Stihl, Husqvarna or other
LT
>Received permission from SWMBO to purchase a new chainsaw, probably 16" to 18" bar. I'm leaning towards a Stihl or Husqvarna. Any opinions?
Thanks,
LT
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Stihl, Husqvarna or other
LT
>Received permission from SWMBO to purchase a new chainsaw, probably 16" to 18" bar. I'm leaning towards a Stihl or Husqvarna. Any opinions?
Thanks,
LT
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other
TD
>Don't overlook Echo also. Get the one from the dealer that offers the best service locally. That will usually be Stihl.
TD
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other
Rick in Colgate, Wi
>I recently bought a new Stihl for the simple reason that the model I bought has a "no tools" chain tensioning system.
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other
Raymond Overman in SC
>I like my Husky. I've used a Stihl and like it too. My father has a small Echo that's been running for 15-20 years.
The one thing I would suggest is start a relationship with your local dealer/repair with your purchase unless you're into DIY small engine repair. It's worth it when you have a problem to have that relationship built rather than walking in saying you saved $20 at a big box store, now I've got a problem. Can you help me?
doesn't husqvarna make poulan now?
e
>any good?
Re: doesn't husqvarna make poulan now?
Raymond Overman in SC
>Both are made by Electrolux.
depends ....
e
>both stihl and husqvarna are great saws -- what model you decide really depends upon your expected use.
for example, i have the husky 55 with a 20" narrow curf bar with rip chain -- great saw for cross-cutting <18" log sections, and for carving blanks. however it is way under-powered for ripping very hard green wood, and the thin curve bar easily wanders.
furthermore, i've used a husky 372 and 385 with 3/8 28" bar -- great for ripping and ripping crotches ... difficult to shape blanks with, however (well, maybe if i'd weight-trained a bit more).
you can find husqvarna on-line, however stihl can only be purchased through a dealer. both stihl and husky have new EPA Phase II models which many have had problems with.
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Have a 16 year-old Stihl [023 x 16"] that runs as well as when new.
Have a Husky 372XP with a 28" bar running full skip 3/8-50 chain. At 5-1/2 hp and 14,000 rpm, it blows through 24" maple and ash like the little Stihl goes through pine and fir.
They are very different saws used for different purposes.
If the Stihl quits, I'll replace it with another Stihl; probably a MS260 Pro with an 18" bar. Great small saw with outstanding balance, and a very good power-to-weight ratio.
If the Husky croaks, I'll replace it with another Husky.
Hope this helps.
M
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other
Mike Schwing from Md.
>I would recommend staying within the Stihl or Husqy realm, simply for reputation and serviceability. Stihl seems to have more prevalent local service, here anyway, and I've been very happy with my local Stihl retailer/service center.
I would not buy your saw based on bar size, as most saws will operate with many different bar lengths. I believe in buying the most saw I can safely operate, because you'll never be with too much saw for the job, but you can be with too little. I have a Stihl MS360 Pro with 3 bars - 14", 20", 25". It will handle everything I can possibly want to cut in the mid-Atlantic states. I also have a homeowner type something or other form Lowe's - it's good for brush and small branches, but not tree trunks of the size I can turn on my PM3520.
When I need a saw around the yard I still use the Stihl over the homeowner saw, I just put the 14" bar on, so its safe.
If I was a bigger man, I'd have an even more powerful saw, but at 65"/140lbs. I just can't operate any more than I have now.
That new tool free tensioner is a nice feature, but not a must have. The ability to quickly change bars/chains is. I like the chip ejection of the Stihl, too, not all saws I've used keep the chain sprocket area clear as well as the 360 does.
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other
ebd
>I got the Stihl because I do some rip type cutting when slicing up green logs for blanks and the chip ejection chute is much bigger on the Stihl (clogs much less) than on the Husky.
Re: doesn't husqvarna make poulan now?
Curt Fuller
>Electrolux!, really?
My experience with Electrolux vacuums is they really suck! And that's a good thing for a vacuum to do. If they can repeat that performance on a chainsaw it should be a good one.
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other
JKJ in East TN
>The best advice I've read is to buy the saw based on the dealer. Either saw should work fine, but if you ever need service, adjustment, or parts, a good dealer can make a big difference.
JKJ
Re: No wonder there aren't any ...
JamieDonaldson
>... big trees left in N.Jersey!!!! Mark has been practicing with his saw-monster Husky !
Re: Jersey Trees
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Jamie,
Know what the average of all New Jersey trees is?
60 years old; that it! This is due to most of the whole dang State's trees having been cut for firewood and coke for the bog iron founderies in the 1800's. There are post Civil War pix of my area (close to an old steel mill) where the entire landscape as far as can be seen is clearcut and completely denuded. They look like the place was hit with a nuke; very strange.
M
Re: I remember Red Bank....
JamieDonaldson
>... because I lived near the shore while stationed at Ft. Monmouth. Not too many trees to the North, but later did find some going South.
Re: Down-The-Shore
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Used to live down there; nice and quite out in the Pine Barrens.
This is not to say there aren't old tree here. Have been offered dibs on a 5-1/2 FOOT DIAMETER (at 4' above ground level!) walnut. Problem is that it's a roadside tree and is rumored to have a significant portion of A '73 Ford Pinto imbeded. No mill would ever touch it.
m
chainsaw decision
LT
>Thanks to everyone who responded. The replys were very informative and very helpful. After much deliberation, it came down to the Stihl and Husqvarna. It was very close, but I decided to go with the Husqvarna.
If you hear about someone chasing tree service trucks or lurking in the local wood dump...it will be me!
Thanks,
LT
Re: chainsaw decision
Raymond Overman in SC
>Which model?
Re: chainsaw decision
LT
>350 with the 18" bar
Re: doesn't husqvarna make poulan now?
James L. Seigal
>A chain saw with built in dust vac! what a concept. Jim S.
Do You Really Want To Buy A Chainsaw .............
Barry Turner
>Do you really want to buy a chainsaw from a company that makes vacuum cleaners?
Stihl 361 with 20" Bar
Barry Turner
>I bought the above earlier this year and have really been pleased with it, although I have not used it extensively. It is on the low end of the professional grade saws Stihl makes. It is so far ahead of the Homelite/Poulan/McCullochs I have used it is scary. The only7 negative is, it's a lot heavier than those saws. Of course, it is 59 CC's, so 12.3 lbs ain't so bad.
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other-for small lumberjill
Jill
>Happy Holidays to all. I recieved $$ to get a chain saw. The Stihl sounds nice but but big. Would the Stihl be ok for a medium lumberjill?? I got sum muscle too ;-) Thanks!!
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>From experience, I would be reluctant to use a Stihl for jobs requiring sawing jobs other than the ordinary. We bought the top of the line Stilh to half or quarter logs too big in diameter for my sawmill. We used the correct oil:gas mixture, using Stilh oil. The motor burned up before a two years of use. It was rebuilt and went again. The Husqvarna we now use for the same job is awesome and shows no sign of wear. For my every day sawing jobs I continue to use my smaller Stihl.
Re: Stihl, Husqvarna or other-for small lumberjill
Rick in Colgate, Wi
>Hi Jill,
Stihl has a complete line of chainsaws in all size ranges. Get yourself to a dealer and take a look! You may want to check out their "easy2start" recoil available on some models.