated. I assume fungus is one of them. I don't know what effect alcohol has on spores if any are present in the wood. I assume they would also be dehydrated and thus non viable.

I would consider the wet wood more of a threat than dry wood for inhalation of live fungus.

Dave Smith

Fungus love this wet weather in Longview, WA.

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#4

Re: Alcohol should take care of the fungus.

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Thanks Dave and Dale,

I thought so but wasnt sure. I wear a good mask while turning but was concerned about the dust while finishing the dry wood.

Thanks,

Norm

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#5

No, No, No

Shawn - in ID

>Soaking in alcohol will NOT take care of the problems associated with spalted wood. First, the soaking procedures most woodturners are using just aren't very extensive - you'd have to change out to fresh pure alcohol several times over many days to be complete. Either way...sure, you'll kill a few of the organisms and make many of them go dormant. But when those buggers get into the moist depths of your bronchioles and alveoli - bam, back to life just like sea monkies in water! One last time, you have NO (or vanishingly little) health benefit to soaking spalted wood in alcohol.

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#6

Re: No, No, No

David Breth

>So if somebody has, for example, a half log of spalted maple sitting in a garage that is dry and seasonally cold, is there a significant health concern associated with turning it? Or with introducing things you might not like having in your house?

David B.

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#7

Um . . . No [Apparently] Long

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>David,

I have asked your question of a mycologist [fungal organism specialist], an ENT(ist) [Ear, Nose & Throat], and a pulmonologist [lung specialist] I got the same answer each time:

"There has not been a single documented infection of a human being by wood-rot fungi - NOT ONE."

Make no mistake, fungal infections can be very serious, even deadly, and it's been something of a race to find drugs that will kill the kind of fungi that do infect humans before they (the drugs) kill the patient. Fungi are highly specialized organisims that are keyed to specific locations. The MD told me that was no way I had enough wood dust lodged in my lungs that would be needed to support the growth of wood fungi there. It is not just warmth and moisture that makes/allows the fungus to grow; it must also have its special food. Wood fungi feed on the lignin and sugars in the wood; both of which had better not be in your lungs to start with.

That's all not to say, however, that you may have an allergic reaction to rotten wood just as many people are higly sensitive to molds, mildew or other dusts like walnut or cocobolo. Reasonable precautions when working with spalted wood, like any other potential sensitizer, are just good shop procedure.

If you want direct information, look up a mycologist or infectious disease specialist in your area and ask your question again. I'm not one nor have I slept in a Holiday Inn (Express or otherwise) in many years. |;-}}

Mark

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#8

Re: Um . . . No [Apparently] Long

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>I once worked for a munisipal government. There was one alderman who always had an opinion on any topic that came up at a meeting. The only problem was that his opinion was always the same as that of the person that he last spoke to regarding that topic. It seems as though I am doing the same thing with this topic. Every response I read seems reasonable until I read the next. You are right though, I should go to an expert in the science field.

Thanks all for your help.

Norm

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#9

mark, I'd want a second opinion!

e

>"Only in the past decade or less have we begun to understand the

potential health risks associated with exposure to toxic mold contamination. Spores can be inhaled, absorbed through the skin or ingested on our food. And, because some people are more susceptible than others, one person may become debilitated by exposure to mold in the home, another person sharing the same environment is essentially unaffected...."

there is a known risk of working in or around mold ... my doctor tells me to minimize the risk ... reduce the amount of spores being imported into my environment, keep cross-contamination down, reduce exposure ... sounds like common sense

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#10

Re: That's Why

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I said to consult an expert on fungal infections for first hand knowledge. I'd really like to hear back on what he is told.

There are millions of fungi, some harmful, some not. Many are yummy, but the few that spalt wood have not, so far as I have discovered from those who aught to know, been a problem for people.

And they're not molds; that's a whole different class of organisms. I am allergic to a number of molds, and react adversely to mildew. Spalted wood doesn't bother me in the least.

