Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

More art and plagiarism

Posts

More art and plagiarism

#1

Keith Tompkins

More art and plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>Just when you thought it was finally over.. :)

A few thoughts on the subject...when I do a demo or class, I like to stress the importance of understanding design principles. Here are a few reasons...Most turners attend sessions held by "known" turners whose contributions are well respected. I think many people leave with the idea of "borrowing" these newly learned techniques, and applying them in their new work. The problem is many emulate the techniques without fulling understanding WHY the technique works, or without having a good foundation or understanding of form or design. The result is, in too many cases, a highly decorated, poorly executed form. It doesn't work too well, and the turner can't understand why his pieces don't look like "turner X"s" work, who just charged him big bucks to learn the latest technique.

While it's great to learn from the masters, it's much more important to learn fundamental form principles first. By studying, understanding and applying these principles, a turner won't need to rely on someone else's "secrets" in order to advance. Plus, they learn to trust their own instincts and will develop their own style much easier...they won't be limited to copying what others do. They will understand HOW and WHY good pieces work.

Personally, I try to avoid techniques commonly seen at shows...such as piercing. In my opinion, there are too many such pieces, and they all begin to look the same after a while. Only when I come up with something where piercing is really called for will I use it.

If this seems a bit hard to swallow, take a good, long look at Mr. Wally Dickerman's website. FORM, FORM, and more FORM. As good as it gets.....sorry Wally, I couldn't help it.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#2

Re: More art and plagiarism

Carole in VA

>I was looking at a magazine tonight and saw a lovely picture of a sea urchin type creature (no spines). A wonderful form provided by Mother Nature. I thought that I would like to turn one, carve it an texture it. I have not seen that done anywhere, but it is such a perfect form of nature that I'm sure someone, somewhere has done it. Will I be plagarizing?

Re: More art and plagiarism

#3

Re: More art and plagiarism

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Thanks Keith....I don't have a web site, so I assume that you're referring to my album on WoW. I have well over 100 pieces shown there.

Carole, Curves and forms copied from nature can be wonderful. Bill Neddow, one of the best bowl turners, bases some of his forms on the form of the small end of an egg.

Wally

Re: More art and plagiarism

#4

Re: More art and plagiarism

Carole in VA

>Wally, I have been trying to "exactly" duplicate an egg ever since I started turning (long before I ever heard of Bill.) It is surprising how difficult it is to get it perfect. It looks like such a simple form! But I suppose my continuing efforts are are not wasted...it's good practice.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#5

Re: More art and plagiarism

John Lucas

>It has been done before but I'll bet yours will be different if you explore it a little. Mike Lee from Hawaii had done so but they are his interpretation of the form not a copy. A lady from England or Scotland does wonderful work along this line and I can't think of her name right now. It has been done in clay and in glass. Don't worry about it. Do your own interpretation.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#6

Re: More art and plagiarism

John Lucas

>Keith I think John Jordan said it best. You just have to turn a lot. When you see a demo and want to use that technique go ahead and make piece like that person. then make another but think about how you would change it. Then make another and another etc. By the time you've made half a dozen you will have an idea of which direction you want to go with that piece. Then it will start to take on your personality instead of the being a copy of the demonstrators work.

If you buy the book 500 wood bowls. It's easy to get discouraged because you can find just about any possible technique and someone has already explored it. However Keith is right. If you try to understand why that person came up with that style then you will start to understand how you can use it and make it your own. Find a piece you like and build it. Then go back to what I said above and see where it takes you. That's how many of those pieces evolved. I photographed for 3 of the people in the book and I know that's how thier evolved.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#7

Re: More art and plagiarism

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>On the other hand. If you are charging people to teach them how to turn, and your techniques or whatever, than you shouldnt be surprised if they try to duplicate your work. I think that if you are teaching it for monet, than you are selling it.

Norm

Re: More art and plagiarism

#8

Plagiarizing Nature...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Plagiarizing nature seems to be totally acceptable.

At least I haven't heard of any complaints from upstairs...

Really, how can someone else legitimately complain if you use the same source for your inspiration?

Re: More art and plagiarism

#9

What comes first?

Ron in Drums PA

>So what comes first? Form or technique?

I would say you learn them both at the same time. You see a technique, you try to duplicate it, it comes out not quite the same, so you try another. Along the way you learn better how to handle your tools and with a little more confidence you try to refine your forms. You finish a turning, and In your mind's eye, you see a better shape. Now you return to the lathe and need to learn how to handle your tools to achieve that shape.

You finally get a shape you are proud of and then someone posts a picture of their newest turning, you love it and try to turn a similar form and the process starts all over again.

