Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Let's go back to critique question....

Posts

Let's go back to critique question....

#1

Let's go back to critique question....

TD

>There is a thread below about critiqueing that needs more attention.

At a local or club level critiqueing is normally limited to skills and simple form while at national levels it would be much more in depth. Good answers were given for both but no one suggested where to divide the two or if there should be a distinction between the two. I got to wondering, where do other clubs draw this line? To me I would think that if you push the envelope too far at a local club level there might be risks to the club's unity. What do the rest of you think?

TD

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#2

JL

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

JL

>Depends on the thickness of skins. Many people take critiques and criticism personally. I think if you want to have formal critques, they have to be made "non-threatening". I think that if there is interaction in the critiquing format and a way of making it non-competitive, it would probably go over better. Present things as alternatives and in an exploratory fashion.

I think that is also important to realize that there is no one "right" way of making something. Maybe I'm all wet. Anyway, my $0.02.

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#3

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

Phil Joines

>At the club level I'd be real carefull of doing an in depth of normal show and tell items. What I'd like to see is a spacific program from a knowlogable person. I've tried to get professors from the local collages, UNT & TWU, art departments to do one. They aren't interested.

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#4

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

RussFairfield

>I see there being 2 types of critique, but not divided along the lines you have suggested. One is a 2-way conversation, and the other is not.

One is the critique that takes place as a conversation between whoever made the piece and whoever is critiquing it. The other is an evaluation in front of an open forum. It is a 1-way presentation, and the presence of the person who made it not required.

One can be a learning experience, while that is not necessary for the other.

There is nothing to prevent either from taking place at any time or location. Either could be in the local club meeting, a national symposium, or in someone's shop.

The 2-way discussion type of critique best serves the needs of the local club because it can be an educational tool. A critical evaluation of the piece in front of an audience assumes that the person already knows how to turn wood.

I would really like to see the 2-way conversation between critiquer and artist used at the National Symposium level in woodturning.

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#5

Agreed. But . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There would probably have to be some preparation between the presenter and the reviewer prior to the "real" session. This is because any number of people might not wish to be personally spotlighted in front of a "national" audience, and some might become quite defensive, especially if the reviewer asked them questions to which they found they couldn't give what they considered acceptable answers; nobody wants to appear "dumb" in front of a bunch of strangers.

It could, however, be tremendous if, say in the AAW Symposium IG Critique, 3 or 4 of the pieces could be selected for the "Socratic" method. If different kinds of pieces were selected (bowl, HF, segmented, etc.) and each dialogue were handled by a different "expert", (or 3-4 pieces pieces of the same type but presenting different issues and 1 expert) now we're talking $aleable video following the show!

M

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#6

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

Arch

>Perhaps on request, two turners of different persuasion or orientation, could fill out printed 'balance sheets' with limited subjective footnotes, in which the credits and debits _must balance might cause less grief and be more helpful. Maybe the credits/debits list could be standardized and as objective as possible, omitting phrases such as "I like", "this is wrong" etc., instead using choice of wood, overall form, lines, weight, finish, utility, etc.

Could "critique" ("an act or instance of criticizing. esp. a critical estimate or discussion"... Webster) be the wrong word for club use? Perhaps Assessment? Peer review? Growth stimulator? even "Brag Sheet".:) Whatever?

Obviously TD, I haven't thought this out very well, so dont'critique it too closely. :) Arch

-=

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#7

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>Our club always has a show and tell but the "critique" is on request....

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#8

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

Ed Moore

>TD,

As a former professor, my duties frequently involved visiting classes of junior members and following up the visit with a "heart-to-heart" discussion. You can bet that I did my absolute best to be diplomatic and to avoid a confrontational attitude. It was my experience that almost every time I made a constructive comment, no matter how well phrased, I got a defensive argument coming back the other way. Now it seems to me that if you wish to enter through a gate, then it isn't very clever to argue with one of the gatekeepers.

