Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Canon A620 and an ugly box

Posts

Canon A620 and an ugly box

#1

Canon A620 and an ugly box

Ed Moore

>The thread on digitals cameras resonated with me, I checked things out on camera review sites, and then I followed Sean's recommendation and got the Canon A620. I feel very good about this choice. So today I took two pictures of a box that I have painted with acrylic paint. It seemed like a good idea at the time, but with the lid in place this box is dead. I can easily make another lid, but I urge you to make suggestions as to how to recover here. Before you post, please look at my followup post and picture with the lid off.

Thanks,

Ed


img

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#2

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box II

Ed Moore

>Here's the box with the lid off. Don't blame the camera for the resolution. I scaled it waaaay down to get below the limit.

I request your comments -- the asbestos suit is in place. FIRE AWAY!!

Ed


img

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#3

JL

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box II

JL

>Fuzzy pic. I like the choice of colors. The pics are not "quite" in focus.

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#4

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box II

Ed Karch

>Nice box. remake the lid from a contrasting color like holly and dome it a bit to avoid a flat.

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#5

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box II

Ed Moore

>JL,

These were edited versions of my first two shots with the camera. I should have used close-up mode, but was chicken. However, when you go from 1.3 MB to 30 or 36 KB you expect to lose a lot of clarity. Adding to being not focussed just right, you see what we get. Thanks,

Ed

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#6

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Sean Troy

>Hi Ed, I find if you mount the camera on a tripod about 3 feet from the turning and not zoom in, your pics will be much cleaner. You can crop them with your photo software. Set that camera to the finest setting and you can shoot in auto to see how my suggestion works. Good luck, you'll get the hang of it. Sean

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#7

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box II

Ed Moore

>Ed,

The box is made from ash. Would an ash lid left natural work? I agree with the suggested shape improvement. Should I stick with the ebony finial? The rim is stippled with the burner and then blackened with gesso.

I have never tried adding color like this, but I wanted to do something to jazz the box up a bit. The actual color is darker, as in the first picture. What I envisioned as easy -- isn't.

I have a lot to learn about the camera, photography in general, and photo editing.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#8

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box II

Bryan Jones

>I agree with Ed , a contrasting color for lid would be much better .

have fun with your new camera

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#9

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box II

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ed, I'm not sure why you think it's so ugly? I rather like it myself. The dark rim is a nice touch and I like the finial/knob too. I think the idea of a natural lid might be an alternative....but definintly not something that needs to be done.

I love boxes and really need to try my hand at making them more. There are so many variations and design opportunities with boxes and containers. I say leave it as is....and keep on going!

Jen :)

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ed, well, here's my critique. I think the blue lid and form go well together..the black textured rim adds enough contrast.It appears elegant and a bit understated. Removing the lid reveals a pleasant surprise...the gold interior. A contrasting lid may be a bit too much.

Slimming down the foot slightly may improve the overall appearance, however; it is attractive as is,you have developed a good line. The problem with the lid isn't so much the lid...it's the finial. It does't appear to compliment the rest of the piece... Some design work is needed...a sketch book would be a great way the visualize it. If you can nail the finial, the effect will pull the whole unit together.

On many pieces, the minor details can make or break the overall impression. The grain on the inside of the lid appears to be torn..the first thing I noticed. Fine detail, even in unexpected areas such as under the lid will add a great deal to the piece. A nice touch would possibly be exposing the tenon on the finial, with a constasting wedge that secures it. Then a cutting technique to finish it off would eliminate the torn grain problem.

What do you think about the finial? Lots of good stuff here to work with...Keith

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#11

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Ed Moore

>Keith,

Thank you very much for your critique. I agree with it, although I will try to explain, not justify, choices I made. I looked at the bottom of the lid and those two little white dots that you spotted are indeed a small tear. Of more concern to me, but not visible in the photo, are the paint streaks that resemble sanding marks. I had a devil of a time with the acrylic paint. The actual color of the box is like the right-hand portion of the first picture, maybe at the 2/3 - 1/3 point from left to right. So, it seems too dark to me.

The finial. I made the lid after doing most of the other painting and at that point I felt like I had painted myself into the proverbial corner. The rich gold interior looked okay with the rest of the form, but it was too strong for the exterior of the lid. I could not think of a color that would work as the third color. So, more dark blue seemed like my only choice. That being said, with all that paint showing I felt that I had to have an ebony finial, and as you said, an understated one. Quite possibly I succeeded too well in that last regard. I felt that a Cindy Drozda-like finial was wrong for this shape box. I tend to avoid pointed finials on boxes that may be used. Any suggestions? Would cocobolo have been a better choice for the finial here?

