Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Artists and giving credit to others

Posts

Artists and giving credit to others

#1

Artists and giving credit to others

Ron in Drums PA

>When an art student goes to school to better learn the art of painting, one of the first tasks that is set to them is to copy the masters. In large cities that have museums who display well-known artists, you will see students with easels copying masterpieces. This is accepted in the art world and in museums. Only after these students learn "the proper technique" then they can start using the skills they have acquired to create their own style. One�s own style does not come from thin air, it is something that is learned over the course of years by borrowing ideas from other artists.

Throughout the years there have been many movements in art, cubism, pointalism, romantic, renaissance and art nevo just to name a few. In each of these disciplines, you will find many artists categorized as having similar work. Many of these artists knew each other and copied from each other, some were good friends, others were heated enemies and others had something in-between.

Another example would be in the music world, if no one copied Halley And The Comets� style, they would have been the first and only rock and roll band.

The same thing is happening in wood turning, there are many styles out there that can be categorized as the same movement and from hundreds, if not thousands of turners there will emerge a few well-known names that will make it big. One hundred years from now no one will be asking if they were the first, but they will be acknowledged as the best.

In both the art and the music world, the well-known names have always expressed who has influenced them the most. Woodturners should do the same thing. I see nothing wrong borrowing ideas from the great, but one should always acknowledge how they where influenced. On the same token, if someone teaches their technique, they shouldn�t be surprised if the ones they influenced are using their acquired skills.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#2

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Michael Sinclair

>Ron

As far as I am concerned you have hit the nail on the head regarding this subject. I think this situation is relatively new to turning, unlike the painting artists who have had a couple of hundred years to come to terms with the fact that similar styles evolve in groups of artists.

Windsor chairs are obviously a design that has been copied over the years and market forces decide the price people will pay and this depends on the makers name and quality of work. I believe the same will apply to turned work.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#3

Don Pencil

I Agree but............

Don Pencil

>As I do not recall ever having seen it done, how does one give credit to another for influence of a particular piece of work?

If my work is being reviewed in print, I am giving a lecture, excepting an award, I am writing a article or book, making a video, or doing a demonstration, I can see where I have the oppertunity to give credit. Otherwise, how do I do this? Do I scribe or burn a credit line into the base of the work when I name, date, and sign the work? This could get a little wordy especially on a small piece.

And if I could and did do that, would someone coming later and doing that have to add another credit to me for my influence on their work.

Don

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#4

Ron, the unique part is......

TD

>the signature on the bottom. When you get really good at what you do people will already know who made the piece and they will look at the bottom for confirmation.

TD

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#5

Re: I Agree but............

Ron in Drums PA

>You're right...

I can't tell you how many times I have made something which I thought was unique only to hear someone else say "Boy, that's nice! it looks just like so-and-so's"

I was listening to an interview by Paul McCartney not to long ago. He gave a long list of people who has influenced him, but on his sheet music it says "Music By Paul McCartney" (at least since Lennon died)

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#6

Re: Ron, the unique part is......

Ron in Drums PA

>My point exactly.

Picasso has acknowledged who his influences where and most of us can tell a Picasso at a glance.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Keith Tompkins

>Good analogy, Ron. In music, we all get eight notes. Bach or Beetoven had the same basic eight notes to work with as we do today. Just these eight notes can be arranged in endless combinations. It's HOW they are arranged that makes a timeless masterpiece. A student of music could spend a lifetime studying the possibilities...and just scratch the surface.

A successful turning is not that different than a great song. Words such as balance, composition, emphasis, or harmony could easily be applied to both. Both require the same degree of skill and knowledge, the difference is one appeals to our sense of vision, the other appeals to our sense of hearing.

There are influential turners, there are influential musicians. The Beatles influenced how a whole generation of budding musicians. Many became technically much better musicians than the Beatles. Yet, if they attempted to gain acceptance by playing the Beatle's songs, it would never happen...even if they were vastly superior. They must find their own "voice" as well.

