Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

power sanding RPMs?

Posts

power sanding RPMs?

#1

power sanding RPMs?

GaryG in MD

>I just bought an angle drill for power sanding. Like many such drills, it has a variable speed trigger. It goes up to 1400 RPM max., but that seems too fast to me.

I'm sure I'll get a number of different answers to this question (indeed, that's what I want), and I'm sure that different speeds are appropriate for different circumstances, so my question is: what RPM should I use, and for what circumstances?

Let me break that into two questions. What's a good speed for sanding with the lathe 'on', and what's a good speed for sanding with the lathe 'off'?

TIA, Gary

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#2

Re: power sanding RPMs?

Rick Allen

>Hi Gary

It all depends.

I usualy sand Birch with the lathe turning at 476 RPM and the drill counter rotating at 789 rpm using the leading edge of a 2" disc for sanding the outside and most of the inside. For the first 1.27" rim towards center I change rotation and sand with the trailing edge at 1136 RPM

I usualy sand Hard Maple with the lathe turning at 723 RPM and the drill counter rotating at 1226 rpm using the leading edge of a 3" disc for sanding the outside and most of the inside. For the first 1.77" rim towards center I change rotation and sand with the trailing edge at 614 RPM

I usualy sand Cherry with the lathe turning at 373 RPM and the drill counter rotating at 509 rpm using the leading edge of a 2" disc for sanding the outside and most of the inside. For the first 0.77" rim towards center I change rotation and sand with the trailing edge at 697 RPM

I usualy sand American Black Walnut with the lathe turning at 263 RPM and the drill counter rotating at 1226 rpm using the leading edge of a 2" disc for sanding the outside and most of the inside. For the first 1.67" rim towards center I change rotation and sand with the trailing edge at 612 RPM. Please note that I start with 180 grit and I will sometimes exhaust 2 or 3 of discs of the initial grit before moving to the next grit.

I usualy sand White Ash with the lathe turning at 835 RPM and the drill counter rotating at 2192 rpm using the leading edge of a 2" disc for sanding the outside and most of the inside. For the first 2.04" rim towards center I change rotation and sand with the trailing edge at 1254 RPM

I usualy sand Cocobolo with the lathe turning at 348 RPM and the drill counter rotating at 1767 rpm using the leading edge of a 2" disc for sanding the outside and most of the inside. For the first 0.85" rim towards center I change rotation and sand with the trailing edge at 1814 RPM

Merry Christmas

P.S. Yes it's a joke

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#3

JL

Re: power sanding RPMs? ROTFLOL

JL

>

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#4

JL

Re: power sanding RPMs?

JL

>Seriously though - remember that they sell the Sorby "Sandmaster" - which is just a "freewheeling 2" sponge head". It works at whatever rpm is generated by the contact with the lathe. It is a matter of feel. You want a high enough rpm to feel comfortable and get good sanding. I usually sand at lower rpm when the lathe is on and higher rpm when the lathe is off.

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#5

Re: power sanding RPMs?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>This is really subjective, but I sand with the lathe near "dead slow", maybe 100-150 rpm for a 7" bowl. The drill is running about 1/4 to 1/3 speed - the edge of the pad that is moving in the same direction as the turning is moving about twice as fast as the wood. Actually, I try to maximize the plume of dust going into the dust collector. I run the drill at about the same speed with the lathe turned off. Well, most of the time. Sometimes it's a lot slower when I'm really going after a bad section. I also hand sand which is equivalent to a very, very low drill rpm.

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#6

Incomplete

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Gary,

Rick left out that the plane of the abrasive media surface should meet the work surface at an angle of precisely 11.4* with the tangential direction of rotation of the abrasive media in a range of +/- 4.65* from radial axis for internal work, +/- 7.25* for outside work, and at a deadnuts 1.4* for rim sanding.

[Rick, I can't believe you left that out!]

|;-}}}

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#7

Re: power sanding RPMs?

John Lucas

>Gary

I have no idea what speeds I turn at or my drill speed. None of the them have rpm's. I turn the lathe way down and the try to make the disc on the drill run faster than the bowl. It seems to give less spirals this way. On small bowls I often just hand sand. When I do that I don't turn the lathe speed down as much. For spindles I usually just leave the lathe at whatever speed it is set at and then after initial sanding I stop the lathe and sand with the grain.

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#8

Re: power sanding RPMs?

JKJ in East TN

>I generally sand with the drill speed low and the lathe speed low or off. A lower speed seems to work better for me and generates less heat. Heat from high speed and pressure can cause checks in sensitive wood, destroy the velcro hooks on the pad, and wear out the paper rapidly.

For the inside of bowls, I do much of the sanding with the lathe turned off, rotating the bowl back and forth by hand with the sander running as slow as it will go. Then follow up with hand sanding with the grain. I think the best quality is from sanding by hand, but the power sanding disk helps avoid local surface irregularities (i.e., dips in softer areas), especially with coarser grits.

If I run into a troublesome area (hard-to-remove scratches or end grain tearout), instead of powering through it with a higher speed I think prefer to drop back to a coarser grit, often in conjunction with some soft wax or oil or sanding sealer.

I almost never use power sanding on spindles.

JKJ

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#9

Re: power sanding RPMs?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Hmmmm, Brian, I alway make sure that the sanding disk is either moving across the rotation, or opposite. I see an indepth study coming....

Mark

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#10

Re: power sanding RPMs?

Don Tewell

>Thanks goodness. I was wondering how you got such exact measurements, especailly sanding. Good joke, it got me going.

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#11

Re: power sanding RPMs?

GaryG in MD

>JL, I've been using a Sandmaster up till now, but I don't like the way it slows down in the center of bowls and platters. So now I have a drill too. Thanks for the thoughts. ...Gary

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#12

Re: power sanding RPMs?

GaryG in MD

>OK troops, which way is it? ...Gary

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#13

Re: power sanding RPMs?

GaryG in MD

>Brian, Your comment about 1/4 to 1/3 speed is the kind of thing I was looking for. One thing I want to do is glue in a block on the trigger so it won't go full speed when I give it a full squeeze, and I was wondering how much speed to "block" out. Thanks. ...Gary

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#14

Re: power sanding RPMs?

GaryG in MD

>John,

I'm using a Jet 1236, and it doesn't go really slowly. I'm already running it below the first detent. That will just have to be slow enough.

I'm surprised to hear you say that you hand sand with the lathe on. I've been avoiding that because I thought it was almost guaranteed to give rotary scratches?

Thanks for your thoughts.

Gary

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#15

Re: power sanding RPMs?

GaryG in MD

>JKJ, All good info. That's what I was looking for. Thanks. ...Gary

Re: power sanding RPMs?

#16

Re: you're right

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I was trying to give a visual indication of the speeds and I completely forgot to mention that I sand using the cross-grain and opposite direction edges of the sandpaper. Thanks for clarifying that.