I am one of the founders of Smith Mountain Lake Woodturners, the Program Director, and host of Skill Enhancement sessions in my shop. I point this out so that you will understand that I will occasionally be asked to critique someone's newest creation. I always try to find a way to ask them which level of critique they want. Usually they will say they want the full treatment. Always start with something positive if it is available, maybe a comparative remark about this piece versus previous efforts. If there are marks that should have been sanded out I point them out and do not hold back because anyone can sand, or learn to. When it comes to form or thickness, if there is a feature I don't like I put things in the frame of reference of my preferences and tell them what I would like better, but add that that is my taste.

And when I don't know what to say, I go back to the old standby "Now that's interesting!" I guess this is akin to seeing an ugly baby and saying "Now there's a baby!"

In the thread "Canon A620 and an ugly box" that I posted, I felt that folks gave good constructive criticism and tried to help me. So that respondents would tell it like it is, I told them I was wearing my asbestos suit.

If someone tells me that they like to critique the work of others, I give that a lot of thought as I mentally evaluate them. I want to know why.

Ed

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#9

Re: Let's go back to critique. To assure pc

Arch

>In an abundance of pc and to reassure anyone who would have the audacity to disrespect my critique: "persuasion" or "orientation" do not concern age, sex, religion, politics, race, color, creed, felt bottoms, file scrapers or duplicator attachments; just plain ole 'whatcha like to turn'. So there! :)

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#10

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

Ed Karch

>"critique" ("an act or instance of criticizing. esp. a critical estimate or discussion"... The word has been corrupted from an assessment or judging against known standards which is constructive to something destructive such as being negative and critical.

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#11

known standards.....I like it!

TD

>This is what I was trying to say in the original thread. Smoothness of curves (no flat spots), finish, sanding or tool marks, over-all form, choice of wood, etc. All of these are known standards. Beyond this you get into a lot of hype and personal likes/dislikes. At a club level I think this is as far as we should go. Any other comments?

TD

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#12

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>At a club that I once belonged to, we had an interesting critique session as the program for a meeting. We invited anyone who wanted one or two or more pieces critiqued to present them at the meeting. We had two well known local turners, two well known clay potters, who of course do similar forms, and a local gallery owner. Each offered their critique of each piece offered. It was interesting to hear the similarities and differences in the critiques. The gallery owner looked at the pieces as art objects to sell so she sometimes saw them in a different perspective.

Wally

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#13

Two big points there,and one of my own.

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>We also used to critique by request only.The person who had brought the piece usually talked about it in "show and tell" first(so we got some background) and then asked a specific person to critique.

Set standards-Not only established guidelines that can be researched,but also set standards for conducting the critique.After seeing more than one member get sliced pretty deep afew of us felt guidelines were in order and consulted Jacques Vesery as to a proper format.We`ve tried to stick with his very well thought out suggestions.

Any critique is only as good as the person receiving it.I`ve tried to get thru to some folks but thier minds are made up and they`re not really looking for feedback,just someone to agree with them.No amount of advice,no matter how well meant or carefully spoken is going to dent thier armor.Move on to someone who really is looking for the path to real growth and improvement.

If you can point to something in print to back up your statements then they carry more weight.I`m constantly loaning my books on design and steering people who ask toward sources for information(like here and the AAW site).

The trick is to link an open mind with sound advice aimed toward growth and improvement.Everything else is just air of varying temperature.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#14

Re: Two big points there,and one of my own.

Les Robison

>Can you please share Vesley's thought on the critique methodology?

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Two big points there,and one of my own.

Keith Tompkins

>Known Standards....finally!! Things that have been taken for granted by the art community for thousands of years are finally being considered in the turning world.

