We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>This is a very simple project, making some spatulas, and both times I am having the same issue. Doing this on my mini, the spatulas are about 12" long. I am getting chattering doing the handles. I've sharpened my skew, taken ridiculously light cuts, loosened the tailstock a bit, taken such a light grip on the tool that I am barely holding onto it, tried long point up and long point down, gone to my detail gouge, and yet still I am getting this vibration and chatter. Of course I have resorted to the 100 grit gouge to solve the issue, but any clues to what I might be doing wrong? Or is it just the fact that I am using some curly maple? Its crazy that such an basic project makes me feel like I am regressing. It is not a thin handle, make from 3/4" stock going down to about 3/8 at the smallest, so I doubt it is really flexing.
Yea, I can get chatter when I don't want, but still haven't figured out my chatter tool. Maybe that would give me a clean cut! ;)
Are you working on a thin spindle out away from the thick stock?
I generally work from the tailstock end to the headstock in 1/2"-3/4" increments going for a final thickness, sanding and perhaps finishing as I go. I generally do my cuts from the thin end towards the headstock
As the thin end gets longer it looks steady but really is whippy.
You might reach your middle fingers under the tool rest to support the thin stock from behind while doing light cuts.
I would not feel comfortable using a skew like that, but use a detail gouge like that if needed.
>Ed that is not unusual at all and it sounds like you are doing all the right things. I would try 2 more. The first is to turn the speed down so you don't burn your fingers and the cup your left hand either over or under and support the spindle exactly opposite the pressure from the bevel on the skew or spindle gouge. It takes practice. I don't know what I do differently than what I used to do because now I can control it quite easily and before I fought it like crazy. I think it's balancing the forces between rubbing the bevel and pushing with my fingers. Take light cuts of course with a very sharp tool. I've also found on some woods, and curly maple is one of them, that I can control the whip or chatter better with a small spindle gouge.
The other tip is to put one end in a 4 jaw chuck. This only works of course if you can spare the extra wood. I start turning at the tailstock and turn about 2 inches thin. Then I go another 2 inches and so forth. Eventually you will reach a point where you can turn about 4or 5 inches from the chuck and just keep on turning thin.
On something as long as you are turning you might have to support the tailstock end slightly to keep chatter and wobble to a minimum
>HI Ed, you mentioned the wood is curly maple. That is probably the problem. as the grain turns differently as you go. On thin spindles, I wrap my fingers around the turning, with only my palm on the rest, my thumb guides the tool. A skew is easy to control in this way, although it seems deadly. Try different speeds, and hone your tools in addition to grinding. Put pressure in line with the centers, not directly against the turning. A homemade steady will work in a pinch.
The curly maple could very well contribute to the problem - I have much more trouble with figured wood than straight-grained wood for thin spindles, especially if the wood is fairly soft such as maple compared to wood like macacauba, purpleheart, bloodwood, oak, etc.
What I ALWAYS do with thin and relatively thin spindles may sound dangerous but I think it is perfectly safe. It is recommended by many experts and I've seen it illustrated in books and magazines: I cup the fingers of my left hand over the top and behind to support the wood just behind the tip of the skew or gouge. My left hand moves along with the tool like a traveling steady rest. This is safe since if there is a catch, the tool will be pulled away from the fingers.
Since the left hand is supporting the work, the skew or gouge must be supported entirely by the right hand. I usually grip it up close, around the metal rather than back on the handle. In addition, I often support the end of the handle by pressing it against my forearm. After a bit of practice, this feels very natural and is very controllable. For added control on precision cuts, I often press my left thumb against the left side of the tool very near the tip.
You still need to make light cuts with this method. One author puts it this way - if your fingers get hot from the friction, you are pressing too hard into the wood! Without such finger support, I usually get chattering and even flexing, which can lead rapidly to a catch and breakage.
Besides that, very light cuts with a very sharp tool help as you already mentioned. Try increasing the angle of the skew to make more of a slicing cut. Also, I have skews sharpened at different bevel angles - sometimes a different one helps. Sometimes I find that either tightening or loosening the tailstock helps, as well as speeding up or slowing down the lathe to find the sweet spot.
And what John Lucas said about using a chuck is right on - for thin spindles I always grip one end in a chuck of some sort. This tends to keep the first 1/2 of the piece from flexing, stiffening the entire piece. One night I broke three magic wands in a row without a chuck where I typically will not break one in 50. (I acutally use the morse taper in the headstock spindle as a jam chuck, but the principle is the same.)
>JKJ I forgot to mention the morse taper trick. I used that in an ornament class because we didn't have enough chucks to go around. I had 3 beginners in that class and it worked for all of them. Here's what he's talking about. Turn a morse taper on one end of the spindle. I measure the morse taper 1" apart and use those two measurements to turn the taper with the spindle mounted between centers. This taper doesn't have to be perfect because wood compresses when you drive it in the spindle. Anyway after you turn the taper simply remove your drive spur and drive the wood into the taper. Then pull the tailstock up to support the other end.
This has two advantages, oK 3. It lets you turn very close to the drive spindle without worrying about hitting the chuck (because there isn't one) It supports the wood so you have less chatter, and you can use less force on the tailstock which again reduces chatter.
>All good advice. I am going to try learning how to use hand support and also play around with different speeds. I had it turned up a bit, probably around 1800 or so just to deal with the spatula end but maybe I should have then turned it down to work on the handle.
This was a bit too long to try a chuck, my tailstock was already partially overhanging the end of the bed of the mini.
>>...my tailstock was already partially overhanging
>the end of the bed of the mini.
I ran into that when turning on my mini as well. That's another big advantage to the morse taper jam "chuck" - you save several inches on a short bed lathe. In fact, some times I'd turn the tapers between centers on a bunch of blanks on my larger lathe then do the rest of the turning on the mini - they were just too long to fit between centers on the mini.
If the mini is too short to even make the taper, it could even be done the old way with a hand axe or sharp knife. As Sir Lucas mentioned, it doesn't have to be perfect to work. Someone once posted that they even jam a square blank into the spindle, but if you make the taper fit fairly close, it can grip and support better. I usually turn about a taper about 1/2" to 5/8" long. I used to measure in two places and set two calipers to those sizes, but after doing a few I now just use one caliper for the large end and guess at the smaller end. I've been meaning to make a little gauge for this.
And about there being no chuck to hit, that's a fact! Not only is there no chuck to hit with your tool (and far more space to work near the end), but no chuck to hit with your knuckles!
BTW, here's a picture of a cocobolo blank with a short taper on the end, ready to turn into a wand.
>Thanks John. I had seen the morse taper method before but it had been a while so it never occurred to me to use it for this. I am going to keep it in mind for the future and also try hand support.