Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Am I dune this right?

Posts

Am I dune this right?

#1

Am I dune this right?

David Breth

>I'm making a coin bank for my son. I've been planning this one in my head for awhile, and so far it is working out ok, but I had a question to determine if I just sealed my fate in the way I did some glueing.

I turned a cylinder (more or less), put tenons on both ends, parted it in half, and hollowed out the middles of the two sections, leaving room for a hole & cork in the bottom and a slot in the top. I didn't get real aggressive with the wall thickness because I didn't want the pieces to hold roundness to the greatest extent, and wanted to allow for errors when I'm turning the final piece. I left the walls at roughly 5/16ish. When I glued, I left the tenon on the side that will have the hole & cork.

To prep for glueing, I used flat surfaces - not a "step" like you would have with a fitted box top, and I trued them quite flat before they came off the lathe. I used Elmers wood glue (yellow glue), running a small bead on both pieces, stuck them together, twisted them together to get good contact (they were adhering well almost immediately and were difficult to twist). I would have clamped it all together had my clamps been big enough, so instead I put a block of cherry on top and then about twenty pounds worth of dumbells. Glue only leaked out on one side a little bit, as I ran the beads closer to the interior than the exterior.

Tonight, I'll finish turn it and that will be that.

So, the questions: Was a "yellow glue" an appropriate choice? Was the use of flat surfaces (a 5/16" wall) good method, or should I have used a stepped arrangement ala a fitted box top? I think the method I used gives more surface area that I can be certain is in contact, but would be interested in your thoughts. This is the first piece I've cut/glued back together.

David B.

Re: Am I dune this right?

#2

Re: Am I dune this right?

John Lucas

>David If it was long grain to long grain you should be fine. If it was end grain to end grain you might be asking for trouble. I usually put a step in when I glue up something like that but it's mostly for alignment sake. It it's end grain to endgrain the step is necessary to give you more glue surface and also some side grain to side grain glueing surface.

Re: Am I dune this right?

#3

Re: Am I dune this right?

David Breth

>To which I can only say, Ooops. End grain to end grain. I will say this - it is thorn apple, and the end grain is presenting a very, very smooth surface.

Re: Am I dune this right?

#4

You might be OK

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Generally the advice is just as John stated - end grain joints aren't as strong as long grain. That said, I have made many many cutting boards with hundreds of end grain joints, not a single one has come apart. The surfaces were all very flat, joined well together, and I used Titebond white and yellow glues, with lots and lots of clamping pressure. The only one that ever failed was done with Gorilla glue.

Today's glues are amazing. I wouldn't fret so much, but I wouldn't do it exactly the same way next time, especially since matching mortise and tenon joints are so easy to produce on a lathe.

Re: Am I dune this right?

#5

Re: You might be OK

John Lucas

>David I just made 20 2 part ornaments. All had endgrain joints, no rabbits or steps, and the wall thickness at the glue joint was less than 1/4". All held. I was using CA glue however. White or yellow glue has a tendencey to penetrate the grain and starve the joint. When I do this I but glue on the joint and let it dry for a few minutes and then apply more and put it together.

Re: Am I dune this right?

#6

Re: You might be OK

David Breth

>Thanks for the input - I'm planning to post some pictures of completed items fairly soon, to show the direct results of advice I've received here, and/or to give updates on particular things I've posted about. This bank will be one of them, provided it doesn't become two cups with a lot of dents on the sides....

David B.

Re: Am I dune this right?

#7

Re: Am I dune this right? *LINK*

Rick Allen

>What done is done.

For your furture file:

If you size the endgrain glue surfaces first (a mix of yellow wood glue and watter (50/50) and let that dry (20 minutes or more). Then apply a bead of yellow glue on one surface. Twist the joint together back and forth. As you do this twisting you will notice that it becomes more and more dificult. At some point you will know that there isn't much more twisting you can do. Line up your joint and leave it. That will be a very strong glue joint.

What happens is the watered down glue will prevent the endgrain from absorbing all the glue in the joint. The twisting will cause the glue to foem long strings which will extend the glue into the endgrain of each surface.

I took a workshop with Michael Hosaluk making his "worm" box. That is the way the endgrain pieces were glued together.


Look at the "Fat Bumpy Eels" and the "Tiger Horn"