As part of my demonstration on form and design, I will turn an intentionally poor form. In that way, I can do a severe critique and not offend anyone (Once, however, I was a bit harsh and actually became angry with myself):P I then use "known standards" such as the golden rectangle to show the proportion is off on the piece I'm critiquing. I can also use the same piece to show the effect of balance, by comparing it to a piece with obviously better balance.Of course, I explain the principle of balance and how it will affect the appearance of a piece...as well as showing how to correct the problem. Then, other things come into play as well, and should be considered...emphasis, rythm,and unity, to name a few. I have done this demo for three years now and have discovered:

1. Many turners don't feel they need to understand even basic ideas concerning form and design.

2. Many people have attended my demo out of a feeling of obligation...and admitted that to me later. (remove them from category 1.)

3. Many people who attended the same demo asked.."do you really consider all those things before you create a turning?"

4. Most who attended the demo felt differently about form and design after sitting through the session...sometimes, I can actually see the lightbulbs going off in someone's head during parts of the talk.

5. If you critique a piece produced by someone who thinks principles or "known standards" are just rubbish, the critique is meaningless. In many cases, and I've seen it happen, it's easier to be offended than to listen with an open mind.

6. Several turners have commented to me after such a demo..."While you were talking, I thought you must be speaking directly to me! I had to look around to see if everyone was looking in my direction. I was having problems with my pieces and couldn't understand why...now I'm beginning to see what the problem is."

7. Due to politically incorrect language, #7 has been deleted by the moderator. I have already apologized, and it won't happen again! I'm glad you didn't have to read THAT!

8. I can learn from each demo, and improve upon it next time by critiquing my performance.

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#16

Re: Let's go back to critique question.... *LINK*

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Club critiques are indeed riskly and sometimes frustrating. I've seen two extremes, neither of which was satisfying.

The first was someone who had a reasonable eye for design, but he had just returned from the national symposium and started talking about having your own "voice". This was in the critique of a classic bowl shape by a beginning turner. An objection to the critique was raised by a third party (me), and that effectively ended all real critiques.

At the other end, a couple of years later I was playing with vase shapes and brought in five small ones. I knew that several of them needed improvement and asked for a critique to help improve my designs. Couldn't get one. The best I could get is "they all look nice".

I guess I'm trying to say is that finding a qualified person who is willing to give critiques can be a major challenge.

No one has mentioned it yet, but the Spring 2004 American Woodturner had a good article "The Art of Critique" by Jim Christiansen. The evaluation form and guidelines are available on the AAW web site at the link below.


AAW Critique/Evaluation Form

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#17

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

Dick Anderson

>Jim Christiansen's write-up on effective critiques was featured in the Jan-Feb 2003 issue of Woodworker West. He states, "Critiques are essential in a woodturners development, and it need not be a negative experience."

Jan-Feb 2004 issue of Fine Woodworking had an article titled, A Guide to Good Design. Mostly focused on furniture design, but applicable to woodturning. Some reference to the golden ratio (golden mean).

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#18

Best Response, Wally

Ruth Niles

>I've never liked a critique done by one person nor only by woodturners because that boils down to their opinion or personal likes and dislikes. I work with a potter and his perception of a few forms has taught me more than some of the national critiques. I've just connected with a glass blower (for doing bottle stoppers) and she sees form from a slightly different angle and I'm loving it.

Just one woman's opinion.

Ruth

Re: Let's go back to critique question....

#19

Design reference material by turners

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Afew good reference books for design/turning are Mike Darlow`s design book.Richard Raffan`s Turned Bowl Design,while no longer in print,is well worth chasing up as it shows how to develope a form from rough blank thru evaluation and removal of defects to finished piece.Bert Marsh also talks about design in his book in ways that are easy to understand and his forms are both organic and flawless.

A more in depth design book would be Steven Hogbin`s Appearance and Reality.He covers just about everything from color and texture to form and proportion in a structured and straight forward way.It truely is a "Handbook for artists and makers" as the subtitle states.

These books are afew of my favorites and the ones I most often steer people to.I`d like to hear about what others find useful and helpful.

Mainely,Bob