Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box
Ed Moore
>Keith,
Thank you very much for your critique. I agree with it, although I will try to explain, not justify, choices I made. I looked at the bottom of the lid and those two little white dots that you spotted are indeed a small tear. Of more concern to me, but not visible in the photo, are the paint streaks that resemble sanding marks. I had a devil of a time with the acrylic paint. The actual color of the box is like the right-hand portion of the first picture, maybe at the 2/3 - 1/3 point from left to right. So, it seems too dark to me.
The finial. I made the lid after doing most of the other painting and at that point I felt like I had painted myself into the proverbial corner. The rich gold interior looked okay with the rest of the form, but it was too strong for the exterior of the lid. I could not think of a color that would work as the third color. So, more dark blue seemed like my only choice. That being said, with all that paint showing I felt that I had to have an ebony finial, and as you said, an understated one. Quite possibly I succeeded too well in that last regard. I felt that a Cindy Drozda-like finial was wrong for this shape box. I tend to avoid pointed finials on boxes that may be used. Any suggestions? Would cocobolo have been a better choice for the finial here?
Incidentally, I agree with an earlier comment by Ed Karch that the lid should have been a little more domed and a little thicker. In honesty, I took a little too much off the shoulder of the lid, causing it to sit too deep.
As to the shape of the finial, would it look better if I duplicated the shape of the overall form on about 3/32" of platform?
Thanks for your help.
Ed