We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Just like all of you, I'm trying hard to get better at my work. Just like most of you, I value other's comments and thoughts of my work. And just like a few of you, I'm asking for critiques of my work.
At our newly recognized Woodturning group, I'm strongly encouraging people to bring in show-and-tell pieces. At least for mine, I'm asking for my fellow members to critique my work.
So I ask you, what are effective ways to critique. I think that there is always something good in a piece and that should be recognized. However, every piece can be improved upon. I hope when my work is being looked at they say something more than "it's poorly shaped" or "that's butt-ugly". How can I learn to do this better and help others along the way?
>First, tell what is good about the piece; then tell what you think might could be done to make it even better. Stay with reliable standards as much as possible, things like finish, sanding or tool marks, even wall thickness, balance and form....in that order. If you want to break it down you can use the one to five measure on each point; finish is a 3, sanding is a 4, etc. Be impartial. If it is a style that you do not have an interest in you might want to start by disqualifying yourself as being able to judge that piece. We all have seen pieces that just don't "trip our trigger" but others love them. You just can't judge a piece fairly if it is a style that you personally don't like.
>I always start out asking the person who made it things like "what do you like most about it" and "if you were to make it again what would you change and why".Those type of questions will get you a long way.
From there it`s pretty much what TD said.
When it comes to form one of the best ways to assess form is to make up a translucent screen and put the piece behind it with a strong light behind the piece.The light will project a dark image onto the screen and eliminate things like wild grain and texture.Later you can use the screen as part of your lite box for pics to put in the club`s newsletter.
I also try to start and end my input on a positive note.
>Hi Chip this is an excellent post. Many turners have experienced hurt feelings or worse as a result of a critique.
First, I think a formal critique should be done by someone who truly understands the concepts of form, and recognizes what steps need to be taken to improve the pieces receiving the critique. Second, the critique must be subjective; the only goal of the person doing the critique should be to offer insight, and to give their honest opinion as to corrections that need to be made.
You must realize, people can become emotionally attached to their work, criticism of their work is often interpreted as a critcism of them personally. Care must be taken here; when I critique a piece, I make sure the person completely understands this. The turner who requests a critique must have an open mind as well, if they become offended by an honest critique, the critique is useless...
For instance, if a piece appears unbalanced, I'll take the time to explain the concept of balance, and the effect it has on a piece. From my experience, many people attempt to embellish their work before they have developed a sense of proportion or good form, or even good turning technique. In this case, I emphasize the importance of mastering the basics before delving into more advanced techniques.
the recipient of the critique should leave with a feeling that they have been helped...encouraged that their work will improve with a bit of effort. Remember...if you point out the areas of a person's work that needs improvement, be sure to point out their strong points as well.
It's important to also remember, be careful about ridiculing a piece while it sits out during an instant gallery or club show and tell. The maker may be standing right behind you.....
>Jim Christiansen has prepared a writeup on how to do a good, positive, informative critique. His writing has been in a couple publications and should be readily available. His web site is www.kestrelcreek.com, which is full of a lot of great information. If you email him I'll bet he will send you a copy of his critique methodology.
>Is to understand the piece, what it's about, and the visual "meaning" of what has been presented within the object. The most serious error that most commenters make is expressing opinions based upon their own style or work. The presenter doesn't give a damn how I or Terry or Keith might do the piece, and comments that reveal such a viewpoint are about guaranteed to piss off the maker and make the critque worthless. Stuff like "I would (do it this way)" must be avoided at all costs. Since Keith has been on the receiving end of a few of my critiques, he has seen how I do them. A good crit takes a great deal of mental effort by the reviewer, first to try to understand what is being presented, and then, in a neutral and non-judgmental way, to list and discuss the perceived strengths, weaknesses, and conflicts within the context of the object itself. It is a dynamic procees that should involve some questions and answers between the reviewer and presenter, and the presenter should get the impression early on that the reviewer is synthesizing their comments as they move along rather than reaching into a bunch of small mental boxes for stock phrases to apply. Avoid platitudes; if all somebody wants is pat on the back, they won't ask for a critique, they'll ask you if and what you like about their piece. Terms like "good curve" don't offer much information to someone seeking to improve; discussing the speed and length of the curve in context of size, color, texture, and other parts of the piece plus its effectiveness in expressing mass, volumn or both, does help because it tells the presenter WHY the curve may be viewed as "good" so they can incorporate the crit into their working knowledge base.
A friendly or casual critique is way different from a teacher's analysis. "Teach" has spent many hours trying to pound certain principals through to the student. The teacher's crit is a vital teaching tool, and can, depending on the student, get rather brutal if it is to have real meaning.
Lastly, when at all possible, the discussion should end with a challenge, whether large or small, to incorporate some portions of the crit into the next piece.
>One thing I found when I first came across this site and posted a few of my first attempts was that I received valuable guidance and encouragement with the feedback I requested.
I try to look at every picture posted and when something catches my eye I save the picture and try to figure out what was it about the piece that draws me. As you all know there are many many fine pieces posted here. Some appeal to each person more than others. I remember one particular hollowform picture and as soon as I saw it my first thought was "perfect form". I don't know if it is appropriate to identify that piece or its creator but it is just an example of how critique can trigger the desire to improve.
I also like the idea that was mentioned of breaking it down into shape, sanding, finish, etc. I'm certain that approach would help me.
>Mark, as usual, you are right on. As Mark stated, he has critiqued several pieces of mine in the past. With thesaurus and dictionary in hand, I attempted to interpret the real meaning of Mark's critiques...and discovered a wealth of information.
When Mark asked WHY I made a piece with a certain curve or style of base, I really did not have an answer. " Seat of the pants" engineering I believe was my reply. After a few of these conversations, I realized that if I was to grow as a turner and "artist" I needed to seriously expand my knowledge of the principals of design. That took a good, long look at my design process. I needed to understand WHY things worked...and truthfully, I was embarassed about my lack of design knowledge.
Since these initial conversations, I have made a great attempt to bring myself up to speed by studying books on art, geometry, even physics. Each topic I studied was applied to my turning, if possible. I also visited places such as the Wharton Eschrick homestead (awesome), major craft shows, museums, just to expand my appreciation of form...again at Mark's suggestion.
I even started doing a demo on form and design based on what I learned....which has been so successful that I wrote an article on the subject,(coming soon) and was invited to present a demo on form and design at the national level. Just a few years ago, this type of demo would be unheard of.
As strange as it sounds, Mark's critiques, and those of turners such as David Ellsworth and Bin Pho, have had a tremendous impact on the direction of my turning career. All I had to do was listen.....Thank you, Mark.
>No "thank you" needed here. The greatest thanks possible is to see raw talent nudged a bit and then bloom. It's rare but immensly satisfying to be able to watch that happen and be able to say "Gee, maybe I did help that along in some small way" so Thank You, Keith, for the opportunity!
>Hi Ed, the next issue of woodturning design will carry the article I wrote on form and design...It's funny, I have gotten so much information from people such as Mark, yet my work looks nothing like theirs. I used the principles of design, which have been known for thousands of years, to base my work on. I think the bottom line is, if you are willing to use your imagination, and study and apply basic principles, then where is the need to copy others?