If spalted wood was as dangerous as some seem to think, turners (who use it more than all others) would have been dropping like, well, trees, because all the nifty masks, powered helmut ventilators, and mini-micron filters and such that people talk about for turning would all be useless. The dust and spores (active or dormant) released by turning and sanding that wood will permeate your clothing and settle on every surface in your shop (unless your cross-ventilation happens to be in an active wind tunnel |;-}} ]. Take off your mask after turning, walk back into your home, and you're depositing those fungal spores everywhere you go as well as breathing them. You house, the carpets, and upholstery are all loaded with those spores you brought in from the shop.

I wear a good dust mask to reduce the amount of dust I breath. I have a DC that returns no air to the shop running while I'm sanding as well as a whole-house blower rigged as an air cleaner using the zipity-do-dah filters that runs while I'm in my basement shop. I actually vacuum the shop once or twice a month, and pick the big stuff up before quitting for the day. I do not, however, kid myself into believing that I'm not inhaling any dust or fungal spores from the spalted wood I've worked with for over 30 years.

If wood-rot fungus were infectious, I'd have been dead long ago.

M

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#11

you heard my giardia story ...

e

>it's a good tale that demonstrates some of these concerns.

this happened several years ago when i had just started turning. i had my tea mug on the bench while i turned some oak that had been down in a field for a few weeks. a very small amount of bark and shavings landed in my cup; after awhile, i fished out the shavings and drank the remaining tea ... my first lesson in possible contamination - in my ignorance, i'd gulped down a petri-dish of rapidly growing single-celled parasites!

giardia is bad and i was ill for some time but it certainly was effective in developing my awareness of what i might be exposed to in the studio.

now, after this experience, one might expect to see me running around in a tyvek suit, afraid of what monster lurks beneath the bark ... hardly. but because i'm more aware of what's under the bark, i can adjust my behavior to reduce the risk ... no different than washing my hands after touching a grocery cart (yuk).

here's some info on giarchia

http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dpd/parasites/giardiasis/factsht_giardia.htm

since mold spores become air-bourne, it's more important to understand how to reduce the contamination -- and how NOT to cross-contaminate (such as bringing the spores from the studio into the house and car).

simple solutions, such as spraying the wood with a 10% solution of clorox BEFORE bringing it into the studio can significantly reduce the number of spores.

bugs are all around us ... the key to survival is to learn which ones to stay clear of :>)

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#12

Doctors & Dust

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That little bug is common and nasty. Had a backpacker friend who had done most of the Appalachen Trial, and decided to do some Colorado walking. Took her something like a year on the meds to finally kick the paracite she picked up in the "lovely mountain stream."

The last time I was at "my" ENT doctor, I asked him about resperators, powered this and that, and several of the options I see people on the net swearing by after telling him about my dust collector. He hands me one of his disposable "doctor masks" and tells me to go home.

I said "Wait a minute, what about all this .1 micron rating and such." He says, "That's all fine [no pun] and technically very true, but, with one exception, you don't need it for a hobby wood shop unless you're in there sanding all day or working in a cloud of dust so dense it would be hard to see." "OK, I'll bite," say I, "What's the exception?" "If you're working with material to which you're sensitive or allergic." "Oh," sez I.

Then he asks me "Do you strip, shower, and put on clean clothes BEFORE you leave the shop and bag the dusty ones for the laundry?" "No," sez I. He asks, "How often do you vacuum clean all your shop surfaces with a super vac fitted with one of those .1 micron filters you asked me about?" I reply "I vacuum clean the shop about once a month, but not the ceiling, rafters, pipes, conduit and other nooks and crannies, and not with a "super-vac", why?"

He chuckles and says, "And you're asking ME about wood dust hazzard masks?"

I still wear my Resp-O-Rator when I'm sanding.

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#13

Correction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I included a statement to the effect that the white-rot fungi, the only ones that cause spalting, eat lignin and sugars. That is incorrect. They "eat" cellulose and hydrocarbons, but turn lignin into carbon dioxide so that they can get to the cellulose.

