Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Bandsaw comparison

Posts

Bandsaw comparison

#1

Bandsaw comparison

Dawn Adams

>I have to make a decision. I can get one of the following bandsaws and am not sure which would be a better choice for me. I can't see using it for much more than cutting bowl blanks and wonder if the larger bandsaw is not just a waste of my money for my uses or if I may at times need the larger horsepower. Maybe being new to turning, I don't realize what else I will be using the bandsaw for. Opinions are solicited and needed!

Option one: (approx. $625) Jet 14" closed bandsaw with 6" riser block, 1HP, 110V, includes Carter bandsaw guides.

Option two: (approx $900) Rikon 18" bandsaw, 2HP, 220V.

Thanks in advance!

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#2

Re: Bandsaw comparison

Gary Ljostad

>I went with choice 3. Grizzly G0513, 17" 2hp 220V. $775. Had mine for 3years now with no problems. Cut lots of green blanks with Timberwolf 1/2" 3tpi blade purchased seperatly. Blade that comes with saw is fine for general dry woodworking use. As with any band saw set up is important, and eazy.

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#3

Re: Bandsaw comparison

Dawn Adams

>I'm kind of stuck with the two I mentioned. I purchased the Jet at Woodcraft and they delivered it to my home. It was supposed to be wired for 110V. I tried the saw and it would not cut without the motor bogging down. The Woodcraft people said it was a bad motor and offered to replace it or get me the new model Rikon at the old model price. One week later, the guy from Woodcraft called to say he thought he knew what the problem was - he showed up at my door and rewired it for 110V (it was wired for 220V). Now I have a perfectly good Jet in my shop that I am using (they said I could keep it and use it until the Rikon was delivered) and a Rikon on order. They said I could decide on either one I wanted. Nice guys.

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Bandsaw comparison

Richard Allen

>Woodcraft has a 1 year graentey on everything they sell. They will take the Jet back and sell you anything you like. You are not stuck with one or the other. You can select the 18" Jet or 14" Delta or 18" delta or anything else you want. Woodcraft wants you to be happy with your purchase.

With all that said, the extra HP is going to be a good thing when cutting green wood. The larger table will also be nice. The 18" Delta would be my choice.

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#5

Ditto, I love it.

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#6

Steven Antonucci

Just bought the Rikon

steve antonucci

>Used it for the first time today. It's a pretty good saw, and had all of power I needed. The book is thin, but if you know bandsaws, you can get it set up.

Steve

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#7

Re: Bandsaw comparison

Gerry in Maryland

>Dawn,

Nice meeting you at the BAT meeting Wednesday. Knowing the lathe that you have and the size of the blanks you probably will be cutting, the two things to consider when choosing a Bandsaw are:Horsepower and Table size. I have a 1hp Delta w/riser (close to what you would get with the Jet 14") and I am looking to upgrade to a saw with a bigger table and more HP. That being said, I would cross the Jet off the list. Just my $0.02..

Gerry

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#8

Re: Bandsaw comparison

GeeSeaWhy

>As you already have the Jet, you can answer your own question. Get the biggest piece of green wood you can fit under the guides and see how the saw performs. If it won't do it or bogs down badly, maybe the Rikon is worthwhile. If the Jet does OK, is it worth spending hundreds more for a machine that does the same job a bit faster?

Graeme

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#9

Re: Bandsaw comparison

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>My brother has the Jet, uses only Timberwolf blades, and it runs and cuts like a dream. When I update from my little Delta, I will definitely go with the Jet.

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#10

Re: Bandsaw comparison

Doug Trembath

>Dawn, as a production turner, I use my bandsaw a lot on green wood. That said, I started on a Laguna, about $2K, because I had it. Due to my (over) enthusiastic usage, it will no longer align correctly, won't resaw any more, and is a real PITA to use for flatwork. In turning, however, it has paid for itself many times over. I just pull all of the guides back out of the way, and use the blade without them.

I got tired of not being able to do some of the things I want to do on the flatwork side, so I recently bought the Grizzly Ultimate 14" bandsaw, based on comments read here, actually, and it was one of the best tool buying experiences I have ever had. Out of the box it was flawless, and took me about an hour to assemble, tune, and begin cutting. The manual is the best one I have ever seen on a commercial tool, and the workmanship was great. A little underpowered, when you are used to using a 3hp saw, but I believe it will do all the things I need in flatwork. I recently visited Woodcraft and did some comparisons, as objectively as I can, and I believe it's at least the equivalent, if not superior to the Jet, Delta, etc.

One more thing...Delivered, to my shop door, with riser, it was about half the cost of the competitors. The first parcel was in my hands within 30 hours of placing my order, on a Sunday night, mind you, and the rest took two days by truck.

I couldn't be happier. Woodcraft will probably take yours back if you just tell them you are dissatisfied with it. If the store gives you any grief, you can call the factory tech reps (customer service), and get them to apply some pressure that way.

Good luck with whatever you choose, and whatever choice you make, please look at your technique as you use it, and keep your body parts out of the direction of travel. TD just had a good thread going about a month or two ago about just this thing.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#11

Re: Bandsaw comparison

Frank Martin

>Dawn,

nice meeting you at BAT last week. I have the Rikon, and am very happy with it (although the blade that comes with it is awful). With a Timberwolf, its all I want. I've sliced 12" stock with no hesitation. I'm just down the road in Perry Hall. If you would like to try the Rikon for comparison, just let me know.

frank

Re: Bandsaw comparison

#12

Re: Bandsaw comparison

Dawn Adams

>Thanks for the invite, Frank. I have sent you an e-mail so I can stop by and test the Rikon.

Thanks!