Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

Posts

New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#1

New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

Frank Martin

>It's time to replace my trusty Sorby 1/2 inch bowl gouge with Ellsworth Grind (not much flute left). I've been happy with the Sorby, but before picking up another, thought I'd pose the question here. Is there another brand that is clearly better I should go with?

have always heard about the Glaser's, but trickier to sharpen?

Crown Pro PM?

Henry Taylor?

thanks for any input.

frank

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#2

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I don't like the bigger Glasers. The flute design prohibits the curved cutting edge profile that is required for the "Terry Daniels cut". I'll show you what I mean at our meeting. I think they have a Glaser at Woodcraft.

Not sure about the smaller ones, as I wasn't looking for a smaller gouge.

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#3

Stay with the one you brought..

TD

>Frank, there is a lot more to a gouge than price and edge retention; flute shape, chip ejection, balance point, polish or finish, and the list goes on. I have tried most brands and I prefer the Sorby. A close second is the One-way. I do not care for the powdered metal gouges. If I honed my gouges I might choose another brand, not sure. For me an edge with "bite" cuts faster than a refined edge on most woods. Sorby is a good product for the way I turn. For those who cut with the tip of the gouge instead of the side there are better choices.

TD

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#4

Re: Stay with the one you brought..

George Van in WI

>Frank, I would agree with Mike and Terry, I have tried others also and find the V flute troublesome for chip ejection and getting the edge profile I was taught by the above. I Use the Sorby 1/2" and the Oneway 5/8", both are the same diameter. I thought the Oneway would last longer between grinds but I cannot support this from my experience.

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#5

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

Rick Allen

>The Sorby has a big "U" shape to the flute. Many others have a "V" shaped flute. If you have worn out a Sorby then chances are you have become acustom to that "U" shape. If I had worn out a bowl gouge I would almost certinaly replace it with one of the same flute shape.

I have several bowl gouges and I much prefer the "V" shaped flute. The "U" shape is more dificult for me to control when making a light finish cut. I don't care for the finish left from shear scraping so I like to have a clean finish cut. The Sorby doesn't let me do that. I have become acustom to the "V" shaped flute on my bowl gouges.

I would check the flute shape on the Penn State gouge as that is the best price on a HSS bowl gouge I have seen.

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#6

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

George Van in WI

>If you buy a bowl gouge from Penn State be sure to ask for the new flute design as they have recently changed. The new flute is deeper than the old design. I felt their old shape was more like a detail gouge.

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#7

Thanks!

Frank Martin

>Thanks All! As always, good insights. Looks like I'll stick with the Sorby.

Frank

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#8

Extra Mileage

Gerry in Maryland

>Hey Frank,

If you remove the Sorby from the crappy wooden handle and use it in the Kelton handle that you got with your McNaughton Coring System you can get some extra mileage. I removed mine and can sharpen it with the Vari-Grind now.(The handle was getting in the way) Even if you don't want to use it as a gouge you can make the back end of the Sorby a 3 point tool or a scraper. (Man am I cheap!)

See you at the BAT Cave tonight..

Gerry

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#9

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

Bill Neddow

>That explains my experience. I picked up one of their bowl gouges, a 5/8th inch one, at the symposium in Albany this fall. For $20 I figured I could not go wrong, even if my wife ended up using it for digging dandelions. As it turned out, all it needed was a proper sharpening and it is in a rotation now with a OneWay, Sorby, Henry Taylor and P&N. I use them all until they are dull, then make one trip to the grinder. All last about the same amount of time, and cut equally well. So I looked into getting a 1/2". Jacques Coulombe is now carrying them in Canada. I looked at them at the Ottawa Wood Show and found the 1/2" was not a bowl gouge. The flute was way too shallow. But I bought it anyway and use it as a detail gouge. Glad to hear they have changed the flute. I will be on the lookout for a 1/2" with the new flute. I also have a Hamlet 2060 that lasts longer than the rest, but I try not to keep it for roughing. If I use it for finishing, I tend to grind it just before the last cut on a bowl. Gives me a lovely finish -- but I am grinding away the harder steel when I could be getting some extra cutting out of it as a roughing gouge.

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#10

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand? *LINK*

albertabob

>Take a look at P&N in the Lee Valley catalogue.

It took me a couple of days to learn how to use it and refine the bevel to my liking but now I would not part with it.

It stays sharper longer too.

I also moved over to the P&N roughing gouge with pleasant results as well.

Bob


http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=49138&cat=1,330

Re: New Bowl Gouge - what brand?

#11

Roger Dunn

I second Bob's vote for P&N

Roger Dunn

>