Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

Posts

2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#1

2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

Ken Langenberger

>I think a 2hp is big enough or should I spend the extra $300 for a 3 hp? Most of my turnings are smaller with only a few bigger ones and still learning.

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#2

3 hp on Oneway 2436?

e

>plan for tomorrow -- plus i figure my 3hp will sell better at my estate sale :>)

i do know that the bowl corer works better w/3hp ... you never know where your turning needs will go; for example, i wish i'd gotten the large outboard attachment. however, now if i do, i know i'll have enough hp to drive the work.

and think what a hassle it will be to change motors when you decide your underpowered.

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#3

3hp will throw you to the ceiling faster

TD

>Unless you are using a coring tool you will never need more than 2 hp

TD

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#4

don't listen to him ...

e

>one always needs MORE POWER ...

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#5

Dick Hines

Re: don't listen to him ...

Dick Hines

>Is that why you bought the compresser with the 60 Gallon tank?

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#6

and more than twice my weight!

e

>ahhhh, yes .... i will have enough hot air to keep me going for some time!!!

that is once i muscle-up enough to get the damn thing in its place!!!

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#7

Re: 3hp will throw you to the ceiling faster

Mac

>Bull tookie,get the three,worth every cent of it and cheaper to do it now instead of later. TD loved the three horse on mine.....

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#8

3 horse...3 horse...3 horse...

Paul in Phoenix, AZ

>...Later on, you'll be glad you did!

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#9

Further clarification...

TD

>I have a 2hp lathe and a 3hp lathe that I use daily. I do not core. My 3hp lathe (a VB-36) replaced a 2hp (VB-36). The 3hp is now for sale, I am going back to the 2hp. Why? The 2 hp has all the power I want and it is quieter. Some of the lathe manufacturers program their controllers to cut the power back if a sudden power draw is sensed; this is a safety thing but it essentially cuts the hp. With a 2 hp or a 3 hp motor I can't tell much difference as either one will stall if a take a quick, heavy cut. Since you say you make mostly smaller things I would recommend the 2 hp. I have turned several 36" diameter bowls on a 2 hp lathe with no problems.

TD

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#10

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

Rick Allen

>Hi Ken

The 3HP will let you run the lathe on the high speed pulley without being underpowered. With 2 HP you might have to change the belt from time to time.

Either way you are going to love that lathe.

Other items to consider are the breaking resistor, the RFI filter and the remote on/off. These things are a pain to add latter on. A lot more of a pain than the cost of those products. I would also add the short bed extention for use on the inboard side. Being able to slide the tailstock out of the way is worth the price of the bed extension.

There are a few other additions to the lathe which you could make but those other things could easly be added latter if you decide they are worthwhile. That is one of the terrific things about the Oneway lathes, you can add "stuff" to the lathe to make the lathe fully capable for many different uses.

You want a pedistal lathe? Put the short bed extension on the outboard side.

You want to turn stuff up to 48"? Add the large outboard extension. You can even add "stuff" so a tailstock can be used when swinging 48" hunks of wood.

Want to turn pencil post bed that are 7' long? Get the long bed extention.

THe great things about the Oneway lathe are the lack of limits to your woodturning.

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#11

Re: 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

Vicmarc.fan

>I don't like the Oneway so I don't own one but I have a lathe with 24" throw and a 3HP motor and my experience with my lathe is with the 3HP motor I am able to core or anything else on the highest speed pulley which saves a lot of time by not having to change the belt all the time. If you don't get the 3HP motor now it will be a big expense later.

Ron

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#12

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

Bill Neddow

>Ken, go with the 3hp, and then you will not be retrofitting later at considerably more cost.

When I bought my Oneway, I was at about the same stage of learning you are at now. Then I realized that my market for bowls was calling for larger ones. I now never turn anything under 14 inches and a lot of them are over 2 feet in diameter. I am so glad I got the 3hp up front. It really speeds up the coring and shaping -- and is very nice to have when i do a deep hollow vase.

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#13

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Ken,

This is just my personal opinion... but I would not buy a Caddy without the power windows. :) Go for the three hp right off the bat. It is always there if you need it, and it does not cost that much more over the life of the lathe. And mine is very,very quiet. :)

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#14

Thanks for the tips

Ken Langenberger

>

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#15

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

ThomD

>"? Most of my turnings are smaller with only a few bigger ones and still learning."

If that is true you don't need this lathe!

How much more power does the 3HP burn when turning pens, and small spindles etc... Seriously. Pros try to keep it running but when one takes on lots of varied projects there is a lot of starting and stopping, and those big moptors have a lot of rotating weight.

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#16

Question was not want or need

Ken Langenberger

>

Re: 2 hp or 3 hp on Oneway 2436?

#17

Re: Kinda a Rorschach question

ThomD

>