Google "white rot" to find out a whole lot more.

Mark

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#14

Re: Doctors & Dust

Barry Irby

>Mark your comments match exactly with what I have filtered out of the hype in my business. My real Job is Home Inspector, which I do to support my wood working hobby. Not a week goes by that some "lab" doesn't contact me wanting me to be their local Inspector. I would take samples in all the houses I inspect and they would tell me what they were and how they should be treated. And we would both make big bucks.

What I have gleaned is that Mold needs four things, Warmth, moisture, a food source, and oxygen. Five if you count the spore, but they are ubiquitous, everywhere and universal. There are at least a 100,000 types of mold and bout thirty have been identified as harmful to humans. Part of the training for mold inspectors covers the fact that mold is almost completely specific about its food source. Your supposition that mold that thrives on wood will not thrive in your lungs exactly matches with my experience and training. Also, if you are allergic to a mold, you will have the same reaction to it whether it is dead or alive, at least initially. Your immune system does not wait to determine if it is alive, it just goes into high gear when it sinuses the shape of the shell of the mold. Thus, killing it and causing it to crumble and float in the air might increase your reaction.

I don't do mold inspections, because I think the jury is still out on the situation, but I am trying to keep my shop cleaner and am improving the ventilation and filtration and wear the mask more, but I have been in there along time and would have died years ago if dust would kill you, even spalted dust. OTOH, I am shocked at the difference and wonder how I got along without the cleaner air. I am sometimes stunned when I forget to open a blast gate on a tool.

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#15

Re: Inspectications

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>He He.

I know several guys who were gearing up for TOXIC MO-O-OLD REMEDIATION!!!![picture housewife clutching newborn running from hairy blob oozing out of the windows of their formerly happy home in suburbia] as the next great opportunity in the fly-by-night divisions of the real estate & home improvement industries now that radon has kind of petered out.

They decided not to spend any money on correspondence course degrees and certificates because the hype was dying down too fast, and a couple of "operators" and small labs in this area got prosecuted and nailed for insurance fraud.

|;-}}

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#16

Again - NO!

Shawn - in ID

>Mark,

I don't want to start an arguement but I also know that just because a person has a degree doesn't mean they know what they are talking about. I'm a physiologist and my life is research, but there is a lot even in my own little niche that I don't know. I saw a cardiologist last year who told me that exercise training does not alter the dimensions of the heart - I'm currently looking at 3 text-books on my shelf that reference hundreds of studies over 60 years documenting numerous adaptations - I've even published one of them. I just did a quick search and found at least a dozen peer-reviewed published papers (in journals as prominent as Chest) documenting human lung infections from wood fungus. Now, I'm not saying that the fungus on any particular person's turning wood is going to infect them and kill them - but infection and complications are documented. Moreover, my primary point was that alchohol soaking a rough turned bowl isn't going to significantly reduce the viability of the colony if they are put back in a suitable environment (there is plenty of evidence of that). The lungs may a poor environment for wood fungus and a healthy immune system will take care of any problems usually...but given the right circumstances and wood fungus has become a pulmonary problem for some people.

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#17

You are both correct

T Daniel

>When I got a severe lung infection in 1997 my doctor said it was "hyper-sensitivity pneumatitis". He explained that it was like an allergy....that is, it might bother one person and not affect the next at all. He said I could have gotten it by walking thru dry leaves, getting near bird droppings, etc. The wood dust was just one of many possibilities of where the infection came from. Staying out of the dust has never hurt anyone.

TD

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#18

Re: Aside

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Shawn,

I'm send you an e-mail.

M

Re: Dave Smith or others - Help

#19

Re: Inspectications

Barry Irby

>Radon? How about lead paint, aluminum siding, vinyl siding, replacement windows, Uffi insulation, liquid siding, clear coating for Asphalt shingles, Etc. I was in a meeting with local Regulators and they were wondering where the next "trend" would be.