Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Cherry/purpleheart bowl

Posts

Cherry/purpleheart bowl

#1

Cherry/purpleheart bowl

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>A segmented bowl, cherry and purpleheart. Approx 7 1/4 x 3 1/4.

Overall, happy with the result, although I don't think I went deep enough into the bottom. Form was what I had been aiming for, though.

Comments welcome

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust


img

Re: Cherry/purpleheart bowl

#2

Re: Cherry/purpleheart bowl

GaryG in MD

>Nice bowl, George. Your can rightfully feel good about it.

I hate to be a Grinch on Christmas Eve, but since you're learning and really want to know, I'll say this: the bottom of your bowl has a long flat area. Many turners consider that to be a design flaw. If you think about the really classic, eye-pleasing shapes, I think you will find that they have a complex curve with a constantly changing slope and no flat areas. You can do a search of recent WC posts and the WC Turning Archive for words like "flat" and "design", and I think you will find some good thoughts along these lines.

But don't worry! The whole point is to have fun and to learn and progress. I'm sure you're doing all those things. Keep it up. I'm only being picky because I think you wanted an honest reply. FWIW, I've never made anything without flaws, but it's fun to keep trying. Criticism aside, it's a pretty bowl; enjoy it.

Happy holidays, Gary

Re: Cherry/purpleheart bowl

#3

Thank You

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>Gary:

This is why I am posting some pics of my beginning pieces, to get some "criticism."

I may go back and tune this thing up a bit, with your thoughts in mind.

I'm in a position where I have very limited time to turn, and no real access to a turning club (you probably wouldn't believe my work schedule!), so basically self-taught. With, of course, the help of this great site. Believe me, any feedback is greatly appreciated.

You're right...I am looking for honest opinions, positive or negative. Only way to learn.

Hope you have a great holiday season.

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: Cherry/purpleheart bowl

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: Cherry/purpleheart bowl

Ric Taylor

>George,

Nice job. If you are happy with the shape, then that is all that matters. I like it.

Ric

Re: Cherry/purpleheart bowl

#5

Re: Thank You

GaryG in MD

>Hi again George,

I can appreciate everything you say. We have a lot in common, except I do have access to an excellent club (two actually -- both an hour's drive, but well worth it), and it makes a BIG difference.

Based on seeing your nice layered bowl, it's obvious that you have some woodworking experience and shop tools. That experience will help you a lot in your turning. I have neither. Indeed, I have no place indoors and have to work outside on the back patio (makes cleanup easier).

WC is a tremendous(!) help, but you also need some hands-on and person-too-person help too. The AAW membership list has ~180 members in Mass and lots more in CT. (If you're not a member, you should become one right away!) Perhaps you could use the list to try to contact someone nearby and see if they would be willing to act as a mentor for you. I think the chances are good that you could find someone who would meet with you once a month, or whatever. Give it a try -- nothing to lose. In fact, just ask here on WC. You never know....

You might also consider videos. They're the next best thing, and they really do make a big difference in your learning curve.

Enjoy, Gary