Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

apple vase

Posts

apple vase

#1

apple vase

DWFII

>Hey all,

I got on this forum several months ago (seems like) and asked a slew of questions about kelton Hollowing tools and turning an apple vase that I had already been working on for about a month. I just finished it...understand the I have a "real" job that takes up 40+ hours a week.

Its not perfect...the Kelton tools were a disaster for me and I ended up relying on the Sorby Hollowmaster and the Multi-tip tool. I have some (two?) tiny shallow "pits" inside...deep inside...from the Keltons (vibration, not catches) that I wasn't able to remove. But I finally did get it sanded inside to a real fine finish. Di9dn't apply any real finish to the inside but it is nearly as smooth and shiney with RenWax as the outside with MinWax Poly.

Overall, I'm pretty happy with it but would welcome any comments that might help me get better.

Apple or crabapple approx. 6" x 4" at widest and walls pretty uniform at 1/8" to 3/16" mouth 1 1/4"

hope this works...

And thanks to all who helped me!

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon


img

Re: apple vase

#2

Steven Antonucci

Mouth out of proportion?

steve antonucci

>My sister in law told me "SSN"- Say Something Nice, before you say something negative... so

I wish my finishing skills were as good as yours- you obviously spend a tremendous amount of time on finishing, and I applaud your effort...

The negative- It's my opinion that the mouth is "off"? Not sure if it's too tall or to wide relative to the foot, but it just looks unbalanced to me. I used my fingers to cover the left to right widenes and I thought it was better, but still kind of tall...

Take it for what it's worth- free advice is worth ten times what you pay for it...

Steve

Re: apple vase

#3

Re: Mouth out of proportion?

Ron Wilson

>I think it is outstanding as it is. Sit back and enjoy it!

Ron Wilson

Re: apple vase

#4

Re: apple vase

JKJ in East TN

>I like the classic pottery form - nice finish too. I think it would look great at my house with some bright and contrasting greenery/flowers.

JKJ

Re: apple vase

#5

Re: apple vase

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I think it looks great. No reservations about proportion from me, but everyone sees thinks differently.

Nice job.

Re: apple vase

#6

Looks Perfect To Me!!!

W.C. Turner

>I would be very pleased with your results.

Re: apple vase

#7

Re: apple vase

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>DW, I like this piece. It has good continuous curves from top to bottom. The proportions look just about right to me. Seems to have a good finish. Well done!

Wally

Re: apple vase

#8

Re: apple vase

Earl Eyre

>Looks good to me. I don't think you need to change a thing. The finish is great.

Everytime I see you tag line, I think we will have to meet some day. I'm also from the Oregon High Desert...just 100 miles south in Klamath Falls, at 4700 feet above sea level.

Earl

Re: apple vase

#9

Re: apple vase

Ad de Crom Netherlands

>DW, well proportioned vase, I like it a lot, great job

Re: apple vase

#10

David Barnett

Sweet, DW, but looks nothin' like an awl haft.

David Barnett

>

Re: apple vase

#11

Re: apple vase

DWFII

>Wow! Thanks for all the compliments and critiques. Unlike a most of the bowls that I have done previously, and despite my problems with the Keltons, I had a deliberate vision as I began and I think I came pretty close.

I'm not an artist. I really admire Molly and Mike and Wally and...well, I don't have a list handy but almost all of you for the really spectacular and creative ideas that I see posted here. So strictly from a craftsman's point of view, the curves and the proportions mean a lot to me--the difference between good and...worth a second look, maybe.

Thank you all for the help and an especial thanks to Russ Fairfield...I believe it was...who wrote an essay on classic proportions that lit a light bulb in my brain.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: apple vase

#12

Re: apple vase

Carole in VA

>I don't see a think wrong with the proportions on that vase! And if the inside is finished like the outside, all I can say is you are one patient (obsessed?) man! LOL Nice job.

Re: apple vase

#13

Re: apple vase

George Van in WI

>Looks great to me. The upper curve is a hard one to get right and you just did. I agree, a very good finish!

Re: apple vase

#15

Re: apple vase

Arch

>For me, it's the usual dilemma. D W asked for help in getting better, not for accolades, but accolades are implicit even in a request for an 'honest opinion' about anyone's work. Like Steve, I think the neck and mouth are perhaps disproportionate and being smaller might be an improvement. "I think" and "improvement" are subjective and are true only in my less than educated sight, so I hesitate to write this in face of positive opinions by much better turners than I. Especially when the overall turning and finish is well done and most attractive.

