Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Hard wood

Posts

Hard wood

#1

Hard wood

John Lucas

>I just turned the hardest piece of wood I've ever turned. It was oak. I've turned alot of oak and other woods much harder, Locust, Osage Orange, Pecan. Even with a freshly sharpened gouge I had trouble making light cuts. The tool would just skip off. I could force it to cut but only if I took off a moderate amount of wood. I finally got it shaped pretty close but had some tool marks and tearout. I decided I would sand it. It was so hard it actually dulled the sandpaper. I've never had a wood do that. It wasn't clogging the sandpaper which I though was happening. You could clean the sandpaper and it just would no longer cut. You could feel the difference with your finger. The sandpaper just didn't have an edge. I finally got the darn thing done. I would have thrown it out but it came from a tree that blew down in my Ex's yard and my son and I cut it up. I wanted to save a piece and turn it and give it to her for Christmas. I had rough turned this bowl and it wasn't hard when I rough turned it green but after 6 months drying it is the most dastardly would I have ever turned. Anyone else ever have this happen. I had some barnwood once that would dull a tool when making the first few cuts through the outside layer. I think this was due to sand in the wood. It cut fine after the first few cuts.

Re: Hard wood

#2

Re: Hard wood

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>I just turned a bowl from a piece of oak that had been sitting in a friend's backyard for about six months. I was like turning concrete. As with you, I had trouble making fine cuts, the tools just kept skipping across the surface. Finally got it done. Had some cracks that I sealed with CA glue and finished with Beal.

Biggest problem is that I now have a ton of this stuff!! :)

Hopefully, with more experience, it will get easier. Would it make a difference if this wood was really cold?

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: Hard wood

#3

Re: Hard wood

Bill Crommett

>John: which species of Oak was it ? I once turned some Live Oak from the coast that went easy when green, but became a tough nut to turn when dry. Live Oak (quercus Virginiana) is prized by ship builders because it is closed grain and therefore less subject to marine rot. A few years ago a construction site was cleared in coastal SC or GA and the timber was shipped to Mystic Seaport, CT to be used on one of the reconstructions of an ancient ship. Is this all OT or what ?

Re: Hard wood

#4

Re: Hard wood

Barry Turner

>I just turned a piece of cherry burl that I swear got much, much harder after it dried. I turned it green and wet and it turned normally.

But, when I went to engrave my name on the bottom with the Dremel vibrating engraver, it sounded like a wood pecker was at work. The hardened tip of the engraver just barely dented the wood. It was almost like the wood was case-hardened or something. Is this normal with cherry?

Re: Hard wood

#5

Re: Hard wood

John Lucas

>I'm not sure what it was. I think maybe White Oak because that's mostly what's around the other house. I tried shear scraping with a flat scraper. It knocked the burr of in about 2 inches of cutting. I can usually do 2 or 3 long passes on normal wood before having to resharpen.

Re: Hard wood

#6

Re: Hard wood

John Lucas

>Barry I've turned a fair amount of cherry, even some that in a barn for 100 years. I haven't had much problem with it.

Re: Hard wood

#7

Re: Hard wood

Carole in VA

>John, I have a bunch of local white oak. I don't like to turn it because I don't care for the gain so I use it as glue blocks. It's hard, but I have never come across any that was as hard as you have described. You DID have your lathe running in forward didn't you? ;))) Just kidding!

Re: Hard wood

#8

Re: Hard wood

Juergen

>John If I can't make any headway with skew or gouge I turn to my trusty scrapers. Works every time with Osage, Pecan, and Hard Exotics.

Re: Hard wood

#9

funny

John Lucas

>Ha, you've been reading my old posts.

Re: Hard wood

#10

Re: Hard wood

John Lucas

>My scrapers tore out the grain in this wood really badly. The only way they would work is in shear scraping mode, held at 45 degrees or greater. The burr would dull after just a couple of inches and then it only burninshed the wood.

Re: Hard wood

#11

Re: Hard wood

JKJ in East TN

>Yikes, almost sounds like hickory! Maybe someday we'll be able to sand with carbide or diamond paper.

I wonder if boiling very hard dry wood and turning it wet would work. Bruce Hoadley (in Identifying Wood) recommends boiling wood samples to soften them before slicing off sections for the microscope. I tried this yesterday with a hand full of various woods, and they were incredibly easier to slice with a razor blade.

JKJ

Re: Hard wood

#12

Re: Hard wood

Ron in Drums PA

>I was thinking the same thing, I have a hickory bowl that I just can't finish because of the hardness of the wood. 60 grit sandpaper just dulls when I try to sand out some tear outs.

Re: Hard wood

#13

Re: Hard wood

Jorge Castaneda

>John, I roughed an osage orage box a couple years ago, now I cannot make any toll bite on it, they just skate over it.

I am not giving up, I just need to find a way...

Jorge