Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Critique the Old Guy

Posts

Critique the Old Guy

#1

Critique the Old Guy

Allen Neighbors

>I've taken no classes on turning, or form. So far, that's out of my reach. I have three or four things that I'm inviting critique on. Help me out... I don't bleed easily, but please don't cuss me :o) The first one is my first goblet, about 5 inches tall, by about an inch-an-a-half wide, thickness varies from about 1/16th to 1/8th at the bottom. It's made of red, aromatic, cedar.


img

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#2

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Allen Neighbors

>This second goblet is made of mesquite, 7" tall, 3.5" wide.

All of these are finished with lacquer.


img

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#3

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Allen Neighbors

>This last one is, I guess, a hollow form of sorts. It's modeled after an indian waterpot, except the bottom isn't entirely round. It's made of ash, and about 1//4 to 3/8 thick, throughout. I can tell you the inside isn't smooth, by any stretch of the imagination. I just don't know how to do that yet. My lathe won't go slow enough for TD's gravel trick.


img

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#4

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Allen Neighbors

>BTW, this mesquite goblet is 1/8" thick throughout.

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#5

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Arch

>Hi Allen, Nice work. More to the point; do you _give_ classes? Arch

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#6

Re: Critique the Old Guy

RussFairfield

>You are almost there on the goblets. The cup and the base are fine, but work on getting rid of that straight steck in between. You are gwetting close on the 2nd one, but it would add ellegance if the stem were a gentle flowing curve without the straight section going into the bottom of the cup.

Keep up the good work, but work on those stems.

Just another old guy's opinion.

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#7

Re: Critique the Old Guy

RussFairfield

>Since you asked, the form looks OK but the top spout looks out of place. It seems to me that it should be about half that height, or about 3 times taller. As it is, it just looks awkward. Also, that bead at the lip distracts from what would otherwise br a nice natural form.

Again, just one old guy's opinion. Others will have something different to say about it.

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#8

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I like the second goblet best, and agree with Russ about the stem. A long curve instead of a straight line would be more visually interesting, and we all like curves, don't we? ;)

On the hollow vessel, the flatness on the top below the neck is a little disturbing. I think the height of the neck would have been more acceptable if the top of the body had continued it's curve up, then into a reverse ogee curve out to the lip.

Only 52, so my opinion may not count as much as the other guys ;)

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#9

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Allen Neighbors

>I thank you for your critiques. I have read a lot of both of your comments on WC, and I have been all over Russ' Corner, and I value both of your comments.

I'll try to remember about the flat spots. And as far as the neck (of the hollow form) is concerned, maybe if I had continued the curve up as Ken suggested, the neck would have been about the right size/length... I think I sanded the underside of the lip too much, and made it appear to have a little bead on it, rather than turn it there. I've learned from this, I think, we'll see how it takes up here in this thick skull... Thanks again.

AL

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#10

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Allen Neighbors

>Arch, you are just trying to be nice.... the only think I could probably teach well is how n-o-t to do something... but thanks anyway.

AL

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#11

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Russ, that's the second time I've seen you refer to yourself as the old guy. Feeling a little stiff in the joints are we?

Wally

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#12

Re: Age is relative

RussFairfield

>Wally,

To most of the folks who read this, I am an old guy. Compared to you and Ted, I am still a kid.

This has been a bad month. On top of the wood allergies, the aches and pains of winter are worse this year. The Doctor says they are all tied together.

The wood dust allergies flare up every winter when I can't use the big wall fan to blow all of it outside, and this winter has been the worse one yet. I am weighing the cost of a large whole-shop dust collection system against not going in the shop until I can run the fan, getting used to working in a cold shop with the fan running, or just turning pens until March. It is looking like I will just have to turn more wood to pay for that big Oneida collector and a few runs of metal pipe.

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#13

Re: Critique the Old Guy

Bill Crommett

>Calling ones self old on this forum is just the same phenomenon as wanting to get your picture taken with a movie star. Some how being "old" here equates to being a master of the bowl .

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#14

Re: Critique the Old Guy

RussFairfield

>I am using the term "old" as a descriptor for 70 years of hard living. It has nothing to do with how little I know about turning wood. {8>)

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#15

Go South Young Man......

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Well climb in that RV and head south. 70 degrees and warm sun here today.

I turned wood for a lot of years before I'd ever heard of a dust system. I must have breathed a ton of dust in those days. I have a reasonably good DC system and an air filter. but that's really not enough. I'm pretty careful about a dust mask when sanding, but I'm thinking that that may not be enough anymore.

Wally

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#16

ebd

Re: Critique the Old Guy

ebd

>I've never done a goblet but they look !difficult!. I liked the other one better than this one. It seems to me that the stem on this one is a little too long and too uniform in diameter. Just my opinion, and uninformed at that.

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#17

These are very good!

T Daniel

>Allen, goblets aren't the easiest things to make and you have done a very good job with these. The first ones I made looked like I had used a dowel for the stems and after suggestions from this WC group I made the next ones with a bead on the stem or a tapered stem and it did look better to me and other turners, however, the buying public never saw anything wrong with the first ones. I give you an "A".

Happy New Year!

TD

Re: Critique the Old Guy

#18

Re: These are very good!

Allen Neighbors

>Thank you both, TD and ebd, I appreciate your comments. I'm learning, and I couldn't do that without help from you other turners. Someday I hope to get some lessons, but until I can, I just have to keep trudging along and ask for help from you folks.

Thanks again.

AL