In summary then, The vase is a very pleasing object. If the turner's experience and state of progress is not in the equation, then in an effort to help I suggest that the mouth and neck could be a tad smaller. IMHO, IMHO, IMHO, IMHO_______just IMHO!, Arch

Re: apple vase

#16

Re: apple vase

DWFII

>Steve and Arch,

I take your point and thank you for expressing it. I can see that the lip may be too wide for the rest of the vase. It didn't seem so when I was turning and finishing it but I could imagine it being smaller with no adverse affects.

The throat is another matter. Despite having a caliper I was shaking like a leaf in the final stages of cutting the throat. I knew I needed the curves to be just so on the outside but the necessities of trying to get the "dangerous" end of the Sorby MultiTip tool into the vase required that the opening--the "mouth"--be no smaller than it is. As it was I never tried to put the tool in the vase while the piece was turning...or take it out either. It was that close.

So...given the relative thinness of the walls and the relative eveness of that thickness, I couldn't take the throat down much more and retain the even curve without risking (in my mind) going through the side.

It's an interesting discussion and perhaps if I had had enough sense to purchase the "heavy" Keltons" instead of the lightweight ones I might not have had the same problems. As it is I'm ready to sell my Kelton set. Anybody interested? Driven very rarely and only on Sundays.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: apple vase

#17

Kelton's

TD

>DW, I too started hollowing with Kelton's. I bought the set used because the original owner hated it. I have the big set with the frame. What I found out was that the Keltons are very good with some shapes and woods but not very good on others. I now have the Jamieson rig with the extra heavy bar, the Sorby armbrace, the Don Pencil armbrace and the Lissi Oland tools. I use them all. Each one has unique abilities. The Jamieson works great and is fast and safe but I cannot get a tight turn from it. Up near the top where I want a right angle I go to the Sorby or the Don Pencil set but never if I have the wood mounted on a faceplate. I will not use the armbrace on wood that is mounted to a faceplate as I see a strong potential for a broken arm. I do use the armbrace if the turning is held in my chuck jaws. In my experience if the tool hangs up (and it will) the wood is easily pulled out of the chuck. I would rather lose the piece of wood than the use of my arm for 3 months. If you have only one hollowing tool just limit shapes to what you can do with what you have. Pushing tools beyond their limits is what gets most people hurt.

TD

Re: apple vase

#18

Re: Kelton's

George Van in WI

>Terry is it possible to use the Pencil or Sorby in your captured rigs or is this where the limitations on tight curves occur? Thanks for the safety comments on the arm brace. I am just starting hollowing and that is a great tip.

Re: apple vase

#19

Re: Kelton's

TD

>George, it would be possible to use the cutting tips from the Pencil in my Jamieson as they are both made to take the same tools and holders but the frame on my Jamieson doesn't let me get far enough to the right so I have to go freehand. All of this only applies to the top of a flat topped vessel. I will post a picture shortly of what I am talking about. Look for a new heading.

TD

Re: apple vase

#20

Re: Sweet, DW, but looks nothin' like an awl haft.

DWFII

>David,

How did you know about...where did you see...my awl hafts?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: apple vase

#21

David Barnett

I never forget a good hand tool, DW. *LINK*

David Barnett

>Bocote, tapered brass ferrule, CC/HCC, '02.

I'm a long-time fan, Crispin Colloquy lurker and cordwainer wannabe who's copied that pattern for gravers and scribes (has heft, is superbly comfortable, protects the delicate nerves in the palm, and it's pretty, too).


Bocote awl haft

Re: apple vase

#22

Steven Antonucci

I did some research today

steve antonucci

>I thought about how many people told me I was "wrong" and I began to believe it... Then I realized I had offered my opinion and I couldn't be ;-)

So here's what I found out, and how the light went on: I googled (yes, it is a verb!) for classic greek forms of that style and type, and more often than not, they have feet! That's what I think is missing. In most of the pictures (after 12 million hits for "Ode to a Grecian Urn, and the bad puns (What's a Grecian Urn? About 3 Drachma!)), the bottom of your vessel would flow back out to a complementary foot to match the neck. It added the width that I thought was missing, and "looked right".

Often as my own worst critic, I can usually find enough fault with my own stuff to avoid needing any help. Thanks for starting a very good discussion.

Steve

Re: apple vase

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: apple vase

Keith Tompkins

>Hi DW, judging by number of hits, it looks like you have a winner. The profile of the piece flows, with no flat spots. I think the size of the rim/neck is a matter of taste. I think by experimenting with practice pieces, you will get a better feeling of what you like in a turning....a couple of pieces sitting on a window sill where you see them every day will be useful. Some shapes will grow on you, some won't. You may get ideas just by studying these pieces. Make sketches...that is a great tool. I think you've got the hang of it!