Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Tearout? when turning

Posts

Tearout? when turning

#1

Tearout? when turning

Arw01

>Took a few minutes of "lessons" from a friend of mine yesterday on my mini. Showed me a couple of basics, I packed up and moved on back home. Today I started doing some work with the Mini Windsor Design set he loaned me on a Purple Heart pen blank, and a blank of Beech my son desired a "light saber" out of.

Both exhibited what I would consider tear out from using the gouge.

I was using the slowest speed, and wondering if this is a feature of technique or a dull tool or?

I touched up the edge just a bit on a course diamond stone and did not observe a difference in the surface, but it did cut quicker.

Re: Tearout? when turning

#2

Re: Tearout? when turning

Allen Neighbors

>Well, I haven't seen any responses to your questions, and I've never turned a pen, but I'll comment, for what it's worth.

When I turn a small handle for my wife's sewing friends "stillettos", I got quite a bit of tearout, until I learned to hold the cutting edge at an angle. (I was actually scraping, instead of slicing the wood). I learned to set the bevel against the wood, and rotate the gouge until it began to slice, and holding the handle so the cutting edge was at about a 45 degree angle.

Maybe that'll help you, maybe not. Good luck. AL

Re: Tearout? when turning

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tearout? when turning

Keith Tompkins

>Make sure the tool is sharp....grind the edge, then hone. Purple heart is a nasty customer, especially to a new turner. Use the tool in a cutting action rather than scraping...if you aare holding the edge at ninety degrees to the turning with only the tip cutting, you are scraping. joining a local turning club will speed the learning process immensely..

Re: Tearout? when turning

#4

Re: Tearout? when turning

alan womack

>I was engaging the piece at 90, rotating my wrist to use different portions of the full width of the gouge to even out the wear. I will give it a try from an angle.

Thanks for the hints.

Re: Tearout? when turning

#5

Re: Tearout? when turning

Carole in VA

>For pens and other small spindle work, crank your speed up. (Wear a face shield)and cut with the grain. Your tools need to be sharp, preferably sharpened on a grinder with a jig like the Wolverine. I use a skew chisel on pens and spindles, but there is a bit of a learning curve to using a skew so practice first and if you can, watch Alan Lacer's video.

Re: Tearout? when turning

#6

Re: Tearout? when turning

Niedling

>I had an entry level turner give me some purplehart pen blanks. A week later he asked me, If I had tried it yet. He complained that he was getting bad tearout. I decided to give his blanks a try and quickly found out that he cut the blank cross grain rather than the wood grain running down the length of the pen. I could not get a clean cut with the gouge. It took a very sharp skew and light cuts to turn the blank. He never thought about the grain orientation of the blank, he was just trying to get the most blanks out the piece of wood he had purchased.

Re: Tearout? when turning

#7

Re: Tearout? when turning

John Lucas

>All excellent answers. I'll add one more. Don't force the cut. It's easy to push the tool the make it cut and even though it does remove wood it won't cut the wood cleanly. Relax your grip, hold the gouge so it is slicing the wood(the cutting edge is about 45 to 60 degrees to the wood rotation) and then just let the tool tell you how hard to push. If you are turning at a very slow speed you are probably pushing the cut. If you turn the speed up the cut will naturally go a little faster and you won't force the cut as much.

Re: Tearout? when turning

#8

Re: Tearout? when turning *LINK*

RussFairfield

>There are 3 things you might want to be doing,

Go to the linked pages for a e-book on turning wood. They are saying the same things as these messages, except there is more detail and diagrams.

Learn how to turn wood on something besides Purpleheart. Cut some twigs from yard trees, or square pieces ripped from a Pine 2x4.

Spend some more time with your friend.


http://www.turningtools.co.uk/wtintro/wtintro.html

Re: Tearout? when turning

#9

Re: Tearout? when turning

eaglesc

>I have never received a license to operate a gouge.

I epitomize wht the tool is named as such.

I use a round nose scraper haned on a diamond stone for most of my"roughing" worw and then use a skew honed on a diamond stone.

My methods are unorthadox but have been successful.

Have never seen a need for $80.00 sharpening aid to turn a pen made from a $1.79 kit.

A lot of my blanks come from glue ups I make from other woodworkers "trash"

I give little attention to whether I use end grain long grain or cross grain other than I like to alternate to get different effects.

With pens CA as a hrdner is a great help.

I have never had any problem with PH other than it is a porous wood and required more sanding and "filling" prior to finishing.Much like walnut.

My.02 but then again I only turn pens.


img

Re: Tearout? when turning

#10

Re: Tearout? when turning

Barry Turner

>Crank the speed up to one of the mid-range speeds. For small diameter work like pens, lower speeds are hardly ever advisable. Reserve the low speeds for larger diameter roughing and bowls. Sharpen tool(s) again. Whenever possible use cutting rather than scraping tools, ie. gouges and skews rather than a round nose scraper. Roll the gouge over on it's side so that you are really cutting, not scraping. Adjust the angle of the skew until you get tightly-curled shavings. Good luck.

Re: Tearout? when turning

#11

Re: Tearout? when turning

eaglesc

>Try the round nose scraper if what you have been doing isn't working,it may save you$80.00

($23.00 for a Diamond stone with two grits at the Blue Borg)

Re: Tearout? when turning

#12

Re: Tearout? when turning

Barry Turner

>It's hard to argue with success, but as I recall it wasn't your successes that caused you to begin this thread.

While $80 may sound high for a sharpening jig to sharpen the tools needed to turn a $1.49 pen, it's very much on the low side to what you really need if you are going to be a serious woodturner. To do that, you have to learn to turn, but you also have to learn to sharpen well at the same time. And to sharpen well, you have to have the right equipment.

Round nose scrapers can be used successfully for a number of tasks. Unfortunately, roughing out blanks is not one of them.

While I admire your "Devil May Care" approach to turning, until you start paying attention to grain direction, etc., you will continue to have the kinds of problems you wrote about. Good luck.

CA, as you have discovered, can be very helpful. Honing your round nose scraper may work well for you, but try using it straight from the grinder or belt sander. It's much faster than honing and the burr left by the grinder cuts very well. You are probably honing it away.

Re: Tearout? when turning

#13

Re: Tearout? when turning

eaglesc

>Boy are you confused!

The guy who started this thread wasn't using a round nose scraper.

I am the one who uses a scraper.

With success I might add.I have been told I turn pretty well but evidently not enough for "bowl turners" Who have all the right tools.

(I suspect you pay more attenion to the name on the tool as ooposed to be able to turn with "sub par" tools.

I highly endorse Harbor feight chisels.

I have always had the impression that bowl turners think of pencrafters as "red headed step children".Thank you for proving my suspicions.

Serious about turning?

If one doesn"t turn bowls evidently one is not a "serious turner"?

People have never sharpend a tool without a motor?

I believe you are full of yourself

From a nonserious turner I will leave you with this.

BTW grain in ALL directions.Roughed wqith a round nose scraper from Harbor feight sharpened on a diamond stone.


img