Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Oak dish

Posts

Oak dish

#1

Oak dish

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>An oak dish made for a friend at work. Measures approx. 5 1/2 by 2 1/2 inches high. Finished with beal buffing. Mostly a practice piece, trying to get the hang of working with oak.

Comments welcome.

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust


img

Re: Oak dish

#2

Re: Oak dish

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>Still working on the phot end of this. Lighting seems to be a problem with digital cams. Hopefully my photo skills will improve.

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: Oak dish

#3

George, we have some work to do....

TD

>It is hard to see in the photo but it looks like the piece is too thick and the thickness isn't uniform. Also, the base looks like it may be too high, not by much but a little pruning would help. Oak is a bear to turn and to dry without cracking; uniform thickness is a must. Nevertheless, turn what you have; it's only practice anyway. Today you make shavings....tomorrow you make bowls:)

Re: Oak dish

#4

Re: George, we have some work to do....

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>Most of the bowls I have turned have been much thicker. The thickness of this one, however, was actually what the recipient wanted...she had seen a few of my other pieces and actually asked for a "heavy" piece, so this was done deliberately. I have to agree about the foot...I should have made it smaller.

I am struggling with consistency in thickness, tho. Like you said, need some more practice.

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: Oak dish

#5

Re: George, we have some work to do....

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Aside from the foot, the outside looks great. Nice flowing curve. Keep doing that--and if you can turn oak, you can turn anything.

Re: Oak dish

#6

Re: Oak dish

John Lucas

>George I think you have two photo problems right off the bat. One is the focus. If you can take the camera off of auto focus. It focused on the back rim. If you don't have manual focus see if your camera has a focus lock feature. Usually you aim the focus point of the camera at the area you want in focus and then push the shutter button part way down. This locks the focus on that point. Since your depth of field was so shallow I would focus on the front. Usually you focus about 1/3 of the way through the bowl.

On your lighting problem, the main one is on camera flash. You will need to turn the flash off and shoot without it using other lighting. You can set the piece next to a window and let the window light one side. Then use a white card or alumnium foil covered card to bounce light back into the darker side of the bowl.

Re: Oak dish

#7

Re: Oak dish

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>John:

Thanks for the tips. Looks like I have as much to learn about photog as turning!

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: Oak dish

#8

Re: Oak dish *LINK*

RussFairfield

>You have a good outside form.

It appears that the inside curve is smooth, but that it doesn't follow the same curve as the outside. If you were a famous woodturner, this would be called your signature style. Since you aren't you will have to settle for our criticism of that.

Don't worry about it. Thick bottoms are common with new woodturners. Make a lot of bowls, and the bottoms will become thinner and the walls more uniform. It is automatic. It comes with practice.

The height and shape of the foot is a personal opinion, just as the diameter of the foot is an opinion. If you are making bowls to please other woodturners, they will have smooth round bottoms and no feet. If you are making bowls to please your wife, or anyone else who will use it as a bowl, they will have the stability of a foot. Make them both ways and see which ones you like the best. If you want to make them to give away as gifts, or to sell, make them to please your wife.

And, sometime we have to leave a foot to keep from going through the bottom.

As for that Oak? Wrap some of it in plastic while it is still wet. The plastic will keep it from drying. Set it aside in a warm place to spalt. You will be glad you did. It will be even more difficult to turn because of the hard and soft spots, but you have some of the prettiest spalted wood you will ever find.

I wrote an article on what makes a good salad bowl. You are well on your way.

And always remember, this is just my opinion.


The Salad Bowl