This isn't plagiarism. This is learning. If you sell a few pieces along the way that's great.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#10

Re: More art and plagiarism

Arch

>Keith, FWIW (not much) I don't worry about plagiary stopping the free exchange of information that's so characteristic of our craft. I think woodturning blossomed and matured when 'secrets' began to be widely shared. Certainly the stature of turned wood objects increased, as did their value.

A strained analogy: Currently, there is much ado about transplanting or making a new human face. Technique concerns crafting the face. (Surgery is craft) I think art and therefore plagiary, concerns nuances. There are billions of faces, but we can recognize each as a separate creation. Piercing a wood bowl or dimpling a chin involves technique, but any 'beauty' inherent in each is art and that isn't likely to be plagiarized by a Copier, although possibly expanded and improved upon by a budding artist.

I see no problem in anyone learning and using techniques and the principles of form and design. The original pierced bowls and inverted cone candlesticks won't hear footsteps so long as they remain more appealing. If and when someone should make better ones, that might be plagiary or it might be new art using the same old techniques that everyone was entitled to and is now. It's not the holes, cones and chin dimples, it's what's done with them. Instead of detracting, the bad work probably highlights and enhances the good, at least with those who matter.

Let the flames begin; flameing is an old technique, the internet made it art! :)

Re: More art and plagiarism

#11

Re: More art and plagiarism

Bill Neddow

>Boy, Keith, do I ever agree with you. The fundamental basics are so important, as is form.

Of course, Wally's work is prime example of good form. But also look at the work of the turners who are into a lot of post turning enhancements. Under the colour, pyrography and carving of people like Andi Wolfe, Art Liestman and Al Stirt, you will find perfect form. That is why their enhancements work so well.

I do not consider using shapes from nature a form of plagarism. We will adapt the forms, depending on our interests and skills. And the forth or fifth time we make something, we will have adapted it enough to make it our own. That is why tuning a lot is important.

Also important is learning new techniques -- and making them your own. Both Andi and Art use Prismacolor pens for coloring some of their work. But the approach, techniques and end results are dramatically different, and in both cases, quite spectacular.

Like Keith, I think the post turning enhancement has to add something. I learned gold leafing from a very good specialist a couple of years ago. I was all excited, thinking I could really give my bowls that added "wow" factor. I tried it on rims, on beads, etc. And in the end, I sanded it all off. It did not really seem to belong. Then recently I got the idea of producing and egg shell left behind by the goose that laid the golden egg. Here, the gold leafing was necessary, and really worked well. Without it, the bowl loses its meaning. There is a picture of it over at WOW. I would have posted it here, only I have never been successful in posting pictures to this site.

Wally, I appreciate your comments, though I doubt I deserve them. What the "small end of egg" bowl concept proves is that inspiration is all around us. All we have to do is open our eyes. Of course, I can't clalim much credit for open eyes. I have been staring, half asleep, at the ends of boiled eggs every morning for almost 65 years. And only once, did my brain click into gear and say: "Hey -- that's interesting!"

Re: More art and plagiarism

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: More art and plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Arch, no flames from me...you may really be attracted to a form such as piercing, and take it to a new, higher level. That would be awesome..nothing wrong with that!

Re: More art and plagiarism

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: More art and plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>Yes, that's it. Sorry again. Maybe you SHOULD make a website!

Re: More art and plagiarism

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: What comes first?

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Ron, We agree. I think they should be learned together. Some people teach to use scrapers for all work in the beginning. Some say don't worry about form, that will come later. Usually it doesn't happen that way. In fact, bad habits learned in the beginning are hard to break, and many turners almost have to start over. Good tool technique and good design right from the beginning. When I teach, I will show a cutting technique with a gouge or skew. When the going gets tough, the student often reaches for the scraper, a comfortable old friend. I gently pry it from their grip and give them back the tool that needs to be conquered. Teaching form is often more difficult..."I like my forms" or " that's my style" is hard to overcome. Sometimes folks refuse to see the problem with their work is a poor appreciation of form, not their technique....leaarning both from the beginning prevents these problems.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: More art and plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>Hi John, when I first started giving lessons, I was forced to study not only my pieces, but form in general. In that way, I could understand WHY some pieces were successful, and point out ways to improve one's work in an informed and intelligent manner.

