P&N bowl gouges
JohnD
>I recently bought a couple and can't get as smooth a cut as with my Sorbys. The grind is not quite like the sorbys. Is it the grind, the gouge our me? Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
P&N bowl gouges
JohnD
>I recently bought a couple and can't get as smooth a cut as with my Sorbys. The grind is not quite like the sorbys. Is it the grind, the gouge our me? Thanks
Re: P&N bowl gouges
John Lucas
>I haven't used a P@N bowl gouge but have used thier spindle gouge. It sharpens and holds an edge as good as any I've used. I would guess it is the sharpening angle that's giving you the problem
Re: P&N bowl gouges
Gerry in Maryland
>I have a P&N Bowl Gouge. I didn't care for the grind that was on the gouge when I received it. I sharpened it with the Wolverene Varigrind the same as I did on my Sorby. I cannot see any differance in them. I use the P&N in a Kelton handle and can rough out much faster than I can with the Sorby with the wooden handle..
Hope this helps.
Gerry
Re: P&N bowl gouges
Raymond Overman in SC
>I use a P&N gouge with an extremely long grind. I don't find any problems with smooth cuts. I have a crown gouge as well and it is a different feel due to the wider flute on my P&N.
Re: I setteld on this grind
AlbertaBob
>I had some problems at the outset too with the deep V and finally settled on this shape.
I can roll it right over during the cut now and go from fine shavings to bulk removal with the turn of my wrist.
Bob
Re: P&N bowl gouges
bob davis
>pardon the stupidity,what is p&n?
Re: P&N bowl gouges *LINK*
Mike Cunningham (cape May)
>Patience and Nicholson turning tools. Australian made. I have several, like them, haven't had any problems with them, though a friend did have difficulty with the edge on one of his.
Lee Valley and Craft Supply carries them
P&N
Re: P&N bowl gouges
Nick Stagg
>I have the 1/2" bowl gouge and I've tried several different grinds on it: swept back, 55 degrees,40 degrees and the Wolverine grind. It will not cut and give the same finish as a Sorby, at least for me. It sits on the rack and is seldom used except for the odd roughing job when the finish is not critical.
Re: P&N bowl gouges
gtwilkins
>Use the 5/8 bowl gouge everyday, great tool holds edge well, I find I can hone on the rubber/diamond wheel 4-5 times before a real light touch-up on the grinder. Just ordered the 3/8. Trevor
I'll stay with my Sorby
TD
>I tried the P&N; it's ok but I prefer my Sorbys. I gave the P&N to my son. I could never figure out why I didn't care for it; just didn't.
TD
Re: P&N bowl gouges
Rick Allen
>It is most definetly you (;->) Why did you end up with a P&N gouge when the Sorby was working so well for you?
Re: P&N bowl gouges
James Brooks in GA.
>I just purchased a supa flute 1/2" P&N along with a Bosch handle. It has a wide u shape in the bottom. I sharpened it the same as a Ellsworth grind. I also like the handle filled with lead shot. You can vary the amount of shot installed. No problems here.
Re: P&N bowl gouges
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>I have all the P&N bowl gouges except their really big one. I also have a P&N detail gouge. I also have Sorbys in all the same sizes. Except for the 1/2", I use mostly the P&Ns. I use my Sweezey 1/2" for 75% of my turning - it is made from 2060 steel and holds an edge a little better.
I have all my bowl gouges in some type of aftermarket handle - Kelton, Bosch, Oneway, Holsulak, etc. I like a longer, heavier handles on bowl gouges.
The P&N bowl gouges have a slightly more V shape in the flute. The Sorby is more U shaped. U shapes are better for those that cut with the side of the gouge grind. V shapes work better for people that cut more with the tip. Either work fine for shear scraping/cutting.
I think that the P&Ns are just fine, and a good buy for the new turner.
Mark
Re: P&N bowl gouges
Greg Jensen
>Try taking the Black Oxide coating off the inside of the flute. I use a scotch brite pad I have on a buffer. You can use some sand paper 220 grit should work well. You may find it gives you a sharper edge.