Incidentally, I agree with an earlier comment by Ed Karch that the lid should have been a little more domed and a little thicker. In honesty, I took a little too much off the shoulder of the lid, causing it to sit too deep.

As to the shape of the finial, would it look better if I duplicated the shape of the overall form on about 3/32" of platform?

Thanks for your help.

Ed

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#12

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I consider it a knob more than a finial, and that's OK. What if he carried on the texture idea form the rim? Maybe make a v groove on top of the knob, about 1/3 of the way in and texture it from the groove out to the edge. I think the flat lid works well because it is lower than the edge of the box. If they were flush it would need a design element to seperate them.

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#13

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I bought the Canon A610. It's the same as the 620 except it is 5 Mega Pixel instead of 7, and around $100 less expensive. I agree the tripod really helps. This Camera really works a lot better in low light situations than my old Fuji Film 3800 does. There is an indoor setting in the scene modes. It is supposed to work better with artificial lights and indoor type exposures. I've only had the camera a few days and haven't got to check everything out yet, but so far I am pleased.

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#14

Re: Hey Ed- you learned to ...

JamieDonaldson

>...turn by practicing, and the same goes for photos- keep practicing, and you now don't have to waste film and paper!

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#15

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>I`d put the rim texture on the top of the finial too and maybe thin out the finial shoulder when it joins the top and the waist area then call it good.That`s just me though.

Don`t know why you`re so disappointed with it,I kind of like it,especially the gold leaf interior.Nice surprise.

Wonder how silver leaf would look with that color blue,maybe give it a colder feel.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Keith Tompkins

>HI Ed, I think ebony ties in perfectly with the black rim...cocobolo wouldn't seem to fit, again a distraction, I think. your eye would travel from the box, to the black rim, to the finial, trying to decide what's happening here. Black fits with the blue and creates a feeling of UNITY. I think the flat lid works as is, it doesn't overwhelm the form.

The finial really isn't a problem, it's an opportunity. To me, the best part of turning is figuring out how to make things work together. Try the finial that mimics the form just to see how it looks. Long term, study how glass artists or potters deal with form, lids, knobs or finials. Make sketches of particularly attractive pieces, and learn from them.

In this case, a slender but simple finial may be the answer. Worth a shot! I think it would continue the feeling of "lift" created by the form.

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#17

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Ed Karch

>Ok I took asecond look. On the first run through I didn't notice the black textured rim and the black finial. My eye just classified them as dark and passed over. on the inside rim you might consider bringing the black down onto the inside shoulder as it is much easier to break from one color to another on an outside corner rather than an inside corner. It is not an ugly box. What did you use for the gold, leaf, paint, wax or none of the above.The overall shape moves the eye up to the top. A bit more lift on the finial might help the eye resolve the top better. Ithin this may be one of those pieces that need to be picked up and fondled to be fully appreciated. Thanks for posting it.

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#18

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Ed Moore

>Ed,

For two years it has been my intention to marble some tops of birdhouse ornaments and some platter or bowl rims. Consequently, I have accumulated a nice collection of acrylic paints. Further inspiration from some books caused me to try this box, which in turn has tried my patience. All surfaces except the ebony finial have been painted with the acrylic paint. Most of my problems have come from not knowing how much to thin the paint. Too thin and it doesn't cover, too thick and it doesn't go on easily.

I want to try a purple box with red interior and some other combinations. Probably the stippled rim will continue to be used.

The one thing I have learned is that a thin coat of wipe-on gel urethane is good for a last coat. It gives a nice feel and just enough lustre to the box.

The problem I have with this box is that it is a little too dark with the lid on. It lacks that "pick me up to see how I feel" appeal that we sometimes want our pieces to have.

Thanks for your help. I'm going to experiment with a a slightly taller finial/knob that is an elongated version of the box shape. The current question I am mulling over is whether to put a bead just above the base.

Ed

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#19

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

Ed Karch

>In design there is a rule of three. Any more than three strong features distracts. You have shape, color, and finial which are strong features. A bead might overdo. If you can print your photo try drawing the bead on the print or photoshop it if you have that software. Draw changes to your finial until you find the one that pleases your eye. If you have an air brush try diluting your acrylics and spraying until you hit the intensity you like.

Re: Canon A620 and an ugly box

#20

Good suggestions. Thanks!!

Ed Moore

>