Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

finishing

Posts

finishing

#1

finishing

John Lucas

>I see on all the newsgroups people asking about this finish over that finish etc. Doesn't anybody do any testing of thier own. I'm not trying to be nasty, I know that it's awfully easy to jump on this machine and get a question answered, god knows I do it. When I'm playing around with paint, epoxy, lacquer, poly etc on a project I almost(notice I said almost) always keep a scrap of the same wood to try out the finish options. Nothing is worse than having finished a piece and you try some new idea on finishing and they are incompatible and wrinkle, blemish, whatever. This sucks and you have to either toss the project or spend a huge amount of time sanding off the old finish just to start over.

I would suggest that you first read Russ's Corner on finishing and then run a simple test on scrap wood. This will save you a lot of work and if you save the samples will give you good idea of what to use the next time.

This is especially true when working with analine dye's and other coloring techniques. Some paints aren't compatible with the common finishes we use and sometimes dye's and inks will run with certain finishes.

I hope no one took this as a Rant, it was meant to be more of a suggestion or a tip.

Re: finishing

#2

Re: finishing

Dawn Adams

>Speaking of Russ's articles on finishing, has anyone seen his video/DVD. I am thinking of purchasing it and wonder if it would be a good tutorial for someone new to finishing.

Re: finishing

#3

Re: finishing

Barry... on SaltSpring

>Firstly I have the video by Russ on Finishing. It is Excellent for some one like myself with no previouss experience,much as Bill Grumbines video is so helpful to amateurs and Hobbyists. I dont take Johns post as a rant, but the suggestion I get from it is do all the testing and experimenting you can think of before you waste time on this forum. Sorry If I have taken this the wrong way. Regards.. Barry...on Saltspring

Re: finishing

#4

Re: finishing

John Lucas

>Barry I hope I didn't sound like people are wasting time by asking those questions. The problem with finishing is that there are so many different brands and types of finishing that even if You(or I) ask a finishing question you may not give enough information to recieve a really good answer. If you have read the information that is already on this site you will probably be able to give the best information to the group to help solve your problem. Even then I would still suggest running a test. Temperature and humidity are other common problems with finishes and just because I live in Tennessee doesn't mean my answer will work in Oregon, Arizona or even Hawaii, and Europe.

Re: finishing

#5

Re: finishing

georgetroy

>I think a good finishing job takes time. we are striving to conquer the cross grain. Sand without leaving scratches. Our finish should adapt the use of the object. I'm an adherent to my priming with lacquer then several coats of Oil(not BLO or Watco). I also use other finishes for kitchen use or even water containment. No expert here but it has very few times in if any in my twenty five years of woodworking and turning that I have had a failure. I guess the biggest reason is I know what works for me. It also would not be unusual for a finish job to take a month waiting for the drying process. GT

Re: finishing

#6

Re: finishing

Barry... on SaltSpring

>John Thank you for your response. You are too correct, particularly regarding humidity and geographical location. I have found by experimenting what works and doesnt in my area. My only point would be to get all the information you can, including this forum before you try your experiments. If I had followed my own advise, I would lnot be working with my second $100 bowl gouge, because I went thru the first one trying to do a ellsworth grind!!! I very much enjoy your posts. Regards Barry... on SaltSpring

Re: finishing

#7

Finishing Books

Ron in Drums PA

>"Great Wood Finishes" by Jeff Jewitt

"Finishes and Finishing Techniques" by Taunton (Fine WoodWorking)

Yes, these books are written for the flat woodworker. But the basics are the basics and these books will bring you a long way to understanding how finishes work.

Re: finishing

#8

Re: Finishing Books

John Lucas

>Understanding wood finishing by Bob Flexner is also a good book.

Re: finishing

#9

Re: finishing

Gary Evans, Tallassee TN

>Hi Dawn,

I believe it was TD who commented on Russ's video to the effect that "if it's not there, you don't need to know it."

I would concur.

Gary