question for power carvers
ken chase
>Is the Trent Bosch carving stand the best choice to hold my turnings
in the chuck for carving? Or are there good alternatives?
Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
question for power carvers
ken chase
>Is the Trent Bosch carving stand the best choice to hold my turnings
in the chuck for carving? Or are there good alternatives?
Thanks
Re: question for power carvers
Dale Cook
>Hi Ken,I have Trent's carving stand and like it alot, but some of the others may be good to.
Re: question for power carvers
John Lucas
>Ken I have the bestwood tools carving stand. I haven't seen the trent Bosch carving stand unless it's the same one he used to demonstrate that was Pneumatic. If that's the case then his is excellent. The Bestwood tools carving stand will fit on your workbench or in your lathe banjo and accepts your faceplates and chucks. I have forgotten the price, I would have to look it up. I bought the first one they made so I got a good deal.
Re: question for power carvers
ken chase
>Thanks much. I can't find a website for Besttools. Do you know how I can reach them for info?
Re: question for power carvers *LINK*
George Van in WI
>Here it is Ken.
Bestwood Tools
Re: question for power carvers
Mike Schwing from Md.
>The Bestwoodtools articulated carving post works OK. I desire it to be much, much more - and I think that the Bosch one IS just what I'm looking for. The Bestwood one does work, it will allow you to do what you want, but it has drawbacks that leave me wanting more. They are:
- The levers move with the rotation/adjustment of the tool. They should stay in one place, the other parts should rotate. It is not always easy to reach around the work, especially when the base is large, and fumble around to find wherever the lever wound up on the last adjustment.
- It should be easily possible to design such a rest that has only one adjustment lever that allows for the entire contraption to be adjusted. I do not like having one lever for rotating, and one for tilting.
- Tightening/loosening the levers can be a real knuckle buster! To get them as tight as sometimes necessary takes considerable force, and then to release them, well, watch your knuckles.
I would buy the Bosch one for sure.
Re: question for power carvers
ken chase
>Mike:
Thanks for the heads up. I watched an instructional video by Neil Scobie in which he uses a terriffic looking device which was made by his friend and would eventually be manufactured for sale. If you happen to have seen the same tape I would like to know your impression of the carving stand compared to Bossh's. I have Bosch's tape also.
Re: question for power carvers
Richard Allen
>Good luck with your quest.
I have the Bosch holder and I am well pleased with it. While at the KC Symposium this past summer I looked at bothe the BestWoods tools version and the Bosch version. I talked with Trent about his holder. He explained several of the features that his holder has which the Bestwood holder lacked. I examined both holders. Between what Trent had said and what I has seen in the two holders the Bosch holder was the better product. I don't recall what the decision points were for selecting the Bosch holder.
I would sugest you contact Trent and ask him why his holder is the best choice.
For those with vac pumps
Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)
>Does anybody use a jig at the bench that uses thier vac turning chucks?
MB
Re: For those with vac pumps
Mike Schwing from Md.
>I've considered it, but most of the things I'd want to vac chuck do not have surfaces consistent enough to attach a vac drum.
I tell you what I find to work best - hot melt glue. I first screw a piece of wood onto a faceplate, turn/shape it as desired, then attach it to the toolrest post using an adapter. I then warm up the glue gun, and hot glue the workpiece on. Sometimes I even shore it up with scraps, all hot glued together. It works REALLY well, so well that I can say I've never had anything come off. Then its not much of a chore to pry it off and clean it up either. No tool marks, no screw holes, no glue creep.
Re: For those with vac pumps
John Lucas
>Ditto on the hot melt glue. I have been thinking about rigging a vacuum chuck to the Bestwoodtools carving stand. I think they now make an adaptor to fit on the carving stand that will accept a vacuum hose. Then you could just put one of your vacuum chucks on there. The only problem with using a vacuum chuck and carving is you are putting a fair amount of force on the carving and if you break the seal it's gonna jump off pretty quickly. I've used a route with vacuum for years and as long as you have a large enough surface area it won't come off. Bowls are different in that they are never as good a seal as a flat milled surface.
Re: For those with vac pumps
Mike Schwing from Md.
>John, I've made a bunch of MDF vac drums using tapped MDF adapters that I got from Johnny Tolly. No need for a special adapter if you go that route - just make one of those MDF drums and drill a hole, insert your vac hose in and seal it. The thing isn't spinning on the carving post, after all.
I have several and will mail you one if you'll email me your address. They are, however, tapped for 1 1/4" x 8 . You know how to reach Johnny otherwise.
Re:thanks all for power carvers help
ken chase
>