Re: Let's go back to critique question....
Ed Moore
>TD,
As a former professor, my duties frequently involved visiting classes of junior members and following up the visit with a "heart-to-heart" discussion. You can bet that I did my absolute best to be diplomatic and to avoid a confrontational attitude. It was my experience that almost every time I made a constructive comment, no matter how well phrased, I got a defensive argument coming back the other way. Now it seems to me that if you wish to enter through a gate, then it isn't very clever to argue with one of the gatekeepers.
I am one of the founders of Smith Mountain Lake Woodturners, the Program Director, and host of Skill Enhancement sessions in my shop. I point this out so that you will understand that I will occasionally be asked to critique someone's newest creation. I always try to find a way to ask them which level of critique they want. Usually they will say they want the full treatment. Always start with something positive if it is available, maybe a comparative remark about this piece versus previous efforts. If there are marks that should have been sanded out I point them out and do not hold back because anyone can sand, or learn to. When it comes to form or thickness, if there is a feature I don't like I put things in the frame of reference of my preferences and tell them what I would like better, but add that that is my taste.
And when I don't know what to say, I go back to the old standby "Now that's interesting!" I guess this is akin to seeing an ugly baby and saying "Now there's a baby!"
In the thread "Canon A620 and an ugly box" that I posted, I felt that folks gave good constructive criticism and tried to help me. So that respondents would tell it like it is, I told them I was wearing my asbestos suit.
If someone tells me that they like to critique the work of others, I give that a lot of thought as I mentally evaluate them. I want to know why.
Ed