Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

WC vs. WoW

Posts

WC vs. WoW

#1

Keith Tompkins

WC vs. WoW

Keith Tompkins

>Concerning the WC and WoW sites, I don't feel there is any need of compariton. While they are both wonderful sites, they have distinctly different personalities.

To me, Wood Central is a special place...I have become acquainted with many turners on this site through their posts, and as I began to count the number of turners I have actually met, I stopped counting at fifty...and hadn't come close to naming them all. I have formed many special friendships here. There are a number of people I have yet to meet....And I know it will be a great time!

This is not just a "faceless" website. Behind each name is a dedicated and talented turner. Almost all are ready to help answer any question someone may field. Many people comment that they are amazed that more "flaming" doesn't occur....such as occurs on other sites. The reason is simple ...we are among friends. Plus, as I have mentioned before, we all have a common interest. Instead of focusing on our differences, which may be many, we can unite in our passion for turning.

I have watched this site grow and change under Russ's guidance into possibly the best turning site of all. I cannot begin to list the amount of information and insight I've gained through this site. Tips on finishing, sharpening, technique, and form are freely given. Photograqhing your work, too! (keep those coming) We have enjoyed many stimulating conversations here. I think it is much easier for a newbie or beginner to post work on WC than on WoW. I can't think of a time when the answers were not aimed at reassuring the person who posted, and the answers are positive and non-intimidating.

The WoW site is the result of much hard work also. The format is different, photos of your work may be posted in a permanent file. Much Like WC, you can post a photo of your work and ask for a critique....You must provide your name (sorry, no lurkers) for all the world to see. There are many well known turners worldwide who post their work on WoW. Going through the various turners work is overwhelming.

If you REALLY want to see how your work measures up, post a photo of your work there, and ask for a critique. You WILL get an honest unvarnished opinion of your work with suggestions on improving. BTW, if you feel that attending a demo give you the right to copy someone elses work...I would suggest not posting a photo of such a piece on WoW. The reaction of the turning world will be swift.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#2

Re: WC vs. WoW

Bruce Wiseman

>Man Keith I thought you post would light up the board. I am surprised it hasn't. I for one don't spend much time over at WOW anymore. The biggest reason is time. How do folks keep up on all the various sites and still have time to turn? But secondly, I never really feel completely comfortable over there. I'm sure it is me.I know it is probably just a projection on my part but it always feels like I am Wayne or Garth and WOW is Alice Cooper...a big I'm not worthy; I'm not worthy. Other folks mileage may vary. It's what makes horse races or more than one web site for us to visit.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#3

Re: WC vs. WoW

Stephen Mushinski

>Keith, I agree about them being different. I do think the people are pretty much the same as many of us use both. The biggest difference is the photo ablums. The WOW photo ablum setup is the best anyone could ever ask for when it comes to getting ideas and forms. Now about posting something that might be a copy of someones work, I see people get upset mostly when it has been sold or is in a gallery to be sold. There are a few that are touchy about not mentioning who might have made the first one. Sometimes I think it is funny as a ton of the woodturning work that is deemed his or her work is just copies of glass, pottery or another material. Kind of like the Microsoft taking ideas and software from others but damit do not copy my software.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#4

Re: WC vs. WoW

John Lucas

>Keith I just feel more comfortable here. I have a lot of short breaks at work between photo assignments and processing runs so can spend a few minutes here and there lurking at all the wood sites. It often takes me too long on WOW to get through all the stuff and participate. This site seems to run faster for me but mostly I just feel closer to all the folks on this site.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#5

Re: WC vs. WoW

RussFairfield

>A lot of woodturners say they see WOW as a gallery for the luminaries, AAW Directors, and assorted experts who have gravitated to that forum.

These same folks see Wood Central as a forum of the "common folk". That too may be changing.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#6

Let`s hope not

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>

Re: WC vs. WoW

#7

Re: WC vs. WoW *LINK*

joaz

>I have been a member of the WOW site for many years as well as this one and I must say WC is much more folksy and fun. WOW can be a bit stuffy and sometime(as in the last couple of days) boring and not much happening. I do like there photo storage capabilities.