A very big influence in my study of form as "art" would be Mark Mandell. He seemed to understand my work better than I did, and encouraged me to dig deeper into the "heady" stuff of turning. I never liked the term "let the wood speak to you" when teaching. Could you imagine a newbie standing at the lathe with an absolute blank expression on their face? :O If I provide the turner with a goal to strive for, it goes much easier.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: More art and plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>Carole, you are just getting inspiration from the world around you. Happens all the time. In my case, I wanted to duplicate the beauty of a rose blossom with a turning. (not a carving) It took over two years to figure out a way to do it that I was happy with. I am now constantly refining the technique. No, my rose doesn't even come close, sadly enough. Working on another unrelated piece led to the method I use for the rose...one thing always leads to another.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: More art and plagiarism

Keith Tompkins

>Norm, I think there is a fine line here. Like I said earlier, what good does it do to merely copy another's work? Really not much personal satisfaction in that. However, to use a lesson as an influence to improve your work is a good thing.

A good example of this is: I taught my son to play guitar. By age 10 he had absorbed all I had to offer, and we got him professional lessons...his ability far exceeded mine. If he mere emulated me, his playing would have been severely stunted. ...stuck at one level.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#18

Copying can be good

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>I recently taught an advanced class on plates and platters and one of the exercises was for the students to bring in a plate from home and either copy it or use it as a baseline to improve upon.

All the students had been thru intro,spindles,bowls 1 and 2(most with me) and knew the cuts and were to the point where they"Handled the tools with authority".Those who had taken the bowl turning courses with me had already been exposed to good form and good design concepts.

It was interresting to hear that the students thought the copy/redesign exercise was the one they found most challenging and also the one they enjoyed the most.One of the reasons they enjoyed it was because they all had enough experience to be able to turn without thinking too much about the cuts.Another reason was because they all had a pre-determined goal(determined from thier baseline object) to reach for and the skills to get there thru applying what they had learned/practiced up to that point.

I found it very enjoyable because all I did was throw out possibilities during the design phase and then remind them how to do the things they already knew.

BTW-Critiques done by thier peers(after proper instruction on how to properly and constructively critique)followed each exercise in the classes and the students felt that`s where the most personal growth came from.

Mainely,Bob

Re: More art and plagiarism

#19

If you teach only technique

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Chances are you`re just teaching someone how to make ugly pieces more efficiently/quickly.

I can`t picture taking money to do that.

MB

Re: More art and plagiarism

#20

Re: If you teach only technique

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Bob, I would go one step further and say that if you teach only technique, the student will often revert to his or her old techniques and still not make ugly forms efficiently! I was teaching a class yesterday, and discussing bowl forms with a previous student. He made the comment that as he compared bowls we had done in a previous class with bowls he had made since, he had come to realize that the forms he was turning were what was giving him the problem, and he was working on getting back to what we had discussed on forms. Specifically, it was the "straight side flat bottom trouble with the corner" stuff that I see over and over again with bowls. I do think technique has to come first, but form has to be right on its heels, virtually in the same sentence.

To go to something Keith mentioned, in this same class, he had a decent hollow form going (even though we were talking about bowls, it was a hollow form class), but it needed to be smoothed out on the surface some. I took his tool from him and said, "I almost hate to show you this because when I show it to people they want to use it for the whole shaping process!" It was a shear scrape to clean up all those bumps, and while a very valuable technique, people have a tendency to go with something easy, epsecially when there is stress involved (like the instuctor leaning over the lathe). ;-)

Bill

Re: More art and plagiarism

#21

Woodturning hurdles

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>One of the first big hoops I try to get students(and sometimes myself)to jump thru is the trap of getting the biggest bowl you can from a blank,especially a blank of exceptional wood.

This is the primary cause of the flat sides,flat bottom,corner in the bowl form.The sooner you can get your mind around the concept of getting the best bowl you can,regardless of size the quicker you will move into "Hitting the form" on a regular basis.

Another hurdle I try to get them to jump over right away is to release the death grip.Sometimes I wish I could do a John Jordan impression and turn using nothing more than my navel to guide the gouge.I bet THAT would convince them.

Mainely,Bob

Re: More art and plagiarism

#22

Re: More art and plagiarism

Frank in Mantua NJ

>I attended Penn. Acd. of art for 3 years as part of my studies I took a year of pottery classes, One of the things the instructor stated often is

There is not a shap that someone someplace has not already made in some form or another, so dont worrey about it. just make what comes to your mind. Then its original to you. after all Mother nature made the real originals anything else is copied from her.

Re: More art and plagiarism

#23

Re: More art and plagiarism

Frank in Mantua NJ

>I attended Penn. Acd. of art for 3 years as part of my studies I took a year of pottery classes, One of the things the instructor stated often is

There is not a shap that someone someplace has not already made in some form or another, so dont worrey about it. just make what comes to your mind. Then its original to you. after all Mother nature made the real originals anything else is copied from her.