Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

alcohol drying problems

Posts

alcohol drying problems

#1

alcohol drying problems

jeremy

>Hello,

I just started to use alcohol to dry roughed out blanks. Unfortunately, in Canada we cannot get ethanol but can get methanol. I soaked two blanks (walnut and maple) in methanol but when I removed them to dry, they immediately (<2h) started to check very bad. My impression was that drying via alcohol would produce >90% clean (unchecked) bowls but I know most of the testing was done with ethanol or isopropyl. I would not have expected methanol to produce any difference results than ethanol or isopropyl.

Has anyone worked with methanol and found unacceptable results? Now that checking has started, can I stop the checking by using CA glue or would you suggest sealing the end grain better with anchorseal at this time and just wait?

Thanks,

Jeremy

Re: alcohol drying problems

#2

Re: alcohol drying problems

ken chase

>Jeremy:

I'm no expert but I believe the piece is to be soaked after roughing out not before. I have had good luck soaking then wrapping the bowls bottom in newspaper and leaving the top open to air.

Good luck

Re: alcohol drying problems

#3

Re: alcohol drying problems

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Hi Jeremy,

I use methol hydrate to dry my turnings after roughing to about 10% and havent had a problem. I soak for 24 hrs. wrap them in a paper bag for a week and than let them dry for a week. I do this in my garage which is about 55 to 60 degrees.

Good luck,

Norm

Re: alcohol drying problems

#4

JL

Re: alcohol drying problems

JL

>Consider the differing vapor pressures of ethanol (ethyl alcohol) versus methanol (methyl alcohol, methyl hydrate). The vapor pressure of ethanol is 44.5 torr and that of methanol is 88.7 torr, at 20�C.

Whatever does that mean?

It means that methanol goes into the vapor phase much easier (it evaporates more quickly) than ethanol. When Dave Smith did his study, he used ethanol (less toxic, readily available, slower evaporation). If you wrap your bowls thoroughly or coat them, the evaporation would be slower and more controlled. They would be less prone to checking. Alternatively you could add a "slow solvent" to the methanol such as diethylene glycol propyl ether. This would slow the rate of evaporation. You could probably add isopropanol (isopropyl alcohol) and slow it down also.

My $0.02.

Re: alcohol drying problems

#5

Re: alcohol drying problems

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Jeremy, there is no science/rationale that I have seen behind the idea that an alcohol soaked bowl (no matter the type) will crack less than an untreated bowl, given the same conditions. In fact, in my meager little science starved brain, I come up with the analysis that it would cause them to crack more rather than less if the bowl was not soaked long enough to replace nearly 100% of the water with alcohol. How long does that take? Nobody really knows, I think.

The thing that causes bowls to crack when drying are moisture differentials and sapwood/heartwood, which shrink at different rates as they dry. Assuming you had no visible sapwood in your bowl, (or no heartwood), it probably cracked because the outside dried MUCH faster than the inside. This will happen on a thicker bowl more easily than a thin one as it cannot stretch/warp/resist the forces causing shrinkage on the oustide vs the ones keeping it in status quo on the inside.

A water soaked bowl (fresh cut) dries as it starts to evaporate from the exposed ends. As that water on the outside evaporates, it draws water from further inside towards the outside surfaces by capillary/osmosis methods. If a bowl has been soaked in alcohol but it has not been long enough to replace ALL of the water, I _think_ what happens is that the alcohol evaporates very, very quickly compared to the water in the deeper reaches of the bowl and the shrinkage differential is too great to resist cracking - CRACK! The problem is in knowing when all of the water has been replaced.

I'm not a proponent of this method, but I have used it with success as an experiment. After a while of roughing out 3 or 4 bowls per month, you have 3 or 4 bowls every month coming dry and ready to finish. The additional thing I do not like about this method is that it seems to produce blanks that are strange feeling, turn like rocks, and seem to have all of the natural oils stripped from them. They just don't seem as "alive" to me. I also don't like having large quantities of alcohol in the house that I can't drink.

Re: alcohol drying problems

#6

Re: alcohol drying problems

Kevin Gerstenecker

>Jeremy, if you follow the method Dave Smith has in the "Articles" section regarding drying roughed out bowls with Alcohol, you will notice a difference in your success rate. I have been using this method since October 2004, when I first met Dave Smith. I have dried LOTS of roughed out bowls, of just about every domestic hardwood, and a few exotic hardwoods, and my failure rate is almost zero. I have found this method exceptionally good for notoriously hard to dry woods, such as Apple, Cherry and other fruit woods. Sure, I have had a few cracks, mostly on roughed bowls where I left the walls too thick, and those were Ash and Osage Orange. Some develop minor cracking that is quickly turned away during the finish turning, but for the most part, the method works, and works very well. The bowls do have a different feel after they dry, much the same as a boiled bowl. But, I don't experience any more difficulty turning an Alcohol dried bowl than one that has been air dried without being Alcohol soaked. After an Alcohol soaked and dried bowl is finish turned, there is no apparent difference between and Akly bowl and non Alky dried bowl, at least not that I can see. Others I know report the same findings. It really is all a matter of preference, but for me, Dave Smith's method has a lot of merit. I will continue to use this method, because it works and works very well for me. There are many other ways to dry roughed out bowls, and the best advice would be to use what works best for you. That's what I do. ;-)

Re: alcohol drying problems

#7

regarding the cracks and CA......

Kevin Gerstenecker

>......Sorry, I forgot to address that Jeremy. I have used CA glue on Alcohol soaked bowls after they have been drying for a few days and I noticed some cracks. My experience is that CA will work well in stopping the cracks from developing further. As for the types of Alcohol and the difference in the drying effectiveness, Dave would be better informed to address that for you. I am sure Dave will see this post, and give you some ideas and information.

Re: alcohol drying problems

#8

Re: alcohol drying problems *LINK*

Chas

>Re:"The additional thing I do not like about this method is that it seems to produce blanks that are strange feeling, turn like rocks, and seem to have all of the natural oils stripped from them. "

Here in the Uk we cannot get access to raw alcohol but use "Methelated Spirits" to good effect with the Dave Smith method.

A 3/8" rough blank soaked for 2 hours and dried for 18 days or so turns with ease and only minimal movement. Left another 7 days or so and it becomes as you say "Rock Hard" and is a challenge to tool preparation and use.

The Beech and Hazel bowls on the link page have all been turned within 4 weeks of harvesting the timber.

I have only had cracking on one piece and that was only about 1/2" of core wood on an edge.


img

Other examples

Re: alcohol drying problems

#9

It should work.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Jeremy,

I don't use methanol because it is very poisonous. Readily absorbed through the skin as well as by inhalation.

Methanol will work for drying wood. The property of miscibility is what causes alcohol to replace water in the wood. Water and alcohol will produce a homogeneous solution when placed in the same container. Water and alcohol can easily pass through cell walls so water in the wood will exchange with alcohol in the soaking solution until the concentrations are equal. In cases where total water removal is required the piece being dried is put into a fresh solution of dehydrated alcohol. The process is repeated until the alcohol soaking solution does not decrease in concentration. This process is used in many scientific disciplines and industrial processes. Therefore, I conclude it is has been proved scientifically to work.

I assume you are drying roughed out bowls. The procedure that works for me is to wrap the outside of the bowl with heavy brown paper. I use grocery bags for wrapping the bowls. Please email me if you continue to have problems.

Dave Smith

The pickle King in Longview, WA.