Sometimes the critiques and comments can get a little high brow!


http://www.maine-web.com/woodturning

Re: WC vs. WoW

#8

Re: Now Russ, that's a little ..

JamieDonaldson

>... bit of the "fallacy of the glittering generality" as we used to say in logic debates. Both sites have a personality, and I don't mean specific people, but I enjoy both sites for differing reasons. WOW is more photo illustrated as a basis of discussion, but I wouldn't be disappointed to see more photos posted here. This WC gang is real people who like to talk and turn, while WOW is a little more oriented toward looking at and talking about turning. Elitism SHOULD have no place in this discussion, but the WOW gang does have some heavy hitters that pop up occasionally, and that adds spice to the stew.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#9

Create a Turning Gallery on WC?

Garrett in Victoria

>Turning has a requirement for visuals that is peculiar to the craft.

If there's enough interest, I'd be glad to discuss with Ellis how we might create such a gallery in the Article & Reviews Department here on WoodCentral. The objective would be to preserve quality pieces for posterity, rules and criteria for selection to be determined.

To that end, let me take small poll. Just respond to this post with a yea - or nay if you feel that way - in the subject line. If more than 25 positives come in within the week, I'll engage gears with no promises of outcome.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: WC vs. WoW

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Create a Turning Gallery on WC?

Keith Tompkins

>why not? sounds good to me....

Re: WC vs. WoW

#11

Re: Create a Turning Gallery on WC?

Joe Flemig

>NO!! As someone mentioned in this thread that they don't have time to keep up with all the different internet groups. With yet another picture forum, we would have another photo gallery to review and the likelihood that we would see the same photo multiple times. That happens a lot already.

Personally, I would rather have one place for photos: WOW. One place for turning talk: WC. One place for free-for-all: rec.crafts.woodturning. As it is now, conversations and advise are fractured. Many posters post the same questions on multiple sites which gets too many different threads going. Then, if you don't read all of them, you won't get the total collective wisdom - only a subset.

There has been a discussion over on WOW about the problem of not enough people posting comments and discussions. More sites means less and fractured participation by any one person.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#12

Re: Create a Turning Gallery on WC?

JamieDonaldson

>It is difficult to follow threads here on WC because of the scrolling format- you really have to look a while to find posts made over a period of time, and the continuity is easily lost. Creating a gallery might work as a reference, but I don't expect it to be very timely as a resource.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#13

Re: Create a Turning Gallery on WC?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree with both Joe and Jamie. WoW is a site that was made for photos first and discussions that follow. WC is a discussion oriented site. Let's keep it that way.

Wally

Re: WC vs. WoW

#14

Re: Create a Turning Gallery on WC?

RussFairfield

>Ellis has talked about this before, so it is appropriate to discuss it now.

Would this be a juried gallery of the best photos submitted, or would it be another place for everyone to have individual albums?

There might be some merit to a juried gallery to preserve the pictures that have been posted. I think they are now being dumped after some period of time.

I can't support starting an individual gallery because WOW is already doing that very well and serving almost the same group of woodturners. Add to that the photo albums on the AAW site, a couple places on Yahoo, and who knows where else, that are already out there. What purpose would be served with another??

I am wondering if the ideal situation wouldn't be a marriage, or other cooperation, between Wood Central and WOW. That way we would have the best features of both sites in one place.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#15

Re: Create a Turning Gallery on WC?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I'm with the "no" crowd on this one. WOW, and the more available AAW forum (www.woodturner.org) both have photo storage capabilities. I like the WOW gallery because it is private, and I like the AAW one because I can send potential customers, relatives, friends, etc.. there and they can access the photos without needing an account. I like WC because without the photos, more discussion is generated. ALSO, both sides of education, teaching AND learning, are done differently when a photo is not the primary subject being discussed. Both have their place, and I like them both.

If you want a photo published, we have "Shop Shots", which the turning crowd traditionally eschews for some reason, but neaderthals and power tool folks take to readily. There are almost no shop shots of turnings. Why do you think that is the case? I don't know either.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#16

Re: WC vs. WoW

Jim King

>I would just like to thank both Ellis and Herm for the sites. They have helped a lot of people.

Re: WC vs. WoW

#17

Message(s) Received Loud & Clear. No Gallery.

Garrett in Victoria

>