Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

Posts

can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#1

can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

Arw01

>Received my Jet Mini Lathe a couple of days ago, some the worse for Amazon shipping, but functional while I am ignored in customer services by both Amazon and Jet.

I had planned on buying a set of the Windsor design lathe tools from my local Harbor Freight, but they tell me I can only order them on-line now. Since HF has a terrible shipping policy, and they won't come in time for instant gratification, I am off to a couple local supply stores to get one lathe tool.

My plan for the immediate future is turning cros-cut pens from purpleheart. I have been using a Japanwoodworker chisel for my "skew" the last two days, and a skew appears to be nothing more than a chisel slick in reality.

Therefore should I buy a spindle gouge first or a try skew in order to bring the square blanks down to round and get them pretty smooth or another type of initial lathe tool?

Thanks

Alan

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#2

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pen *LINK*

RussFairfield

>Take a look at the pen turning instructions on my Website at the link below. You will see my recommendation for the turning tool as being a Continental spindle gouge, but any spindle gouge would be a good choice. You will also need a parting tool, and a skew will come in handy when you want to make custom pens and sand less.

And you might find a scraper a handy tool to have around if you are going to turn across the endgrain of a wood like Purpleheart.

For the price of a "name brand" spindle gouge, you can get an entire set of tools from Penn State, and they are a decent quality M2 high speed tool steel. There are a lot of pen turning folks using the Harbor Freight turning tools, and they are less expensive than those from Penn State. And, don't forget the Sears turning tools. They aren't as shiny as a Sorby, but they are a good cutting tool for a reasonable price.


Turning a pen

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#3

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pen

Gary Ratajczak

>My local HF store has a pen turners set for $9.99 - would be a good start until you can upgrade. You can also pick up a diamond slip stone there for a few $$ to keep an edge. Might find it's all you need. They also had a nice set of tools - don't remember the name on the box, but they were more like the Penn State tools. Nice looking. I though about picking up a set to try some special grinds.

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#4

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pen

Sam Dean

>My favorite tool for pen turning is a 3/8" bowl gouge with a very long side grind. Lay it on its side and it works like a skew; cut from the end and it works like a spindle gouge; turn it so the flute is facing the spinning blank and it works like a roughing gouge. If I could only get one tool, that would be my first choice. My second choice would be a spindle or detail gouge, and third would be a small parting tool.

Thanks,

Sam

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#5

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pen

13

>I would choose a spindle gouge because you can turn a square blank round and you can make a fairly smooth surface.

13

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#6

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pen

Lan Brady

>Alan,

I like a 3/8" spindle gouge. I put a long side grind on it. That way I have a long point that cuts as smooth as a skew. At 1-3 o'clock on the tip it acts like a gouge for rounding and coves. The long taper gives plenty of room for scrapeing(sp?). It ends up being several tools in one.

I also have the HF pen set as mentioned above. That was the best 10 dollar set of tools that I have ever bought. I actually bought 2 sets and modifed the parting tool into a ring/bead cutter. Modifed the spindle gouge into a great domed scraper. I use both skews til dull and sharpen both at the same time.

good luck and happy new year, Lan

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#7

I use two

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>The first is a gouge that is over 2" across. Looks huge but works like a charm. It is quick and does not bounce. Second tool is a 2" wide scraper. If you can afford only one tool, I say go for the largest gouge you can buy. Get some HSS and make your own scraper. Use the lathe to make a handle. Good luck and welcome to turning.

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#8

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pen

ScottS

>I use a 3/8" spindle gouge to turn the blanks round, then a 1/2" skew to bring them to final size. I decided to pass on the $10 set from my local Harbor Freight store. It didn't sound like they were high-speed steel and I figured I'd end up ruining them on the grinder...

If you don't trust Harbor Freight, check out the "Benjamin's Best" tools from Penn State Industries. Given that they sell the same 8-piece set as Harbor Freight (albeit for $15/more), I suspect they're actually the same tools. You pay a bit more, but you don't have to deal with HF.

If you're determined to buy locally and your current chisel has been working for you, then I'd suggest a spindle gouge. I like the 3/8" size. Mine has a "fingernail grind" and I would recommend that profile. Of course, sharpening it is a pain in the neck...

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#9

Re: HF Pen set

Arw01

>unable to come up with a part number on their site to see if the set is in stock at the local store.

Thanks

Alan

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pens?

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: can only buy one lathe tool, which one for pen

Keith Tompkins

>I have a set of hf "windsor design" tools..not as bad as you may think. Good for students, as I won't let anyone use, let alone sharpen my good stuff. I just received a bull nose center, a machinist's #2 live center, and a mini-chuck from hf also..not too shabby!