We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I am turning an oak bowl for a friend at work. Got lots of oak, but I think the learning curve with this stuff will be steep. I've got the shape I want, after lots of very fine cuts, switching from gouge to skew to scraper and LOTS of sanding. Starting to look pretty nice, but boy is that oak hard. Trying a couple of things, just experimenting. A little water between cuts. Now trying a light coating of DNA between sandings. One thing I have noticed is that the dust tends to collect in a few open pores in the wood. Maybe I should have applied a sanding sealer before sanding??
>I have come to believe that the reason we don't see more oak turnings, given its abundence in the US, is not because of its appearance, but rather how difficult it is to turn.
I just pass it on by unless it is something spectacular, and then grit my teeth and bear it.
It sounds like it might be too late now, but sometimes on woods like this a gouge that is not razor sharp actually cuts better. Think of it as a serrated blade. Might surprise you. I didn't believe it at first but rather keep thinking the gouge wasn't sharp enough, so I'd get it even sharper, and it would cut worse.
>Actually, I'm treating this as a learning experience. If I can to the point where I can successfully turn something out of oak, then other species should be easier. And since I have a lot of it, it makes for good practice, anyway.
The skew is used in spindle work, side grain, and there it is tops, but it can wreck havoc on bowls as the grain changes from side to end continuosly. Maybe some people can use it in bowls, but if you are learning, stay away from it and save yourself some trouble.
>There's a reason you have lots of oak. That stuff don't turn so well as you have probably found out. If you have someone who wants an oak bowl, my suggestion is to sneak in piece of ash instead. They'll never know the difference, but you will!
>As part of a bowl turning class, the instructor was showing how to cut a foot with a skew. So, just as an experiment, I tried using it to soften up a curve, and after a couple of attempts, it worked very well.
One of the benefits of being a newbie. I'll try just about anything, once I am sure it is safe.
>Man, I almost never disagree with Mike, or Barry, but I find Oak, in it's many variations, to be a sometimes spectacular turning wood. I have about a six foot dead oak just off the cleared area on our property that I'm going to make some LARGE wall hangings from. The one thing I have experienced is that if you are a bit too enthusiastic in sanding, it will heat check quickly. I turn it green, and fairly thin, but you MUST have consistent wall thicknesses, or it will crack, similar to other fruitwoods. You will probably want to look for unusual grain patterns and save them for your best work, but if it's straight grained and oriented correctly, you get very regular ring patterns, and they almost always are remarked on by my clients, especially those who have oak kitchens, trim, etc.
As far as working characteristics, oak is a pleasure in comparison to Pecan, or as Steven Russell says, pecan-crete.
On another note, the use of a skew on anything but small detail work on a flat grain turning will be viewed by any good instructor as anathema, or for a better word, extremely dangerous. The first time you have a skew catch and flung at you, you learn quickly that that's a hell of an edge, and no telling how it will be oriented if and when it strikes you. Please reserve it for spindle work until you have a generous amount of turning experience. A bowl gouge, properly sharpened off the wheel, will make any cut you need, and won't turn on you nearly as viciously as a skew. I challenge conventional wisdom a lot, but in this case, it just seems foolhardy, with all due respect.
>Ah, so you are not a complete beginner, I trim the foot with a skew too, but on the shape itself I prefer the gouge with a long fingernail grind and fine shearing scrape cuts.
>I wholeheartedly agree with Doug. I love oak for the grain, the texture, and the appearance. It is tough to turn when dry and checks more than other species, but it can be worth it.
I also consider pecan as one of my favorite woods. It can have such surprising grain patterns and finishes so nicely.