Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Hamlet tools

Posts

Hamlet tools

#1

Hamlet tools

Wolf Kiessling

>I am planning on purchasing a Hamlet �� radius scraper to finish off the inside of bowls to remove the ridges. Also, a lot of the wood I use is very punky and difficult to smooth out so I need a very sharp edge (I do a LOT of sanding). Anyhow, I had intended to get one of the ASP2030 or 2060 tools but, after thinking about it, thought that this might be a bad idea. Doesn�t the M2 HSS steel take a sharper edge than the hardened metal? I know the ASP 2030 and 2060 tools hold an edge longer but that is really not the prime consideration here. Also, my main tools are Glaser and Sorby and I know nothing about the Hamlet tools at all. Any recommendations/comments in this regard?

Re: Hamlet tools

#2

This is what I do....

T Daniel

>Use your Sorby gouge to do the inside of a bowl. Sit it against the wood with the flute pointed to 3 o'clock. Then rotate the tool CCW until it just starts to cut; don't go any further. Lift the handle until the cutting edge is at 45 degrees to the cut. You may have to play around with these two things because they work together. As you near the point where the side meets the bottom begin twisting the tool CW as you round the corner and pull the handle toward you at the same time. Do not try this on a good piece of wood and wear your faceshield until you get the rhythmn of it. Once you master this advanced cut you can clean up any ridges left with a cabinet scraper. You'll love this cut once you learn it.

TD

Re: Hamlet tools

#3

Re: What You Do . . .?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>What'd yer computer send me for an e-mail with no message and an attachment? Didn't click on the attachment; too many destructive viruses trying to get the record for 2005.

MM

Re: Hamlet tools

#4

Re: Hamlet tools

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I like them and have several. My big bowl scraper is 2030 and holds a nice burr using the Lee Valley burnishing jig. Don't think a 2060 allow would do very well as a scraper; too hard to sharpen. I do, however, do more shear scraping with the either the gouge or the arm brace on the interior walls.

M

Re: Hamlet tools

#5

Put a negative rake on the scraper *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>Wolf,

I haven't done it yet, but since Cindy Drozda gave her demo several months back everyone at our turner's meeting has been raving about using a negative rake grind on their scrapers and how wonderful it is to use. (We have a very accomplished and well recognized group at our meetings, myself NOT included, and they all seem to be very supportive of this grind.) I'm certain someone here could better explain it, but basically you gind a slight bevel on the top of the scraper effectively lowering the cutting edge just below the top of the scraper.

I suspect you have seen Cindy Drozda's work, but if not I'll stick a link to her site address below.

-Craig


Cindy Drozda

Re: Hamlet tools

#6

FDA warning

T Daniel

>I passed on a warning that I just received about a recall of some medicines containing PPA. Apparently there are a number of sinus medicines that contain this and a recent batch is causing strokes and seizures. go to :

www.fda.gov/cder/drug/infopage/ppa

for more information.

TD

Re: Hamlet tools

#7

Got It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Sent you and e-mail.

Thanks TD

Re: Hamlet tools

#8

Re: Put a negative rake on the scraper

Wolf Kiessling

>If I understand this concept correctly, isn't this kind of like using a skew and holding it perpendicular to the work?

What would be the purpose of having the cutting edge below the top of the scraper? Sometimes I hold the scraper handle way down low, putting the tool about 45 degrees to the work which gives a fine scraping action, kind of like shear scraping. Would that lowered cutting edge provide a similar action?

I'm not sure what I just said makes sense, I hope it does......

Re: Hamlet tools

#9

Re: Put a negative rake on the scraper

RussFairfield

>To me, the negative rake scraper is exactly the same as holding a curved skew flat on the rest and using the edge as a scraper. You can also get the same presentation of steel to wood with a normal scraper by holding the scraper handle very high.

The negative rake on a scraper has the advantage that the tool is thicker and less flexible, the edge is better supported and is less likely to break, and it is easier to sharpen than the skew. It is also held in a more normal flat position.

The skew has the advantage that it can be sharpened to a finer edge, and that equates directly to a smoother cut for me. I will go for the sharper edge every time, even if I have to keep the tool rest closer to the wood, and the tool is more difficult to keep sharp.

Just one old guys opinion. Feel free to disagree.

Re: Hamlet tools

#10

Re: Put a negative rake on the scraper

Chas

>If I understand the grind correctly, does not this configuration give you a negative rake on the cutting face, thus slightly compressing the wood being cut and leaving a compacted surface reducing a tendancy to tear.

Re: Hamlet tools

#11

Re: Put a negative rake on the scraper

Craig Daymon

>The comments made by those that use it are that it is virtually impossible to get a catch and the finish of the cut is outstanding. Now these are very good turners to begin with, so I doubt they see too many catches, but they are not doing run of the mill turnings either.

I think it is very similar to using a (round nosed) skew, but the thickness of the tool below the cutting edge is substantially greater.

I'm trying to remember, but I think someone from the group is writing an article on it for a future Woodturning Design issue.

I suspect what you get is something very similar to those folks that were using an inverted roughing gouge with the end reground. There is a web site that discusses that tool, but I don't recall it right now. It has been discussed previously here.

-Craig

Re: Hamlet tools

#12

Re: Put a negative rake on the scraper

Dick Anderson

>A cabinet scraper is used to put a fine finish surface on the wood. The cabinet scraper is burnished to create a burr, which is the part of the scraper in contact with the wood and doing the cutting. The cabinet scraper is angled towards the direction of cut (less than 90-degrees to the wood).

A negative rake scraper employes the same principle. It is used with a burr for the final, finish, smoothing cut. I have a scraper ground as a negative rake, but frequently use my oval skew for that purpose. This works very well on hard, tight grained woods (exotics like coolibah, red mallee, ebony, etc.), however the burr disappears in about 5 seconds so you are frequently sharpening. A course wheel brings a good burr fairly quickly. I did recently use a negative rake scrape for the finishing cut on a soft maple bowl and it worked very well. Keep the cutting edge of the negative rake scraper on centerline height and the handle level.

Re: Hamlet tools

#13

Scraper website

W.C. Turner

>Craig,

I think this is the site you mentioned.

http://maine-web.com/woodturning/shapeshifter/scaper.html

W.C.

Re: Hamlet tools

#14

That's the site.

Craig Daymon

>Can't say for sure it works the same as a negative rake scraper, but yes that is the site I was thinking of.

-Craig