How many teenagers went out and purchased an electric guitar after hearing "Stairway to Heaven"? Millions. How many turners purchased an "Ellsworth Gouge" after watching him demonstrate it's effectivness? I have no idea, but the number is in the thousands.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#8

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Ron in Drums PA

>Here is a neat story

In 1962 Jagger, Jones, Richards, with drummer Tony Chapman cut a demo tape for EMI and was rejected. It was a song written by Paul McCartney.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#9

Re: I Agree but............

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>Don, I think the answer to your question is this: when an painter, muscian or other artist gives credit for influences to his/her work it is done either in print or verbally in public and not on their actual work. Don't see why it should be any different for woodturnings.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#10

Don Pencil

Re: I Agree but............

Don Pencil

>Thank you. That was exactly the point.

See, great minds do think alike. :)

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#11

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>It's frustrating when people come up with my ideas before I do......

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#12

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Anthony Y

>A few thoughts!

Many music stores have signs in them that say "NO Stairway"

Bill Haleys music was influenced by earlier blues and country players and he influenced others. In music it's ok to directly copy anothers music if you pay up, there are many cover bands out there that belong to the union, i.e. pay up. Paul McCartney was influenced by many but he didn't take Johnny B Good and put his name on it remember Queen/Vanila Ice.

I have taken bits of many peoples work and put then together to make "mine", I have also made direct copys of someones work that have never seen the light of day.

The Winsdor chair was not copied but passed down from master to aprentice.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#13

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Andi Wolfe

>"The Winsdor chair was not copied but passed down from master to aprentice."

That's an interesting observation, and it's interesting to note how different our North American culture is from other countries with regards to crafts. For example, many countries in Europe have extensive apprentice programs and exams to be passed before someone receives the label of "woodturner." Japan also has a system of apprenticing prior to someone earning the label.

Copying a "master's" designs in this system is required to learn and master the skills for creating objects. I suspect that the apprentice/journeyman probably needs to work out an agreement to make objects in the "master's" style once leaving the shop. In contrast, there are several turners on this forum who have expressed an opinion that if they buy a book, DVD, pay for a demo, etc., they have the "right" to "make" the object being shown.

I wonder if this difference stems from the differences in demographics between our cultures. For example, many turners in North America come into the hobby during retirement or after becoming financially secure enough to afford the hobby. The apprentice system in other countries is aimed at younger people aiming for a career in crafts.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#14

That raises a very good question

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>If a dozen people independently come up with the same idea, who "owns" it?

In areas covered by patent and copyright law the answer is fairly clear - the first person. BUT their ownership expires when the patent expires and then it is free for every one to use.

But those laws do not apply to woodturning (and most arts/crafts). And from what I've read, that exclusion is intentional.

So who "owns" a idea that is not covered by the legal system?

I would suggest that each person that independently comes up with the idea "owns" it.

Which really boils down to no one "owns" it.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#15

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Ron in Drums PA

>Good Point Andi

Rembrandt taught many students how to paint. While they where under his tutelage, every student�s piece that was approved by the Master has Rembrandt�s signature.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#16

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Carole in VA

>Amen, Russell! I figure no matter what I think of, if I search hard enough, I will find that someone, somewhere, sometime has probably done it before. ;)

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#17

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Ed Moore

>Andi,

I have not had the pleasure of attending one of your demonstrations, yet. Is there someone to whom you give credit or someone who influenced your work? Of course, since your distinctive work involves leaves, one could make a religious statement, but I am referring to woodturners in this case.

Ed Moore

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#18

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Matt Birchfield

>This is very frustrating...

I made my first tree topper ornament years ago.

My tree topper looks almost exactly like the one Bob Rosand wrote about in the AAW journal this fall. He didn't copy me, nor did he take credit for the idea in the article (if I remember correctly).

This is not the first time I've seen how-to articles published on turnings that I've developed on my own, or at least with similar influences as the author of the how-to article.

My point is this: If we associate with people that have similar interests, read the same magazines and books, belong to the same clubs, we may expect to develop ideas with similar outcomes. This is not copying. Be proud of your work when it is your work.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#19

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I suspect it is primarily a cultural thing.

