Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

finishing apology

Posts

finishing apology

#1

finishing apology

John Lucas

>I'm sorry If my post on finishing rubbed anyone the wrong way. I have been there, using finishes that either don't work like I want or aren't compatible and have to be removed. What I was trying to say is don't "experiment" with finish on a good finished turning. There is a lot of good information out there on finishing, especially in this newsgroup. Ideally we should read all we can and try to make an intelligent decision on a finishing technique. Then try it on a scrap piece. Each of us has a slightly different technique and what works for me may not work for you. I didn't mean to sound like I was fussing about people posting here with finishing questions. That's what this group is all about so my apologies if I came off that way.

Re: finishing apology

#2

Re: finishing apology

George Van in WI

>I did not take your post negatively John. When still in high school we made sample boards with stains and finishes to have a library of what works and doesn�t on different varieties of wood. The forum allows us to expand on our knowledge or ask for guidance along the way.

Re: finishing apology

#3

Re: finishing apology

Carole in VA

>Nothing you said called for an apology! I am as guilty as they come for asking finishing questions. I find that my problem is usually I don't have scrap pieces left that are suitable or big enough for testing finishes. In other words, I can't mount them, turn them and sand them to the same state of pre-finish condition that the "good" piece is in and I have found that pre-finish condition makes a lot of difference in how a given finish "takes".

Re: finishing apology

#4

Re: finishing apology

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I didn't think what you had to say was at all out of line. There is a wealth of information not only in the archives but also in the Article section and Russ's Corner. We all need to be reminded once in awhile that it is often more educational to look for an answer on our own before asking for the answer.

Re: finishing apology

#5

Re: finishing apology

Jamie Donaldsno

>No problem John- I think many of us are guilty of continual finishing experimentation rather than standardizing on a couple of routines that work. Without that experience we are not good troubleshooters, and the glitches we create most often show their ugly heads on a really nice, time consuming turning- its another example of O'Tool's Law!

Re: finishing apology

#6

Re: finishing apology

Vicmarc.fan

>John,

I spent over 25 years refinishing furniture for a living. I found techinques and products that worked for me. I am amazed that those same techniques do not transfer from flat work to a turned object. I find it a much higher learning curve on turned things. IMHO we all have to "do it yourself" to learn because wood from the same tree will not take a finish the same way. Frankly this is what I find interesting in woodturning. You never know what you have until the first coat is applied.

Ron

Re: finishing apology

#7

Re: finishing apology

Ron in Drums PA

>Don't worry about, nothing you said called for an apology.

Re: finishing apology

#8

Re: finishing apology

bob davis

>ditto

Re: finishing apology

#9

Re: finishing apology

Barry... on SaltSpring

>Your information is good John. I apologise for taking it the wrong way!! Regards Barry... on SaltSpring

Re: finishing apology

#10

Re: finishing apology

Bob R

>John: Apology not needed. I think that the apology is from some of us newbe turners (or want to be turners). We see pictures of some great turned and finished turned works of art and want to do the same. I have found that this site has speeded up the learning curve for me but it has made it easy for me to ask, rather than to try.

Bob R

West Mac Turning (or trying)

Re: finishing apology

#11

Re: finishing apology

John Lucas

>Bob I think you have to do both. I will readily admit that it's easy to ask this group a question. There are so many knowledgeable people here. Either way you get to learn and as Keith has said before, we learn trying to answer your questions.