We (the United States in particular) have a young and very diverse culture. Trade/craft guilds didn't get strongly established before the Industrial Revolution came along. Given the pioneer / frontier mind-set, guilds probably would have had a difficult time getting established until that mind-set faded.

This is just another aspect of how different our culture is from the older, more established cultures in Europe, Asia and the Middle East.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#20

Don Pencil

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Don Pencil

>I think that a simular argument would in the form on some sports.

If in baseball, tennis, or golf, someone comes up with a way to grip a bat, racket, or club, they will be on top. That is until the others figure out what they are doing and then they too will be using it.

I just do not think that it is possible to hold technique and style that close to the vest. Personally I would be flattered to see my style and technique were worthy of being copied. Were someone to copy an exact work and call it their own I would not be so thrilled.

As a general rule I believe all woodturners add a little something of there own to the piece. They are not trying to exactly replicate anothers work, just the style and technique.

I also believe that as a woodturner, with repitition, gains experience they will vary the style and technique, mixing it with other learned skills and develope their own styles.

Unless someone is passing their work off as someone elses, I'm not sure there is a issue here.

Don

WWW.DONPENCIL.COM

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#21

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Ron in Drums PA

>Bob Rosand was showing me how he turns his signature ornaments. I had finished one that I was pretty proud of the changes I made to his design. I showed him my accomplishment and he takes a look at it and says "Wow, wait a minute" he runs into his show room and comes back with another ornament and says "That is exacting the way I use to make them"

The two were identical.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#22

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Andi Wolfe

>Ed -

I always start one of my all-day demos with a powerpoint presentation on my design inspirations. In addition to pictures of plants, microscopic images of plant parts, scenery from my field work and the like, I also have a slide at the end that lists the other turners who have been inspirational to my work. This list includes: Jacques Vesery, Linda Behrens, Michelle Holzapfel, Ron Fleming, David Ellsworth, J. Paul Fennell, and Art Liestman.

My botanical inspirations flow naturally from my work as a botanist, but I'm certainly not the only turner who uses leaves or other inspirations from nature as surface enhancement motifs. However, what you can note is that the motifs I use and the way I implement them are very distinctive compared to the work of others. For example, no one would (or should) confuse my leaf motifs with those of Ron Fleming, Linda Behrens, or Michelle Holzapfel.

Jacques Vesery, Art Liestman, David Nittmann and I all use the same techniques (pyrography, transparent dyes, acrylic paints) to enhance the surfaces of our turnings. Again, no one would find our work difficult to distinguish, and yet we've all influenced one another through our interaction and sharing of techniques.

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#23

Thank you. All should read Andi's response.

Ed Moore

>Thank you, Andi.

As a former academic type myself, I strongly suspected that you were careful about giving credit where it was due. Having a presenter give credit or praise to another person never detracts from the occasion for me. But when I suspect that someone was slighted, I never seem to forget that oversight.

Your response to me was so well written that I wish it were placed in a more obvious location on Wood Central. In addition to being in line with what I say above, it shines a bright light on "making it your own" even if there are influences and similar techniques involved.

Thank you,

Ed

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#24

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>A lot of my work is done using the same form. Different heights, different widths etc, but still the same basic form. It seems to have become my signature form. I have no idea where I got it, it just seemed to develop a long time ago. A number of years ago, FWW ran an article featuring a gallery that sells my work. The front cover was a shot of the interior of the gallery. Way in the back, on a shelf, were two pieces that I recognized as mine. I was amazed when a number of people said to me "hey, I saw your pieces on the front cover of FWW". They had also recognized the forms as mine. Even though some people think of me when they see my forms, I certainly don't claim that I own them. In fact I find it flattering theat someone would copy them and give me credit.

When it comes to copying someone else's forms, I have trouble making exact copies of my own.

Wally

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

#25

Re: Artists and giving credit to others

Ron in Drums PA

>Bob Rosand has one of your pieces hanging on a wall Andi. If I remember correctly, he said it was a corroboration between you two. I instantly recognized it as your work.